TL;DR
This paper introduces and validates a comprehensive instrument to measure cross-sector collaboration in stunting reduction programs in Gorontalo Province, Indonesia. The instrument, comprising 10 domains and 95 items, demonstrates strong validity and reliability, offering a crucial tool for evaluating and improving coordinated efforts against stunting.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Stunting, a critical public health issue, particularly in developing countries like Indonesia, requires a multi-faceted approach that extends beyond the health sector. Addressing stunting necessitates effective collaboration among various government agencies, non-governmental organizations, and community stakeholders. However, despite the recognized importance of cross-sector collaboration, there's a significant gap in standardized, validated tools to assess its effectiveness in stunting reduction programs. Existing research often focuses on sector-specific outcomes, leaving a need for instruments that can systematically measure the quality and impact of these crucial partnerships, especially within specific regional contexts like Gorontalo. This lack of measurement hinders the ability to identify strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement in collaborative efforts, ultimately impacting program outcomes.
Methods
The study employed a mixed-methods approach, beginning with a qualitative phase to develop the assessment instrument. This involved Focus Group Discussions (FGDs) and in-depth interviews with key informants involved in stunting management. Following this, a quantitative phase was conducted to test the validity and reliability of the developed instrument. A questionnaire, comprising 10 domains and 95 items, was administered to 32 members of the Gorontalo Province Stunting Reduction Acceleration Implementation Team. Validity was assessed using Pearson correlation, with items considered valid if they met a significance threshold (p-value < 0.05). Reliability was evaluated using Cronbach's Alpha.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized a questionnaire administered to 32 members of the Gorontalo Province Stunting Reduction Acceleration Implementation Team.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Multifaceted Nature of Collaboration: Stunting is not just a health issue; it's deeply intertwined with socio-economic, environmental, and developmental factors, underscoring the necessity of a truly cross-sectoral approach.
- The Need for Context-Specific Tools: Generic collaboration assessment tools may not capture the nuances of specific regional challenges and existing governance structures. This study highlights the importance of developing contextually relevant instruments.
- Beyond Simple Participation: Effective collaboration involves more than just bringing different sectors together; it requires shared vision, clear roles, adequate resources, strong leadership, and robust communication channels.
- The Power of Measurement: A validated instrument is essential for moving beyond anecdotal evidence of collaboration to data-driven evaluation, enabling targeted interventions and continuous improvement.
- Stunting Reduction as a Public Health 3.0 Imperative: The study aligns with the principles of Public Health 3.0, emphasizing proactive, collaborative, and community-engaged approaches to population health.
Key Results
The developed instrument consists of 10 domains and initially 95 items. Validity testing confirmed 93 items as valid, with two being excluded. Reliability analysis using Cronbach's Alpha revealed:
- Exceptional Reliability (>0.9): Cross-sector roles and structures, and cross-sector performance.
- Very Good Reliability (0.8-0.9): Cross-sector vision and mission, partner profile, resource availability, leadership, communication, and partnership functions.
- Good Reliability (0.7-0.8): Cross-sector context.
- Moderate Reliability (0.5-0.6): Need for cross-sector collaboration.
The overall reliability of the instrument was found to be 0.876, indicating "very good reliability," meaning the instrument is consistent and dependable for repeated use.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that while the instrument demonstrates strong validity and reliability within Gorontalo Province, further research is recommended to enhance its generalizability. This includes conducting subsequent testing on larger and more diverse populations. The study also suggests that the current instrument can serve as a foundation for developing more expansive tools for broader applications in assessing multi-sectoral collaboration in health-related programs.
Summary updated