CryoENsemble - a Bayesian approach for reweighting biomolecular structural ensembles using heterogeneous cryo-EM maps

Tomasz Włodarski, Julian O. Streit, Alkistis Mitropoulou, Lisa D. Cabrita, Michele Vendruscolo, John ChristodouloubioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces CryoENsemble, a novel Bayesian method that refines molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of biomolecules using cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) data. It effectively handles complex, dynamic systems by reweighting existing structural ensembles, leading to more accurate interpretations of heterogeneous cryo-EM maps and revealing previously unmodeled structural features.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cryo-EM has revolutionized structural biology, but accurately capturing the dynamics of complex biomolecules remains a significant challenge. Cryo-EM maps often suffer from blurring or missing information in regions that are flexible or exist in multiple conformations. This "heterogeneity" makes it difficult to obtain a complete picture of a molecule's behavior. Traditional methods often struggle to reconcile the static snapshots from cryo-EM with the dynamic nature of biological processes. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a computational framework to integrate dynamic information from MD simulations with the structural constraints from cryo-EM data.

Methods

The core of the paper is the CryoENsemble method, which builds upon the Bayesian Inference Of ENsembles (BioEn) approach. Here's how it works:

  • Input: A structural ensemble (typically from MD simulations) and a cryo-EM map.
  • Bayesian Reweighting: CryoENsemble uses Bayes' theorem to adjust the weights of individual structures within the MD ensemble. The goal is to find a set of weights that best explains the experimental cryo-EM data.
  • Likelihood Function: This function quantifies how well a given structure from the ensemble matches the experimental cryo-EM density. It's modeled using Gaussian distributions to account for experimental noise and resolution.
  • Prior Function: This term incorporates the initial information from the MD simulations, reflecting the relative probabilities of different conformations before considering the cryo-EM data. A hyperparameter ($\theta$) controls how much the refined weights are allowed to deviate from the initial MD weights, balancing confidence in the MD simulation against fitting the experimental data.
  • Optimization: The method minimizes a log-posterior function to find the optimal weights for each structure in the ensemble, along with parameters describing the likelihood function.
  • Novelty: Unlike methods that refine a single structure or generate entirely new conformations, CryoENsemble reweights an existing ensemble, preserving the sampled conformational space while improving its representation of the experimental data. It also explicitly handles both discrete and continuous heterogeneity.

Datasets

The CryoENsemble method was validated using:

  • Synthetic cryo-EM maps:
    • Adenylate kinase (ADK): Generated from X-ray structures representing discrete conformational heterogeneity (open and closed states).
  • Ribosome nascent chain complex (RNC) (FLN5-6+31): Generated from MD simulations, representing continuous conformational heterogeneity.
  • Experimentally derived cryo-EM map:
    • Ribosome-bound state of Trigger Factor (TF): This map was used to test the method on a real-world, complex biological system with known dynamic elements.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ensembles over Single Structures: The study strongly supports the idea that a structural ensemble, rather than a single best-fit structure, is crucial for accurately interpreting heterogeneous cryo-EM data, especially for dynamic regions.
  • Explaining Unaccounted Density: CryoENsemble can help resolve ambiguities in cryo-EM maps. In the TF system, it helped distinguish between the dynamics of TF and the presence of another protein (MetAP) in an unannotated density region.
  • Sensitivity to Prior Ensemble Quality: The effectiveness of CryoENsemble depends on the quality and completeness of the initial MD ensemble. The method refines existing conformations, it doesn't create new ones.
  • Parameter Optimization is Key: The automatic L-curve analysis for optimizing the $\theta$ parameter is critical for balancing good agreement with experimental data and preventing overfitting.

Key Results

  • Improved Agreement: CryoENsemble consistently improved the agreement between the structural ensemble and the cryo-EM data, as measured by correlation coefficients (CC) and Fourier Shell Correlation (FSC05). For the TF dataset, CC improved from 0.68 to 0.71.
  • Accurate Population Distribution: For the ADK dataset, CryoENsemble successfully reweighted the ensemble to match the known populations of open and closed states used to generate the synthetic reference maps.
  • Identification of MetAP Binding Site: The method helped identify an unaccounted density in the TF cryo-EM map as a binding site for methionine aminopeptidase (MetAP), rather than TF dynamics.
  • Robustness: The method showed robustness across varying resolutions (3-10 Å) and noise levels (1-10%) in the cryo-EM maps, though higher resolution and noise presented greater challenges.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dependence on Prior Ensemble: The method's ability to capture heterogeneity is limited by the conformational space sampled by the initial MD simulations. Future work could explore using enhanced sampling methods or machine learning to generate more comprehensive prior ensembles.
  • Computational Cost: While efficient, reweighting time and memory usage can still be significant, depending on the size of the cryo-EM map and the structural ensemble. Clustering the ensemble before reweighting can mitigate this.
  • Integration with Other Data: The authors suggest that CryoENsemble could be extended to integrate other experimental data (NMR, SAXS, etc.) within the BioEn framework, making it a powerful tool for integrative structural biology.
  • Force Field Validation: CryoENsemble could be used to assess which MD force fields best reproduce cryo-EM data, potentially guiding force field parameterization.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) has emerged as a central tool for the determination of structures of complex biological molecules. Accurately characterising the dynamics of such systems, however, remains a challenge. To address this, we introduce cryoENsemble, a method that applies Bayesian reweighing to conformational ensembles derived from molecular dynamics simulations to improve their agreement with cryo-EM data and extract dynamics information. We illustrate the use of cryoENsemble to determine the dynamics of the ribosome-bound state of the co-translational chaperone trigger factor (TF). We also show that cryoENsemble can assist with the interpretation of low-resolution, noisy or unaccounted regions of cryo-EM maps. Notably, we are able to link an unaccounted part of the cryo-EM map to the presence of another protein (methionine aminopeptidase, or MetAP), rather than to the dynamics of TF, and model its TF-bound state. Based on these results, cryoENsemble is expected to find use for challenging heterogeneous cryo-EM maps for various biomolecular systems, especially those encompassing dynamic elements.
BibTeX
@misc{wodarski2023cryoensemble,
  author = {Tomasz Włodarski and Julian O. Streit and Alkistis Mitropoulou and Lisa D. Cabrita and Michele Vendruscolo and John Christodoulou},
  title = {{CryoENsemble - a Bayesian approach for reweighting biomolecular structural ensembles using heterogeneous cryo-EM maps}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.11.21.567999},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure