TL;DR
This paper introduces "Cumulated Time to Chart Closure" (CTCC), a new metric derived from electronic health record (EHR) timestamps, to quantify clinician workload burden. CTCC proved to be a significant predictor of clinician burnout, outperforming traditional EHR usage metrics and offering a more practical way to identify at-risk clinicians and evaluate burnout interventions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The widespread adoption of Electronic Health Records (EHRs) has aimed to improve healthcare efficiency and patient safety. However, EHRs have also been implicated as a significant contributor to clinician stress and burnout. Existing methods for assessing burnout, such as surveys, are often burdensome. Furthermore, current EHR usage metrics, which primarily focus on direct interaction time, have proven insufficient in predicting burnout. This gap highlights the need for a more comprehensive and objective measure of workload burden that captures the full scope of a clinician's responsibilities and their impact on well-being. The authors aim to address this by developing and validating a novel EHR-derived metric that better reflects the multifaceted nature of clinician workload.
Methods
The study employed a retrospective, cross-sectional design, linking administrative survey data on physician well-being with EHR usage data. The core innovation is the introduction of Cumulated Time to Chart Closure (CTCC). This metric is defined as the average time elapsed from the start of a clinical encounter to the completion of all required documentation for that visit, across a set of encounters. Crucially, CTCC accounts for not only direct EHR interaction time but also the time elapsed between EHR activities, thereby encompassing non-clinical tasks, personal responsibilities, and mental load that contribute to overall workload.
Established EHR usage metrics were also collected, including:
- EHR-Time8: Total time in EHR during scheduled hours.
- WOW8 (Work Outside of Work): Time in EHR outside of scheduled patient hours.
- Note-Times: Time spent on note writing.
- IB-Times: Total time spent on the inbox.
- %EncClosed: Percentage of notes closed on the same day as the encounter.
The association between CTCC, these EHR metrics, and burnout (assessed using the Professional Fulfillment Index - PFI) was examined using descriptive statistics and adjusted logistic regression models.
Datasets
The study utilized EHR data from Boston Medical Center (BMC) for attending physicians from January 1 to October 30, 2021. This data was linked with responses from an administrative survey on physician well-being. The dataset included 305 attending physicians and encompassed 242,432 ambulatory encounters. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing EHR data and a validated burnout survey were used.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond Direct EHR Time: The most significant insight is that simply measuring the duration of direct interaction with the EHR (like EHR-Time8 or Note-Times) is insufficient to capture the drivers of clinician burnout. The "mental load" and the time elapsed between tasks are critical components of workload.
- CTCC as a Holistic Workload Measure: CTCC offers a more nuanced view of workload by acknowledging that the time between a patient encounter starting and its documentation closing includes a wide range of activities and cognitive demands, not just typing.
- Predictive Power of CTCC: CTCC emerged as a statistically significant predictor of burnout, suggesting it can serve as a practical, quantifiable proxy for identifying clinicians at risk.
- Burnout as a Mismatch: The paper posits that burnout arises from a mismatch between clinician demands and resources. CTCC effectively captures this mismatch by reflecting the cumulative time it takes to resolve these demands.
- Intervention Evaluation Potential: The ability to derive CTCC from readily available EHR timestamps makes it a promising tool for evaluating the effectiveness of interventions aimed at reducing burnout.
Key Results
- Prevalence of Burnout: 42% (128 out of 305) of the participating physicians experienced burnout.
- CTCC Association with Burnout: In the final adjusted logistic regression model, CTCC remained statistically significant, with an odds ratio of 1.42 (95% CI, 1.00-2.01). This means a 10-fold increase in CTCC was associated with a 42% increase in the odds of burnout.
- Other EHR Metrics: While WOW8 and IB-Times showed unadjusted associations with burnout, they did not remain significant in the final adjusted model when CTCC was included. EHR-Times and Note-Times were not significantly associated with burnout in either unadjusted or adjusted analyses.
- Median CTCC: The median CTCC for all clinicians was 32.5 hours.
Limitations and Future Work
- Cross-Sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature means it cannot establish causality and may not fully capture dynamic changes in demands or resources over time. The authors suggest CTCC is most useful for capturing trends over time.
- COVID-19 Context: The data was collected during the COVID-19 pandemic, which may have influenced workflows and burnout levels.
- Exclusion of Trainees: Trainees were excluded due to their reliance on attending sign-offs for documentation, which could skew results.
- Future Directions: The authors suggest further research to explore causal relationships, investigate optimal window lengths for CTCC calculation, and examine variations in time and predictors of CTCC. They also emphasize the need for more holistic metrics like CTCC to understand burnout drivers and evaluate interventions.
Summary updated