Cryogenic hybrid magnonic circuits based on spalled YIG thin films

Jing Xu, Connor P. Horn, Yu Jiang, Xinhao Li, Daniel Rosenmann, Xu Han, M. Levy, Supratik Guha, Xufeng Zhang, Zhang, XufengarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a "spalling" technique to mechanically peel high-quality Yttrium Iron Garnet (YIG) thin films away from their lossy growth substrates. This breakthrough enables the integration of YIG magnonic circuits with superconducting resonators at cryogenic temperatures, achieving the "strong coupling" regime necessary for next-generation quantum information processing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Yttrium Iron Garnet (YIG) is the "gold standard" material for magnonics—the study of magnons, or collective spin excitations. It boasts incredibly low magnetic damping, making it ideal for carrying and processing information. However, high-quality YIG must be grown epitaxially on Gadolinium Gallium Garnet (GGG) substrates to maintain its crystal structure.

The "deal-breaker" occurs at cryogenic temperatures (below 5 Kelvin), which are required for superconducting quantum computers. At these temperatures, the GGG substrate undergoes a phase transition into a "geometrically frustrated spin-liquid state." In plain English: the substrate starts acting like a giant sponge for microwave energy, causing massive losses that drown out the magnon signals. To use YIG in quantum circuits, researchers needed a way to keep the YIG but ditch the GGG.

Methods

The authors employ a technique called controlled mechanical spalling to separate the YIG film from the GGG substrate.

  1. Preparation: They start with a standard YIG-on-GGG wafer. They optionally use helium ion implantation to create a "damage layer" at a specific depth (about 7 µm), which acts like a perforation line.
  2. Stress Induction: They deposit a stack of metal layers (Chromium, Gold, and a thick layer of Nickel) on top of the YIG. The Nickel layer is electroplated under conditions that create high internal tensile stress (700 MPa).
  3. The "Peel": Using thermal release tape, they pull on the metal stack. The internal stress in the Nickel causes a crack to propagate horizontally through the GGG/YIG interface.
  4. Cleanup: The YIG film (now stuck to the tape/metal) is removed. The metal layers are chemically etched away, and the YIG is annealed at 850°C to repair any crystal damage from the ion implantation.
  5. Integration: The resulting "freed" YIG flake is flip-bonded onto a superconducting Niobium resonator to test its performance at 200 mK.

Datasets

As an experimental physics paper, this study does not use traditional large-scale datasets. Instead, the "data" consists of:

  • Surface Profile Scans: Using 3D laser scanning confocal microscopy to measure the depth and smoothness of the spalled area.
  • Microwave Transmission Spectra ($S_{21}$): Measured using a Vector Network Analyzer (VNA) to identify resonance peaks and "anti-crossing" features.
  • Ferromagnetic Resonance (FMR) Linewidths: Used to quantify the magnetic loss (damping) of the YIG before and after processing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Substrate Removal is Essential: The paper visually demonstrates that while a standard YIG/GGG chip shows no clear resonances at cryogenic temperatures (due to GGG losses), the spalled YIG chip shows sharp, high-quality signals.
  • Stress as a Tool: Instead of trying to chemically dissolve a substrate (which is difficult when YIG and GGG are chemically similar), the authors use mechanical stress to "zip" the film off.
  • Healing the Crystal: A critical insight was that the ion implantation used to facilitate spalling initially ruins the YIG's magnetic properties. However, a high-temperature annealing step successfully "heals" the lattice, restoring low-loss performance.
  • Strong Coupling Achieved: The authors observed a clear "avoided crossing" in the spectra. This is the smoking gun for strong coupling, meaning information can be swapped back and forth between a microwave photon and a magnon faster than the energy is lost to the environment.

Key Results

  • Strong Coupling: The researchers measured a magnon-photon coupling strength ($g/2\pi$) of 62 MHz.
  • Low Dissipation: At 200 mK, the magnon dissipation rate ($\kappa_m/2\pi$) was reduced to 13 MHz. This is a significant improvement over YIG-on-GGG, where the signal is typically too damped to measure accurately.
  • Linewidth: After annealing, the room-temperature FMR linewidth was roughly 1.5 Oe, comparable to high-quality commercial YIG films, proving the spalling process doesn't permanently degrade the material.
  • Successful Integration: The hybrid device achieved a cooperativity (a measure of coupling efficiency) high enough for quantum applications.

Limitations and Future Work

While successful, the process isn't perfect yet. The authors note that the current dissipation rate (13 MHz) is still higher than what is seen in bulk YIG spheres. This is likely due to:

  1. Residual GGG: Small amounts of GGG might still be attached to the spalled YIG.
  2. Surface Roughness: The spalling process leaves a rougher surface than epitaxial growth, which can increase scattering losses.

Future Work will focus on optimizing the spalling depth to ensure a "pure" YIG film and refining the etching/polishing steps to smooth the spalled surface. If perfected, this could lead to wafer-scale production of YIG-on-chip devices for scalable quantum networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Yttrium iron garnet (YIG) magnonics has garnered significant research interest because of the unique properties of magnons (quasiparticles of collective spin excitation) for signal processing. In particular, hybrid systems based on YIG magnonics show great promise for quantum information science due to their broad frequency tunability and strong compatibility with other platforms. However, their broad applications have been severely constrained by substantial microwave loss in the gadolinium gallium garnet (GGG) substrate at cryogenic temperatures. In this study, we demonstrate that YIG thin films can be spalled from YIG/GGG samples. Our approach is validated by measuring hybrid devices comprising superconducting resonators and spalled YIG films, which exhibits anti-crossing features that indicate strong coupling between magnons and microwave photons. Such new capability of separating YIG thin films from GGG substrates via spalling, and the integrated superconductor-YIG devices represent a significant advancement for integrated magnonic devices, paving the way for advanced magnon-based coherent information processing.
BibTeX
@misc{xu2023cryogenic,
  author = {Jing Xu and Connor P. Horn and Yu Jiang and Xinhao Li and Daniel Rosenmann and Xu Han and M. Levy and Supratik Guha and Xufeng Zhang and Zhang, Xufeng},
  title = {{Cryogenic hybrid magnonic circuits based on spalled YIG thin films}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2312.10660},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.10660},
}
Figure