Crossover from Collective to Incoherent Spin Excitations in Superconducting Cuprates Probed by Detuned Resonant Inelastic X-Ray Scattering

M. Minola, Yi Lu, Y. Y. Peng, G. Dellea, H. Gretarsson, M. W. Haverkort, Ying Ding, Xuan Sun, X. J. Zhou, Darren C. Peets, L. Chauvière, P. Dosanjh, D. A. Bonn, Ruixing Liang, A. Damascelli, M. Dantz, Xingye Lu, Thorsten Schmitt, L. Braicovich, G. Ghiringhelli, B. Keimer, M. Le TaconPhysical 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a sophisticated X-ray scattering technique (RIXS) to probe the spin excitations in cuprate superconductors as they transition from optimal to overdoped states. They discovered a surprising crossover from collective, "paramagnon" excitations to incoherent particle-hole excitations, suggesting a fundamental change in the electronic behavior near optimal doping that may be linked to quantum criticality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-temperature superconductivity in cuprates remains a profound mystery, with a key debate centering on the role of spin excitations as potential "mediators" of superconductivity. While neutron scattering has provided insights into spin dynamics, it's largely limited to underdoped materials. Recent transport experiments hint at a quantum critical point (QCP) near optimal doping, where superconductivity is strongest, suggesting a significant change in electronic behavior. However, spectroscopic probes that can track these spin excitations across this critical doping level and understand their nature (collective vs. individual particle behavior) have been lacking. This paper aims to fill this gap by using Resonant Inelastic X-ray Scattering (RIXS) to map out the spin excitation spectrum across a wide doping range, specifically looking for changes that correlate with the proposed QCP.

Methods

The core technique employed is Resonant Inelastic X-ray Scattering (RIXS), specifically at the Copper L3 edge. RIXS is powerful because it can probe electronic and magnetic excitations with high sensitivity and cross-section. The key innovation here is the "detuning" of the incoming X-ray energy. By slightly shifting the photon energy away from the Cu-L3 absorption peak, the researchers can selectively probe different aspects of the electronic excitations.

  • RIXS: This technique involves shining X-rays onto a material and analyzing the energy and momentum of the scattered X-rays. The energy loss in the scattered X-rays reveals information about the excitations within the material.
  • Detuning: By varying the incident photon energy above the Cu-L3 resonance, the authors can tune into different electronic states. This allows them to distinguish between excitations that are sensitive to the incident energy (like particle-hole excitations) and those that are not (like collective spin waves).
  • Polarization Analysis: While not explicitly used for data collection in this work, the authors mention that specific polarization configurations are crucial for isolating spin excitations from charge excitations. They utilized a geometry known to favor spin-flip excitations.
  • Exact Diagonalization (ED) Calculations: To interpret their experimental findings, the authors performed sophisticated theoretical calculations using the ED method on a finite cluster model of the Hubbard model. This is a standard approach for studying strongly correlated electron systems like cuprates, allowing them to compare experimental spectra with theoretical predictions.

Datasets

The paper utilizes experimental data from two families of overdoped cuprate superconductors:

  • (Bi,Pb)$_{2}$(Sr,La)$_{2}$CuO$_{6+δ}$ (Bi2201): Samples with doping levels p = 0.16 (optimally doped, superconducting), p = 0.24 (lightly overdoped, superconducting), and p > 0.27 (heavily overdoped, non-superconducting).
  • Tl$_{2}$Ba$_{2}$CuO$_{6+δ}$ (Tl2201): Samples with doping levels p = 0.20 (lightly overdoped, superconducting) and p = 0.27 (heavily overdoped, superconducting).

