Crystal Structures of Tyrosyl-tRNA Synthetases from Archaea

M. Kuratani, Hiroaki Sakai, Masahiro Takahashi, T. Yanagisawa, Takatsugu Kobayashi, Kazutaka Murayama, Lirong Chen, Zhi‐Jie Liu, Bi‐Cheng Wang, Chizu Kuroishi, Seiki Kuramitsu, Takaho Terada, Yoshitaka Bessho, Mikako Shirouzu, Shun‐ichi Sekine, Shigeyuki YokoyamaJournal of Molecular Biology 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the crystal structures of three archaeal tyrosyl-tRNA synthetases (TyrRS), revealing distinct conformations of the crucial KMSKS motif. These structural differences offer insights into the enzyme's mechanism of amino acid activation and tRNA binding, suggesting a role for an insertion sequence in enhancing tRNA affinity in some archaeal species.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (TyrRS) is a vital enzyme responsible for attaching the amino acid tyrosine to its corresponding transfer RNA (tRNA). This process is essential for protein synthesis. TyrRS operates through a two-step mechanism: first, it activates tyrosine by forming a tyrosyl-adenylate intermediate, and then it transfers this activated tyrosine to the tRNA. Key to this mechanism are conserved motifs like "HIGH" and "KMSKS," which are known to be involved in binding ATP and stabilizing the transition state during amino acid activation.

While the general mechanism of TyrRS is understood, there are known differences between bacterial, eukaryotic, and archaeal enzymes, particularly concerning the KMSKS motif and tRNA binding. For instance, many eukaryotic and some archaeal TyrRSs lack the second lysine in the KMSKS motif, using a "KMSSS" sequence instead. Previous structural studies of archaeal/eukaryotic TyrRSs often showed disordered KMSKS loops or low-resolution structures, hindering a detailed understanding of their conformational dynamics. This paper aims to resolve these structures at high resolution to elucidate the conformational variations of the KMSKS motif and their implications for TyrRS function, especially in archaea.

Methods

The researchers determined the crystal structures of three archaeal TyrRSs: Archaeoglobus fulgidus (A. fulgidus) TyrRS bound to L-tyrosine, Pyrococcus horikoshii (P. horikoshii) TyrRS bound to L-tyrosine, and Aeropyrum pernix (A. pernix) TyrRS in its substrate-free form.

The primary techniques employed were:

  • X-ray crystallography: This was the core method for determining the three-dimensional structures of the proteins. Data were collected at cryogenic temperatures (100 K or 90 K) using synchrotron radiation sources (Advanced Photon Source and SPring-8).
  • Structure determination: For A. pernix TyrRS, both selenomethionine (SeMet)-substituted and native crystals were used. SeMet crystals allowed for Single-wavelength Anomalous Scattering (SAS) phasing, a common technique for initial phase determination. For A. fulgidus TyrRS, Molecular Replacement (MR) was used, employing the structure of M. jannaschii TyrRS as a search model.
  • Data processing and refinement: Standard crystallographic software packages (HKL2000, Sca2Structure, O, CNS) were used for processing diffraction data, phasing, model building, and refinement.
  • Sequence alignment: ClustalX was used to align the sequences of the studied archaeal TyrRSs with other known archaeal and eukaryotic TyrRSs, aiding in the identification of conserved and variable regions.
  • Structural analysis: Tools like Cuemol were used for visualization and analysis of the protein structures, including hydrogen bond interactions and conformational comparisons.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets or benchmarks. Instead, it relies on:

