Cross-ancestry genome-wide association analysis of corneal thickness strengthens link between complex and Mendelian eye diseases

Adriana I. Iglesias, Aniket Mishra, Véronique Vitart, Yelena Bykhovskaya, René Höhn, Henriët Springelkamp, Gabriel Cuéllar-Partida, Puya Gharahkhani, Jessica N. Cooke Bailey, Colin E. Willoughby, Xiaohui Li, Seyhan Yazar, Abhishek Nag, Anthony P. Khawaja, Ozren Polašek, David S. Siscovick, Paul Mitchell, Yih Chung Tham, Jonathan L. Haines, Lisa S. Kearns, Caroline Hayward, Yuan Shi, Jin‐Moo Lee, Kent D. Taylor, Jie Jin Wang, Elena Rochtchina, John Attia, Rodney J. Scott, Elizabeth G. Holliday, Sandra E. Staffieri, Paul N. Baird, Jing Xie, Michael Inouye, Ananth C. Viswanathan, Xueling Sim, Pieter W. M. Bonnemaijer, Jerome I. Rotter, Nicholas G. Martin, Tanja Zeller, Richard Mills, Emmanuelle Souzeau, Jost B. Jonas, Irene Schmidtmann, Thibaud Boutin, Jae H. Kang, Sionne E. M. Lucas, Manfred E. Beutel, James F. Wilson, R. Rand Allingham, Murray H. Brilliant, Donald L. Budenz, William G. Christen, John H. Fingert, David S. Friedman, Douglas Gaasterland, Terry Gaasterland, Michael A. Hauser, Peter Kraft, Richard K. Lee, Paul R. Lichter, Yutao Liu, Stephanie Loomis, Sayoko E. Moroi, Margaret A. Pericak‐Vance, Anthony Realini, Julia E. Richards, Joel S. Schuman, William K. Scott, Kuldev Singh, Arthur J. Sit, Douglas Vollrath, Robert N. Weinreb, Gadi Wollstein, Donald J. Zack, Kang Zhang, David M. Evans, Inês Barroso, Jenefer M. Blackwell, Elvira Bramon, Matthew A. Brown, Juan P. Casas, Aiden Corvin, Panos Deloukas, Audrey Duncanson, Janusz Jankowski, Hugh S. Markus, Christopher G. Mathew, Robert Plomin, Anna Rautanen, Stephen Sawcer, Richard C. Trembath, Nicholas Wood, Chris C. A. Spencer, Gavin Band, Céline Bellenguez, Colin L. Freeman, Garrett HellenthalNature Communications 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study performed a large-scale, cross-ancestry genome-wide association meta-analysis of central corneal thickness (CCT), identifying 19 new genetic regions associated with this trait. Notably, a significant portion of these CCT-associated regions are located near or within genes known to cause Mendelian disorders, suggesting shared genetic underpinnings between complex and rare eye diseases, particularly with keratoconus.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Central corneal thickness (CCT) is a fundamental characteristic of the eye, highly heritable, and linked to serious eye conditions like keratoconus and glaucoma. While previous studies have identified genetic loci associated with CCT, a comprehensive understanding of the genetic architecture and its overlap with rare Mendelian disorders was lacking. This paper aims to expand the known genetic landscape of CCT, identify novel associated regions, and explore the functional implications of these findings, particularly their connection to complex and Mendelian eye diseases. The researchers sought to understand if genetic factors influencing CCT also play a role in the development of keratoconus and glaucoma, and if there's a shared genetic basis with rare connective tissue disorders.

Methods

The study employed a multi-stage genome-wide association study (GWAS) approach. Initially, they conducted ancestry-specific meta-analyses (European and Asian cohorts) to identify significant CCT-associated loci. Subsequently, a cross-ancestry fixed-effect meta-analysis was performed to maximize power and detect additional loci. To identify independent genetic signals within known regions, they utilized a conditional and joint multiple-SNP (CoJo) analysis. Gene-based association testing was performed using VEGAS2 to identify genes, rather than individual SNPs, associated with CCT. Finally, they investigated the clinical relevance of CCT-associated loci by testing their association with keratoconus and primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) risk. Regulatory potential of variants was explored using tools like HaploReg and RegulomeDB, and pathway analyses were conducted using VEGAS2 and INRICH to understand the biological processes implicated.