This data is complemented by previously published RIXS data on underdoped YBa$_{2}$Cu$_{3}$O$_{6+x}$ (YBCO) to cover a broader doping range.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Crossover in Spin Excitations: The most striking finding is the clear change in the nature of spin excitations as doping increases beyond optimal. At optimal doping, the excitations are "Raman-like," meaning their spectral weight is concentrated at a specific energy (around 0.3 eV) and doesn't shift significantly with detuning. This is characteristic of collective spin waves (paramagnons). However, in overdoped samples, a significant portion of the spectral weight shifts to higher energies with detuning, indicating a transition to more incoherent, particle-hole-like excitations.
  • Universality Across Cuprate Families: Remarkably, the RIXS spectra for both Bi2201 and Tl2201 show very similar behavior across the doping range. This suggests that the observed crossover is a generic feature of cuprates and not specific to the particular material composition.
  • Connection to Quantum Criticality: The observed crossover in spin excitations occurs around the doping level where transport experiments suggest a quantum phase transition. This provides a spectroscopic link between the proposed QCP and the fundamental electronic behavior of the material, specifically the dynamics of spins.
  • Hubbard Model Success: The exact diagonalization calculations on the single-band Hubbard model, despite its simplicity, remarkably reproduce the key features of the experimental RIXS spectra, including the doping-dependent crossover. This lends strong support to the idea that strong electronic correlations are the primary driver of these phenomena.

Key Results

  • Paramagnon Dominance at Optimal Doping: RIXS spectra at optimal doping are dominated by a paramagnon feature with a peak energy independent of incident photon energy.
  • Emergence of Incoherent Excitations: Beyond optimal doping, a strong contribution from incoherent particle-hole excitations appears, characterized by a spectral weight that shifts to higher energies with increasing detuning.
  • Sharp Crossover: This transition from collective to incoherent spin excitations occurs rapidly in a narrow doping range around optimal doping (p ≈ 0.16).
  • Model Agreement: Exact diagonalization calculations of the Hubbard model accurately reproduce the experimental RIXS spectra across the doping range, validating the model's ability to capture the essential physics.
  • Charge vs. Spin Excitations: The paper notes that while charge excitations show a consistent fluorescence-like behavior with detuning, the spin excitations exhibit the dramatic crossover described above.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Limitations: While the Hubbard model provides a good qualitative description, the authors acknowledge that it's a simplified model. Future work could explore more complex models that include additional physics, such as disorder or coupling to phonons, which might explain finer details of the spectral broadening and potential discrepancies.
  • Experimental Resolution: The RIXS resolution (180 meV) is a limiting factor in precisely resolving very fine spectral features.
  • Charge Contribution: While the authors estimate the charge contribution to the spin channel, directly measuring it with high precision is challenging due to low count rates.
  • Origin of the Transition: The paper highlights that the origin of the quantum phase transition near optimal doping is still debated. The RIXS results provide a crucial piece of the puzzle by linking it to the spin dynamics, but further theoretical and experimental work is needed to fully elucidate the underlying mechanisms.
  • Implications for Superconductivity: The authors suggest that the observed loss of paramagnon spectral weight and the rise of incoherent excitations might weaken the spin-fluctuation-mediated pairing mechanism, potentially explaining the decrease in superconducting transition temperature in the overdoped regime. This is a key avenue for future investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spin excitations in the overdoped high temperature superconductors Tl_{2}Ba_{2}CuO_{6+δ} and (Bi,Pb)_{2}(Sr,La)_{2}CuO_{6+δ} were investigated by resonant inelastic x-ray scattering (RIXS) as functions of doping and detuning of the incoming photon energy above the Cu-L_{3} absorption peak. The RIXS spectra at optimal doping are dominated by a paramagnon feature with peak energy independent of photon energy, similar to prior results on underdoped cuprates. Beyond optimal doping, the RIXS data indicate a sharp crossover to a regime with a strong contribution from incoherent particle-hole excitations whose maximum shows a fluorescencelike shift upon detuning. The spectra of both compound families are closely similar, and their salient features are reproduced by exact-diagonalization calculations of the single-band Hubbard model on a finite cluster. The results are discussed in the light of recent transport experiments indicating a quantum phase transition near optimal doping.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{minola2017crossover,
  author = {M. Minola and Yi Lu and Y. Y. Peng and G. Dellea and H. Gretarsson and M. W. Haverkort and Ying Ding and Xuan Sun and X. J. Zhou and Darren C. Peets and L. Chauvière and P. Dosanjh and D. A. Bonn and Ruixing Liang and A. Damascelli and M. Dantz and Xingye Lu and Thorsten Schmitt and L. Braicovich and G. Ghiringhelli and B. Keimer and M. Le Tacon},
  title = {{Crossover from Collective to Incoherent Spin Excitations in Superconducting Cuprates Probed by Detuned Resonant Inelastic X-Ray Scattering}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.119.097001},
}
Figure