Current status and prospects of super-pangenome studies in plants

Xiaoqin Huang, Lisong Hu, Rui Fan, Xingtan Zhang, Chaoyun HaoScientia 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This review tracks the evolution of plant genomics from single reference genomes to "super-pangenomes" that span entire genera. By integrating the genetic blueprints of both crops and their wild relatives, super-pangenomes provide a high-resolution map of the "hidden" diversity lost during domestication, offering a powerful toolkit for breeding climate-resilient and high-yield crops.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, plant biology relied on a "single reference genome" per species. However, a single individual cannot represent the vast genetic diversity of an entire population. This led to the rise of pangenomes, which aggregate data from multiple individuals within a species to capture "presence-absence variations" (PAVs)—genes that some individuals have and others lack.

The problem is that even standard pangenomes are often limited to cultivated varieties. Thousands of years of human selection have created a "domestication bottleneck," where crops lost the rugged survival traits (like drought tolerance or pest resistance) found in their wild cousins. To find these "lost" genes, researchers are now moving toward super-pangenomes, which expand the scope to include wild relatives across an entire genus or higher taxonomic group.

Methods

The paper outlines the transition from linear sequences to variation graphs. Instead of forcing every new sequence to align with a single reference, these graphs represent genetic variation as branching paths.

Key construction strategies include:

  • De novo Assembly: Assembling every sample from scratch. It’s the most accurate but computationally expensive.
  • Iterative Assembly: Mapping reads to a reference and only assembling the "leftovers." It's faster but can be biased toward the reference.
  • Graph-based Assembly (The Gold Standard): Using tools like Minigraph-Cactus or PGGB to build a multi-dimensional map of SNPs, InDels, and large Structural Variations (SVs).

The authors also highlight the importance of T2T (Telomere-to-Telomere) sequencing and haplotype-resolved assemblies, which allow researchers to see the differences between the two sets of chromosomes in diploid or polyploid plants.

Datasets

As a review paper, it synthesizes results from several landmark super-pangenome projects:

  • Rice (Oryza): Studies covering hundreds of accessions, including wild species like O. rufipogon.
  • Watermelon (Citrullus): A T2T-level super-pangenome covering 7 species.
  • Potato & Tomato (Solanum): Massive datasets capturing the diversity of the nightshade family.
  • Others: Cotton (Gossypium), Soybean (Glycine), Apple (Malus), and Poplar (Populus).
  • Table 1 in the paper provides a comprehensive breakdown of these datasets, listing sample sizes and the specific wild relatives included.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Variable" Genome is the Key to Adaptation: While "core" genes handle basic survival, "variable" genes (found in super-pangenomes) are usually responsible for responding to environmental stress and pathogens.
  • Structural Variations (SVs) Matter More Than SNPs: Large-scale changes—like deletions or inversions of DNA chunks—often have a bigger impact on traits like fruit size or bitterness than single-letter mutations.
  • Evolutionary "Lenses": Super-pangenomes allow for "evolutionary screening" to identify deleterious mutations that have accumulated in crops over time, which can then be "purged" through precision breeding.
  • The Secondary and Tertiary Gene Pools: Super-pangenomes systematically map the "wild cousins" of crops, providing a clear roadmap for transferring valuable traits into elite varieties via CRISPR or molecular breeding.

Key Results

  • Rice: Researchers identified ~63,000 gene families in wild rice that were completely missing from cultivated varieties.
  • Watermelon: The super-pangenome revealed that the loss of bitterness and the increase in sugar content were driven by specific structural variations (SVs) in wild ancestors.
  • Tomato: A 244-base pair deletion in a cytochrome P450 gene was found to be a major driver in the evolution of fruit number and branching during domestication.
  • Potato: By comparing 192 samples, researchers developed an "evolutionary lens" to identify and filter out harmful mutations that hinder breeding efforts.

Limitations and Future Work

Despite the promise, the authors acknowledge several "bottlenecks":

  • Computational Hurdles: Building and visualizing a graph for a large, complex plant genome (like wheat or sugarcane) requires massive memory and processing power.
  • Standardization: There is currently no "universal standard" for how many samples or what depth of sequencing is required to call a dataset a "complete" super-pangenome.
  • Visualization: It is still difficult for humans to intuitively "see" and interpret multi-dimensional graph genomes compared to traditional linear maps.
  • The Next Frontier: The authors predict a move toward even higher taxonomic levels—potentially "Kingdom-level" pangenomes—to understand the deepest roots of plant evolution.

Summary updated

Abstract

近年来,高通量测序技术的迅猛发展极大地推动了植物全基因组测序进程。然而,单一参考基因组无法全面覆盖物种的全部遗传信息,限制了基因组学的深入研究。泛基因组(Pan-genome)通过整合多个代表性个体的基因组数据,有效克服了单一参考基因组的局限性,能够更全面展示物种的基因多样性,包括基因结构和变异,为基因组学研究开辟了新方向。然而,泛基因组更多关注单一物种内的基因多样性,为了捕捉植物界丰富的遗传多样性,泛基因组进一步扩展为超泛基因组(Super-pangenome)。植物超泛基因组从物种层面扩展至属或更高分类单元,涵盖栽培种及其二级、三级基因库中的野生近缘种。通过整合多元物种的种质资源,不仅构建了丰富的遗传变异图谱,还能捕捉到稀有基因和独特变异,为植物改良提供了新的潜力与方向。这将有助于通过分子标记辅助选择或基因编辑技术,将野生近缘种有价值的性状转移到优质品种,为植物品种改良提供宝贵基础,推动农业生产中更高效、更具适应性的品种创新。在这篇综述中,我们回顾了植物基因组和泛基因组研究的发展历程,总结了目前已发表的植物超泛基因组及其应用,并探讨了植物超泛基因组未来的前景和面临的挑战。
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2025current,
  author = {Xiaoqin Huang and Lisong Hu and Rui Fan and Xingtan Zhang and Chaoyun Hao},
  title = {{Current status and prospects of super-pangenome studies in plants}},
  booktitle = {Scientia},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1360/ssv-2024-0337},
}
Figure