Crystal orientation fabric anisotropy causes directional hardening of the Northeast Greenland Ice Stream

Tamara Annina Gerber, David A. Lilien, Nicholas Rathmann, Steven Franke, Tun Jan Young, Fernando Valero-Delgado, M. Reza Ershadi, Reinhard Drews, Ole Zeising, Angelika Humbert, Nicolas Stoll, Ilka Weikusat, Aslak Grinsted, Christine S. Hvidberg, Daniela Jansen, Heinrich Miller, Veit Helm, Daniel Steinhage, Charles O’Neill, John Paden, Siva Prasad Gogineni, Dorthe Dahl‐Jensen, Olaf EisenNature Communications 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the internal structure of ice crystals within the Northeast Greenland Ice Stream significantly impacts its flow. By combining radar, ice core data, and modeling, researchers found that this "crystal orientation fabric" makes the ice much harder to deform along the flow direction in some areas, while potentially softening it in others. This anisotropy is a crucial, previously underappreciated factor in understanding ice sheet dynamics and predicting sea-level rise.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately modeling ice sheet behavior is critical for predicting future sea-level rise, but current models struggle with the dynamic mass loss from ice streams. A key unknown is how the internal structure of ice crystals, specifically their orientation (crystal orientation fabric or COF), influences the bulk mechanical properties of ice. While it's known that COF can create anisotropy (making ice behave differently in different directions), its spatial variability and impact on ice stream flow, particularly in dynamic regions like the Northeast Greenland Ice Stream (NEGIS), have been poorly understood. Existing models often simplify this by assuming isotropic ice or using generic enhancement factors, missing the nuanced, directional hardening or softening that COF can induce.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Radar Surveys: They utilized airborne and ground-based radio-echo sounding (RES) techniques. Specifically, they analyzed two key radar signals influenced by COF:
  • Birefringence-induced beat signatures: These arise from interference patterns caused by different radar wave speeds due to COF.
  • Travel-time differences: These occur when radar waves polarized orthogonally travel at different speeds, leading to time delays for reflections from internal layers.
  • Ice Core Data: Direct measurements of COF from ice cores drilled at the EGRIP site (ice stream center) and a shallow core (S5) at the southeastern shear margin provided ground truth.
  • Numerical Ice-Flow Modeling: Two models were used:
  • Elmer/Ice: A full-Stokes ice-flow model coupled with a COF evolution model to simulate COF development under realistic ice stream conditions.
  • Specfab: A kinematic model focusing solely on COF evolution in response to strain, used to explore downstream changes.

By combining these methods, they could map the spatial distribution of COF anisotropy and translate it into directional flow-enhancement factors.

Datasets

  • Airborne Radar Data: Ultra-wideband radar survey data from the EGRIP-NOR 2018 campaign.
  • Ground-based Radar Data: A UHF radar profile across the northwestern shear margin and polarimetric phase-sensitive radio-echo sounding (PRES) measurements at six locations.
  • Ice Core Data: Samples from the deep EGRIP ice core and the shallow S5 core at the southeastern shear margin.
  • Surface Velocity Data: Satellite-based surface flow velocities (referenced from Joughin et al., 2018).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • COF is Highly Variable and Directional: The study demonstrates that COF anisotropy is not uniform but varies significantly over short distances within the NEGIS, closely following the ice stream's geometry.
  • Directional Hardening is Significant: The COF can make ice substantially "harder" (more resistant to deformation) along the flow direction, by one to two orders of magnitude compared to isotropic ice in some areas. This is a much stronger effect than typically accounted for.
  • Shear Margins are Complex: While the ice stream center shows pronounced hardening, the shear margins present a more complex picture, with some evidence suggesting softening for horizontal shear, though this is less definitively confirmed by all methods.
  • Rapid COF Reorganization: The COF can reorganize over relatively short timescales (hundreds of years), adapting to changing strain regimes within the ice stream.
  • Temperature vs. COF: The hardening effect of COF along the flow direction is so significant that it would require unrealistically large temperature drops (15-30°C colder) to achieve the same stiffness through temperature alone. This highlights COF's dominant role in this specific hardening.

Key Results

  • Spatial Anisotropy Mapping: The study provides the first spatially extensive map of depth-averaged horizontal COF anisotropy in the NEGIS onset.
  • Flow-Enhancement Factors:
    • Along-flow pure shear (compression/extension): Ice in the ice stream center is estimated to be 1-2 orders of magnitude harder than isotropic ice.
  • Horizontal shear: Shear margins show potential softening by a factor of two, though this is more pronounced in modeling than radar observations.
  • COF Evolution: Modeling suggests a transition from a vertical girdle COF outside the ice stream to a vertical single maximum within the stream, with further complex transitions downstream.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Depth Averaging: Radar methods provide depth-averaged anisotropy, limiting the ability to resolve vertical variations in COF.
  • Assumptions in Enhancement Factor Calculation: Calculating enhancement factors relies on assumptions about COF types and strain-COF alignment, particularly in shear margins where direct observations are limited.
  • Model Limitations: The Elmer/Ice model, while advanced, is not fully 3D and imposes shear stresses, potentially smoothing sharp gradients. It also doesn't fully capture dynamic recrystallization.
  • Shear Margin Ambiguity: The role of COF in shear margin softening remains somewhat unclear, as temperature effects (shear heating) could also contribute.

Future work could focus on improving the vertical resolution of radar measurements, obtaining more direct COF measurements in shear margins, and developing more comprehensive 3D ice-flow models that fully incorporate dynamic recrystallization and complex COF evolution. Understanding how these COF-induced stiffness variations influence the propagation of disturbances upstream from the ice sheet margin is also a key area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

The dynamic mass loss of ice sheets constitutes one of the biggest uncertainties in projections of ice-sheet evolution. One central, understudied aspect of ice flow is how the bulk orientation of the crystal orientation fabric translates to the mechanical anisotropy of ice. Here we show the spatial distribution of the depth-averaged horizontal anisotropy and corresponding directional flow-enhancement factors covering a large area of the Northeast Greenland Ice Stream onset. Our results are based on airborne and ground-based radar surveys, ice-core observations, and numerical ice-flow modelling. They show a strong spatial variability of the horizontal anisotropy and a rapid crystal reorganisation on the order of hundreds of years coinciding with the ice-stream geometry. Compared to isotropic ice, parts of the ice stream are found to be more than one order of magnitude harder for along-flow extension/compression while the shear margins are potentially softened by a factor of two for horizontal-shear deformation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gerber2023crystal,
  author = {Tamara Annina Gerber and David A. Lilien and Nicholas Rathmann and Steven Franke and Tun Jan Young and Fernando Valero-Delgado and M. Reza Ershadi and Reinhard Drews and Ole Zeising and Angelika Humbert and Nicolas Stoll and Ilka Weikusat and Aslak Grinsted and Christine S. Hvidberg and Daniela Jansen and Heinrich Miller and Veit Helm and Daniel Steinhage and Charles O’Neill and John Paden and Siva Prasad Gogineni and Dorthe Dahl‐Jensen and Olaf Eisen},
  title = {{Crystal orientation fabric anisotropy causes directional hardening of the Northeast Greenland Ice Stream}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-38139-8},
}
Figure