  • Protein Data Bank (PDB): The determined crystal structures of A. pernix, A. fulgidus, and P. horikoshii TyrRSs have been deposited in the PDB with accession codes 2CYA, 2CYB, and 2CYC, respectively.
  • Existing PDB structures: The study references and compares its findings with previously determined TyrRS structures, such as those from T. thermophilus (PDB: 1H3E), M. jannaschii (PDB: 1J1U, 1U7D, 1U7X), and human TyrRS (PDB: 1N3L, 1Q11).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • KMSKS motif plasticity: The most striking finding is the varied conformations of the KMSKS motif across the three archaeal TyrRSs. This highlights the dynamic nature of this crucial region and suggests different functional roles or states.
  • "Semi-closed" KMSKS conformation in P. horikoshii TyrRS: The formation of a 310 helix by the KMSKS loop in P. horikoshii TyrRS is novel. This conformation appears to enlarge the entrance to the active site, potentially facilitating the release of pyrophosphate after tyrosyl-adenylate formation and possibly aiding initial tRNA binding.
  • "Closed" KMSKS conformation in A. pernix TyrRS: The KMSKS loop in A. pernix TyrRS adopts a conformation similar to the ATP-bound "closed" form seen in T. thermophilus TyrRS. This suggests it is poised for ATP binding and activation.
  • "Open" KMSSS conformation in A. fulgidus TyrRS: The KMSSS loop in A. fulgidus TyrRS is positioned slightly further from the active site and is stabilized by hydrogen bonds, resembling an "open" state.
  • Role of insertion sequence: An insertion sequence preceding the KMSKS motif in P. horikoshii and A. pernix TyrRSs is proposed to enhance binding affinity for their cognate tRNA. This insertion forms a helix (α12) in P. horikoshii TyrRS, located near the tRNA anticodon stem.
  • Conserved non-proline cis peptide bond: All four archaeal TyrRS structures examined possess a conserved non-proline cis peptide bond in the N-terminal domain. This feature is suggested to be important for tRNA binding, specifically interacting with the cytosine base of the tRNA's anticodon, which is a key identity determinant. This is the first report of such a conserved cis peptide's role in TyrRS-tRNA recognition.

Key Results

  • High-resolution structures: The paper provides high-resolution crystal structures: 1.8 Å for A. fulgidus TyrRS and 2.2 Å for A. pernix and P. horikoshii TyrRSs.
  • Distinct KMSKS conformations:
    • A. pernix TyrRS: KMSKS loop resembles the ATP-bound "closed" form.
  • P. horikoshii TyrRS: KMSKS loop forms a novel 310 helix, termed "semi-closed" form.
  • A. fulgidus TyrRS: KMSSS loop is somewhat farther from the active site, in an "open" conformation.
  • Tyrosine-binding pocket conservation: The tyrosine-binding pocket is largely conserved among the studied archaeal TyrRSs, with similar hydrogen bonding networks.
  • Insertion helix (α12): In P. horikoshii TyrRS, an insertion sequence forms a helix (α12) that is proposed to enhance tRNA binding affinity.
  • Non-proline cis peptide bond: A conserved non-proline cis peptide bond was identified in the N-terminal domain of all four archaeal TyrRSs studied. This bond is implicated in interacting with the tRNA's cytosine residue.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Substrate-free A. pernix TyrRS: While the A. pernix TyrRS structure was determined in the substrate-free state, its KMSKS loop conformation resembles the ATP-bound state. Further studies with ATP and tyrosine bound would be beneficial to fully understand the transition.
  • KMSSS loop dynamics: The KMSSS loop in A. fulgidus TyrRS was observed in an "open" conformation. The paper suggests that upon ATP binding, it might undergo conformational changes similar to the KMSKS loop, but direct structural evidence for this is lacking. Future work could involve determining the structure of the A. fulgidus TyrRS complexed with ATP and potassium ions.
  • Eukaryotic TyrRS and tRNA interaction: The paper notes that eukaryotic TyrRSs lack the conserved non-proline cis peptide bond. Investigating the structure of eukaryotic TyrRS complexed with its cognate tRNA would be crucial to understand how these enzymes achieve tRNA recognition and whether alternative mechanisms are employed.
  • Functional validation of insertion sequence: While the insertion sequence is proposed to enhance tRNA binding, direct experimental validation of this hypothesis would strengthen the conclusions.
  • Role of cis peptide in other archaea/eukaryotes: The paper speculates on the evolutionary significance of the cis peptide bond in archaea, possibly related to survival in extreme environments. Further structural and functional studies of TyrRSs from a wider range of archaeal and eukaryotic species are needed to confirm these evolutionary hypotheses.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kuratani2005crystal,
  author = {M. Kuratani and Hiroaki Sakai and Masahiro Takahashi and T. Yanagisawa and Takatsugu Kobayashi and Kazutaka Murayama and Lirong Chen and Zhi‐Jie Liu and Bi‐Cheng Wang and Chizu Kuroishi and Seiki Kuramitsu and Takaho Terada and Yoshitaka Bessho and Mikako Shirouzu and Shun‐ichi Sekine and Shigeyuki Yokoyama},
  title = {{Crystal Structures of Tyrosyl-tRNA Synthetases from Archaea}},
  journal = {Journal of Molecular Biology},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jmb.2005.10.073},
}
Figure