Datasets

The study utilized data from multiple large-scale cohorts:

  • European-specific meta-analysis: 14 cohorts, N=17,803 individuals.
  • Asian-specific meta-analysis: 5 cohorts, N=8,107 individuals.
  • Cross-ancestry meta-analysis: Combined European and Asian data, N=25,910 individuals.
  • Keratoconus cohorts: 933 cases and 5,946 controls (European ancestry).
  • POAG cohorts: 5,008 cases and 35,472 controls (European ancestry).
  • Conditional and Joint (CoJo) analysis: Genotype data from 2,582 unrelated Australians from the BMES cohort was used to estimate linkage disequilibrium (LD) patterns.

The study also leveraged publicly available datasets for regulatory annotations, including ENCODE, GENCODE, and Roadmap Epigenomics projects, and the Ocular Tissue Database for gene expression information.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Complex and Mendelian Diseases: The most striking finding is the significant overlap between genetic loci influencing a common quantitative trait (CCT) and genes responsible for rare Mendelian disorders. This suggests that common genetic variations might influence susceptibility to both complex and rare diseases through shared biological pathways.
  • Shared Genetic Architecture with Keratoconus: The strong inverse correlation between CCT effect sizes and keratoconus risk indicates that genetic variants that decrease corneal thickness are likely to increase the risk of developing keratoconus. This provides compelling evidence for shared genetic influences.
  • Collagen and Extracellular Matrix (ECM) as Key Players: Pathway analyses consistently highlighted the involvement of collagen, ECM metabolism, and connective tissue-related pathways in determining CCT. This aligns with the known structural role of the corneal stroma.
  • Beyond Known Pathways: While confirming known pathways, the study also uncovered previously unreported gene sets, broadening our understanding of the molecular mechanisms underlying CCT.
  • Implication of Specific Mendelian Genes: The identification of CCT loci near genes like FBN1 (Marfan syndrome), ADAMTS2 (Ehlers-Danlos syndrome), and TGFB2 (Loeys-Dietz syndrome) directly links common variations in these genes to CCT, offering new avenues for research into these connective tissue disorders.

Key Results

  • 19 Novel CCT Loci: The cross-ancestry meta-analysis identified 44 loci associated with CCT, of which 19 were novel.
  • Significant Link to Keratoconus: A significant inverse correlation (r = -0.62, P = 5.30 × 10⁻⁵) was observed between CCT and keratoconus effect sizes. Three CCT SNPs showed significant association with keratoconus risk in the expected direction.
  • No Link to POAG: No significant correlation was found between CCT and primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) effect sizes (r = -0.17, P = 0.2).
  • Mendelian Disorder Gene Proximity: 20.5% (9 out of 44) of CCT loci were found within 1 Mb of a Mendelian disorder gene.
  • Pathway Enrichment: Pathway analyses revealed significant enrichment in collagen, ECM, basement membrane, TGF-β regulation, and skeletal system development pathways.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Causality vs. Association: While the study identifies associations, it acknowledges that the nearest gene to a lead SNP may not always be the causal gene. Further functional studies are needed to confirm the specific genes and mechanisms at each locus.
  • POAG Association: The lack of a clear association between CCT loci and POAG risk suggests that while CCT is a risk factor for POAG, the underlying genetic influences might be distinct or more complex than initially hypothesized.
  • Functional Validation: The authors emphasize the need for functional studies to validate the identified candidate genes and elucidate the precise mechanisms by which genetic variation influences CCT and related diseases.
  • Cross-ancestry Differences: While the cross-ancestry analysis increased power, subtle differences in genetic architecture between populations might exist and warrant further investigation.
  • Exploration of Regulatory Elements: The study utilized regulatory annotations, but further detailed functional experiments are required to pinpoint the precise regulatory elements and their impact on gene expression.

