Current systematic carbon cycle observations and needs for implementing a policy-relevant carbon observing system

Philippe Ciais, A. J. Dolman, Antonio Bombelli, Riley Duren, Anna Peregon, P. J. Rayner, Charles E. Miller, Nadine Gobron, G. Kinderman, Gregg Marland, Nicolas Gruber, Frédéric Chevallier, R. J. Andres, Gianpaolo Balsamo, Laurent Bopp, François‐Marie Bréon, Grégoire Broquet, Roger Dargaville, Tom J. Battin, Alberto Borges, H. Bovensmann, Michael Buchwitz, J. H. Butler, Josep G. Canadell, Robert B. Cook, Ruth DeFries, Richard Engelen, K. R. Gurney, Christoph Heinze, Martin Heimann, A. Held, Matieu Henry, B. E. Law, Sebastiaan Luyssaert, J. B. Miller, Takashi Moriyama, C. Moulin, Ranga B. Myneni, C. Nussli, Michael Obersteiner, Dennis S. Ojima, Yude Pan, Jean-Daniel Paris, Shilong Piao, Benjamin Poulter, Stephen Plummer, S. Quegan, Peter A. Raymond, Markus Reichstein, Léonard Rivier, Christopher L. Sabine, David Schimel, Oksana Tarasova, Riccardo Valentini, Guido R. van der Werf, D. E. Wickland, Mike Williams, Claus Zehner2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues for a comprehensive, globally integrated carbon observation system to better understand and manage the carbon cycle. It outlines the current state of observations across land, ocean, and atmosphere, highlighting significant gaps and proposing a roadmap for a policy-relevant system by 2020, emphasizing the need for denser, more accurate, and sustained data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the critical need for a robust, globally integrated carbon observation system. Current efforts are described as "sparse, exploratory," and insufficient for accurately projecting future climate changes or verifying the effectiveness of mitigation policies. This lack of comprehensive data hinders our ability to understand the complex carbon cycle, attribute flux changes to specific processes, and make informed policy decisions. The authors highlight that existing inventories and observations have significant uncertainties, especially for remote regions and for distinguishing anthropogenic emissions from natural fluxes.

Methods

The paper doesn't present a single novel algorithm but rather synthesizes the current state of carbon cycle observation across various domains: land, ocean, and atmosphere. It reviews existing measurement techniques, including:

  • In situ measurements: Ground-based networks (flux towers, atmospheric stations, ocean moorings, hydrographic surveys), aircraft profiles.
  • Remote sensing: Satellite-based measurements of atmospheric composition (CO2, CH4), land cover, vegetation properties, ocean color, and surface temperature.
  • Data integration and modeling: The paper emphasizes the need for model-data fusion, data assimilation, and the development of consistent frameworks to combine diverse data streams. It discusses the importance of understanding and quantifying uncertainties in both observations and models.

Datasets

The paper references numerous existing datasets and data products, including:

  • Atmospheric: GLOBALVIEW, WMO GAW World Data Center, Total Carbon Column Observing Network (TCCON).
  • Oceanic: Surface Ocean CO2 Atlas (SOCAT), Global Ocean Flux Study (JGOFS), World Ocean Circulation Experiment (WOCE), GLODAP, CARINA, PACIFICA.
  • Terrestrial: FLUXNET, FAO Forest Resources Assessments, EDGAR, VULCAN, MODIS, Landsat, BIOMASS, various national forest inventories.

The paper does not introduce new datasets but rather advocates for their improved integration, accessibility, and quality.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Transformational Advance Needed: The current carbon observation framework is insufficient. A shift from sparse, exploratory efforts to a dense, robust, and sustained system is required across all components of the carbon cycle.
  • Remote Sensing is Crucial but Needs Ground Truthing: Satellites offer dense coverage and frequent revisits, essential for remote areas. However, their accuracy and long-term consistency need to be improved and rigorously validated against high-quality in situ data.
  • Fossil Fuel and Land Use Emissions are Key Challenges: Accurately constraining emissions from fossil fuel combustion and land-use change, especially at high spatial and temporal resolutions, is identified as the biggest hurdle for a policy-relevant system.
  • Integration is Paramount: No single observation type is sufficient. A balanced portfolio of observational techniques, leveraging the strengths of each and offsetting weaknesses, is essential. This includes integrating atmospheric, oceanic, terrestrial, and socioeconomic data.
  • Uncertainty Quantification is Non-Negotiable: All data products must be associated with robust uncertainty estimates, crucial for data assimilation and policy interpretation.
  • Policy Relevance Drives Requirements: The design of the observing system must be driven by the needs of policymakers, requiring clear, understandable, and actionable information.

Key Results

The paper's primary "result" is a comprehensive assessment of the current state of carbon cycle observations and a detailed articulation of the needs and requirements for a future global, policy-relevant carbon observing system. It identifies specific gaps in:

  • Spatial and Temporal Resolution: Many current observations lack the necessary resolution to attribute flux changes to specific processes or to monitor policy impacts at relevant scales (e.g., city-level).
  • Data Density: Remote regions (southern oceans, Arctic, tropical forests) and certain flux types are significantly under-sampled.
  • Consistency and Accuracy: Long-term consistency and accuracy of remote sensing data need improvement for effective model integration.
  • Data Integration and Accessibility: A lack of a single, harmonized system for data dissemination, archiving, and access hinders progress.

