TL;DR
This paper explores how geomatics, a suite of spatial data acquisition and analysis technologies, can be leveraged to document, preserve, and promote cultural heritage sites, specifically focusing on the historic port city of Tartous in Syria. By integrating techniques like laser scanning and panoramic photography, the research aims to create detailed digital models that support sustainable tourism and heritage management.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper addresses the challenge of effectively valorizing and sustainably managing cultural heritage sites, particularly in the context of increasing tourism. Many historical sites face the risk of degradation due to overuse or neglect, and there's a need for robust methods to document their current state, understand their historical evolution, and communicate their value to a wider audience. The "Mare Nostrum" project, which this paper contributes to, aims to create a heritage trail along Phoenician maritime routes, highlighting the importance of pilot sites like Tartous. The core problem is how to bridge the gap between the physical documentation of heritage sites and their effective promotion for sustainable tourism and long-term preservation.
Methods
The research employs a range of geomatics techniques for data acquisition and analysis:
- Metric and Thematic Survey: This involves detailed geometric and thematic surveys of structures. Specifically, the paper highlights the use of:
- Total Station: For establishing a topographic network and measuring points.
- HDS6000 Phase-Based Laser Scanner: For high-resolution 3D detail surveys, capturing complex geometries and textures of architectural elements like the Knights' Chapel and city walls. Data acquisition was carefully planned to ensure uniform coverage and minimize shadow areas.
- Image Recording: Extensive photographic documentation was undertaken using:
- High-Resolution Digital Cameras (Nikon D3, D90, D700): With various fixed and zoom lenses.
- Panoramic Photography: Utilizing a panoramic head and fish-eye lens to capture 360° views of complex spaces. These were later elaborated into cylindrical equirectangular projections.
- HDR (High Dynamic Range) Imaging: Employed to capture images with a wider color depth and recover details in under or over-exposed areas, crucial for external photography.
- 3D Digital Modelling: The collected data (laser scans and photographs) is used to create 3D models. These models serve multiple purposes, including historical reconstruction checks, understanding morphological transformations, and creating virtual museums for education and communication.
- Database Management: Panoramic images are organized in a database (Adobe Lightroom 3) using metadata and keywords for efficient cataloging, searching, and accessibility for the research group and external researchers. Geotagging information from GPS is also utilized for innovative image management.
Datasets
The paper focuses on data collected from the Governorate of Tartous, Syria, specifically the port city of Tartous and its surrounding areas, including:
- The Citadel of Tartous (including the Knights' Chapel and Ottoman galleries).
- The Cathedral/Museum of Tartous.
- The archaeological site at Amrit.
- Arwad Island.
The data collected includes:
- Metric survey data (total area, survey area).
- Topographic survey data (total stations, traverses, vertices).
- Laser scanner survey data (stations, targets, spatial coordinates, registration error).
- Image recording data (photographs, panoramas, resolutions, shooting time).
- Over 14,000 photos were taken.
- Approximately 70 panoramas were created, each composed of an average of 21 photos.
No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing sites were documented using advanced geomatic techniques.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Geomatics as a Holistic Tool: The paper demonstrates that geomatics is not just about acquiring data but also about creating a new methodological approach to data management and analysis, enabling a more complete understanding of heritage sites.
- Bridging Physical and Digital Realms: The integration of precise metric data (laser scanning) with rich visual information (photography) allows for the creation of highly detailed and accurate 3D digital models that can represent heritage sites with remarkable fidelity.
- Sustainability through Digital Documentation: Detailed digital documentation and virtual representations can significantly contribute to sustainable tourism by providing alternative ways to experience sites, potentially reducing physical pressure on fragile heritage.
- Multifaceted Applications of 3D Models: Beyond simple visualization, 3D models can serve as powerful tools for historical reconstruction, understanding structural evolution, and creating engaging educational content.
- The Power of User-Generated Content (UGC) in Cultural Mapping: The paper touches upon how online platforms and UGC are transforming cultural mapping, making information more accessible and influencing tourist choices, highlighting the need for structured digital heritage resources.
Key Results
- Detailed 3D Models: The research successfully produced 3D models of key structures within the Tartous Citadel, such as the Knights' Chapel, and urban fabric, providing detailed geometric and textural information.
- Comprehensive Data Acquisition: A significant amount of metric and photographic data was collected, enabling detailed analysis of architectural features, construction techniques, and states of preservation.
- Creation of Virtual Tours and Multimedia Products: The collected data is being used to develop virtual tours and integrated multimedia products for popularization and communication of the heritage sites.
- Integration of Diverse Data Sources: The paper showcases the successful integration of existing plans with newly acquired survey data to create comprehensive site plans.
- Quantitative Data Summary: Table 1 provides a clear summary of the metric and image recording data, detailing the scale of the survey and the equipment used. For instance, the Tartous Citadel total area is about 31,000 sq m, with a survey area of about 6,900 sq m.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The paper acknowledges that the process of data acquisition and post-processing is time-consuming and requires skilled personnel.
- Access to adjacent private spaces and the complexity of transferring reference systems around buildings presented challenges during the detailed survey of the Chapel.
- The paper implies that the full potential of the collected data for "shared cultural mapping" is still being explored.
- Future Work:
- The paper suggests that the panoramas of archaeological and cultural sites in Tartous will be connected and put online.
- In the future, meta-nodes will be used to connect principal Phoenician Mediterranean ports, expanding the "shared cultural mapping" concept.
- The research aims to contribute to programming sustainable development by transforming tourism into an element that valorizes environmental and cultural qualities.
- Future efforts will focus on identifying strategies and instruments for reducing tourism pressure on the environment and improving the quality of areas affected by mass tourism.
Summary updated