Summary updated

Abstract

Central corneal thickness (CCT) is a highly heritable trait associated with complex eye diseases such as keratoconus and glaucoma. We perform a genome-wide association meta-analysis of CCT and identify 19 novel regions. In addition to adding support for known connective tissue-related pathways, pathway analyses uncover previously unreported gene sets. Remarkably, >20% of the CCT-loci are near or within Mendelian disorder genes. These included FBN1, ADAMTS2 and TGFB2 which associate with connective tissue disorders (Marfan, Ehlers-Danlos and Loeys-Dietz syndromes), and the LUM-DCN-KERA gene complex involved in myopia, corneal dystrophies and cornea plana. Using index CCT-increasing variants, we find a significant inverse correlation in effect sizes between CCT and keratoconus (r = -0.62, P = 5.30 × 10<sup>-5</sup>) but not between CCT and primary open-angle glaucoma (r = -0.17, P = 0.2). Our findings provide evidence for shared genetic influences between CCT and keratoconus, and implicate candidate genes acting in collagen and extracellular matrix regulation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{iglesias2018cross,
  author = {Adriana I. Iglesias and Aniket Mishra and Véronique Vitart and Yelena Bykhovskaya and René Höhn and Henriët Springelkamp and Gabriel Cuéllar-Partida and Puya Gharahkhani and Jessica N. Cooke Bailey and Colin E. Willoughby and Xiaohui Li and Seyhan Yazar and Abhishek Nag and Anthony P. Khawaja and Ozren Polašek and David S. Siscovick and Paul Mitchell and Yih Chung Tham and Jonathan L. Haines and Lisa S. Kearns and Caroline Hayward and Yuan Shi and Jin‐Moo Lee and Kent D. Taylor and Jie Jin Wang and Elena Rochtchina and John Attia and Rodney J. Scott and Elizabeth G. Holliday and Sandra E. Staffieri and Paul N. Baird and Jing Xie and Michael Inouye and Ananth C. Viswanathan and Xueling Sim and Pieter W. M. Bonnemaijer and Jerome I. Rotter and Nicholas G. Martin and Tanja Zeller and Richard Mills and Emmanuelle Souzeau and Sandra E. Staffieri and Jost B. Jonas and Irene Schmidtmann and Thibaud Boutin and Jae H. Kang and Sionne E. M. Lucas and Sandra E. Staffieri and Manfred E. Beutel and James F. Wilson and R. Rand Allingham and Murray H. Brilliant and Donald L. Budenz and William G. Christen and John H. Fingert and David S. Friedman and Douglas Gaasterland and Terry Gaasterland and Michael A. Hauser and Peter Kraft and Richard K. Lee and Paul R. Lichter and Yutao Liu and Stephanie Loomis and Sayoko E. Moroi and Margaret A. Pericak‐Vance and Anthony Realini and Julia E. Richards and Joel S. Schuman and William K. Scott and Kuldev Singh and Arthur J. Sit and Douglas Vollrath and Robert N. Weinreb and Gadi Wollstein and Donald J. Zack and Kang Zhang and David M. Evans and Inês Barroso and Jenefer M. Blackwell and Elvira Bramon and Matthew A. Brown and Juan P. Casas and Aiden Corvin and Panos Deloukas and Audrey Duncanson and Janusz Jankowski and Hugh S. Markus and Christopher G. Mathew and Christopher G. Mathew and Robert Plomin and Anna Rautanen and Stephen Sawcer and Richard C. Trembath and Nicholas Wood and Chris C. A. Spencer and Gavin Band and Céline Bellenguez and Colin L. Freeman and Garrett Hellenthal},
  title = {{Cross-ancestry genome-wide association analysis of corneal thickness strengthens link between complex and Mendelian eye diseases}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-018-03646-6},
}
Figure