The paper proposes a phased deployment, with a first-generation demonstration system achievable within 3 years and a more comprehensive system by 2020, emphasizing the need for sustained funding and international collaboration.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • The paper acknowledges that the "carbon cycle does not operate in isolation" and is linked to other global cycles (water, nitrogen, etc.) and the climate system. While it states the importance of studying these, it explicitly limits its scope to the carbon cycle itself.
  • The paper notes that the "policy frameworks on how to manage the biospheric carbon cycle for GHG mitigation are still in a primordial state," making it difficult to define precise observational requirements for specific policy mechanisms.
  • The authors admit that the "cost of an adequately funded monitoring system with current technology will be assessed in a future study."

Future Work:

  • Develop transformational advances in observation technology and methods to achieve higher spatial and temporal resolution and density.
  • Improve the accuracy and long-term consistency of remote sensing measurements.
  • Establish robust data management and integration systems with open access and standardized protocols.
  • Foster international collaboration and sustained funding commitments.
  • Periodically re-evaluate end-user needs as policies evolve and our understanding of the carbon cycle deepens.
  • Focus on specific "hotspots" with high carbon reservoir vulnerability and potential for rapid change.
  • Develop more sophisticated data assimilation techniques and models to reconcile diverse data streams and quantify uncertainties.

Summary updated

Abstract

A globally integrated carbon observation and analysis system is needed to improve the fundamental understanding of the global carbon cycle, to improve our ability to project future changes, and to verify the effectiveness of policies aiming to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and increase carbon sequestration. Building an integrated carbon observation system requires transformational advances from the existing sparse, exploratory framework towards a dense, robust, and sustained system in all components: anthropogenic emissions, the atmosphere, the ocean, and the terrestrial biosphere. The goal of this study is to identify the current state of carbon observations and needs for a global integrated carbon observation system that can be built in the next decade. A key conclusion is the substantial expansion (by several orders of magnitude) of the ground-based observation networks required to reach the high spatial resolution for CO2 and CH4 fluxes, and for carbon stocks for addressing policy relevant objectives, and attributing flux changes to underlying processes in each region. In order to establish flux and stock diagnostics over remote areas such as the southern oceans, tropical forests and the Arctic, in situ observations will have to be complemented with remote-sensing measurements. Remote sensing offers the advantage of dense spatial coverage and frequent revisit. A key challenge is to bring remote sensing measurements to a level of long-term consistency and accuracy so that they can be efficiently combined in models to reduce uncertainties, in synergy with ground-based data. Bringing tight observational constraints on fossil fuel and land use change emissions will be the biggest challenge for deployment of a policy-relevant integrated carbon observation system. This will require in-situ and remotely sensed data at much higher resolution and density than currently achieved for natural fluxes, although over a small land area (cities, industrial sites, power plants), as well as the inclusion of fossil fuel CO2 proxy measurements such as radiocarbon in CO2 and carbon-fuel combustion tracers. Additionally, a policy relevant carbon monitoring system should also provide mechanisms for reconciling regional top-down (atmosphere-based) and bottom-up (surface-based) flux estimates across the range of spatial and temporal scales relevant to mitigation policies. The success of the system will rely on long-term commitments to monitoring, on improved international collaboration to fill gaps in the current observations, on sustained efforts to improve access to the different data streams and make databases inter-operable, and on the calibration of each component of the system to agreed-upon international scales.
BibTeX
@misc{ciais2013current,
  author = {Philippe Ciais and A. J. Dolman and Antonio Bombelli and Riley Duren and Anna Peregon and P. J. Rayner and Charles E. Miller and Nadine Gobron and G. Kinderman and Gregg Marland and Nicolas Gruber and Frédéric Chevallier and R. J. Andres and Gianpaolo Balsamo and Laurent Bopp and François‐Marie Bréon and Grégoire Broquet and Roger Dargaville and Tom J. Battin and Alberto Borges and H. Bovensmann and Michael Buchwitz and J. H. Butler and Josep G. Canadell and Robert B. Cook and Ruth DeFries and Richard Engelen and K. R. Gurney and Christoph Heinze and Martin Heimann and A. Held and Matieu Henry and B. E. Law and Sebastiaan Luyssaert and J. B. Miller and Takashi Moriyama and C. Moulin and Ranga B. Myneni and C. Nussli and Michael Obersteiner and Dennis S. Ojima and Yude Pan and Jean-Daniel Paris and Shilong Piao and Benjamin Poulter and Stephen Plummer and S. Quegan and Peter A. Raymond and Markus Reichstein and Léonard Rivier and Christopher L. Sabine and David Schimel and Oksana Tarasova and Riccardo Valentini and Guido R. van der Werf and D. E. Wickland and Mike Williams and Claus Zehner},
  title = {{Current systematic carbon cycle observations and needs for implementing a policy-relevant carbon observing system}},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.5194/bgd-10-11447-2013},
}
Figure