Crystalline hydroxyapatite thin films produced at room temperature — An opposing radio frequency magnetron sputtering approach

Zhendong Hong, Lan Luan, Se‐Bum Paik, Bowen Deng, D. E. Ellis, J. B. Ketterson, Alexandre Mello, Jean Guillaume Eon, Joice Terra, Alexandre Malta RossiThin 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel "opposing radio frequency magnetron sputtering" technique to create highly crystalline and well-adhered hydroxyapatite (HA) thin films at room temperature. This method offers a promising alternative to conventional plasma spraying for producing biocompatible coatings on medical implants, potentially improving their integration with bone tissue.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hydroxyapatite (HA) is a key material for biomedical implants due to its excellent biocompatibility and ability to promote bone integration. While plasma spraying is a common method for depositing HA coatings, it often results in amorphous films with poor adhesion, requiring post-deposition heat treatments that can be detrimental to the underlying implant material. Conventional sputtering techniques also tend to produce amorphous HA films. The challenge is to develop a method that can produce crystalline, well-adhered HA films at low temperatures, avoiding the drawbacks of existing methods.

Methods

The core innovation in this paper is the use of an "opposing radio frequency (RF) magnetron sputtering system with a right-angle geometry." This setup involves two sputtering guns facing each other, with the substrate holder positioned at a right angle to the targets. This configuration, adapted from previous work on superconducting thin films, allows for a unique interaction of magnetic fields. The researchers used stoichiometric HA targets and sputtered them onto various substrates (fused silica, Si(100), Si(111), MgO) under controlled argon and oxygen gas pressures. They characterized the resulting films using X-ray diffraction (XRD), Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR), Raman spectroscopy, Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), and optical microscopy. A preliminary dissolution test was also performed.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Room-temperature crystallinity: The opposing magnetron sputtering approach successfully produces crystalline HA films at room temperature, eliminating the need for high-temperature annealing.
  • Improved adhesion: The as-sputtered films exhibit better adhesion to the substrate compared to annealed films, which is crucial for implant longevity.
  • Substrate influence on texture: The orientation of the substrate significantly impacts the crystallographic texture of the HA films, with silicon substrates promoting preferred growth along the c-axis.
  • Stability of as-sputtered films: The as-sputtered films are found to be more stable and less soluble in a physiological environment than their annealed counterparts, a critical factor for in-vivo performance.
  • Potential for metallic implants: The technique's ability to produce high-quality HA films at low temperatures makes it a promising candidate for coating metallic implants, which are sensitive to high heat.

Key Results

  • As-sputtered HA films were found to be nearly stoichiometric, highly crystalline, and strongly bound to the substrate.
  • Post-deposition heat treatment at 800°C did not significantly improve the crystallinity of the films and, in some cases, led to crack formation due to thermal mismatch.
  • XRD analysis confirmed the presence of HA peaks in the as-sputtered films, indicating high crystallinity comparable to sintered HA powder.
  • FTIR and Raman spectroscopy confirmed the presence of characteristic HA functional groups and indicated a higher degree of crystallinity in films deposited on Si(111) compared to Si(001).
  • Dissolution tests showed that as-sputtered films were significantly less soluble than annealed films.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while the opposing magnetron sputtering system can produce textured HA films, further optimization of experimental conditions might be needed to precisely control the degree of crystallinity and preferred orientations. They suggest that this technique may be a promising alternative to plasma spray for HA films on metallic implants, implying that future work could focus on demonstrating this application directly. The paper also mentions that moving the substrate further from the plasma region could improve thickness uniformity, but this might come at the cost of deposition rate and film purity.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{hong2007crystalline,
  author = {Zhendong Hong and Lan Luan and Se‐Bum Paik and Bowen Deng and D. E. Ellis and J. B. Ketterson and Alexandre Mello and Jean Guillaume Eon and Joice Terra and Alexandre Malta Rossi},
  title = {{Crystalline hydroxyapatite thin films produced at room temperature — An opposing radio frequency magnetron sputtering approach}},
  booktitle = {Thin},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1016/j.tsf.2007.02.089},
}
Figure