Criticality, factorization, and long-range correlations in the anisotropic<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mrow><mml:mi>X</mml:mi><mml:mi>Y</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:math>model

Steve Campbell, Jonathan G. Richens, N. Lo Gullo, Thomas BuschPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We investigate long-range quantum correlations in the anisotropic $XY$ model, demonstrating that quantum discord serves as a robust figure of merit for capturing critical features in the thermodynamic limit at both zero and finite temperatures. By analyzing large site separations, we identify a simple scaling behavior that facilitates the estimation of critical points under thermal conditions. Furthermore, we explore ground-state factorization in finite-size systems, linking it to energy spectrum crossings and explaining its persistence at finite temperatures. Finally, state fidelity calculations reveal that remarkably small systems can accurately approximate the thermodynamic limit.

Introduction

Quantum Phase Transitions (QPTs) in many-body systems are characterized by sudden changes in the ground state properties driven by quantum fluctuations. Traditionally, entanglement has been the primary tool for diagnosing these transitions. However, entanglement is often short-ranged and fragile, particularly at finite temperatures. This study explores the anisotropic $XY$ model to determine if alternative measures, specifically quantum discord, can provide a more comprehensive understanding of criticality and long-range correlations.

Quantum Discord as a Long-Range Probe

A significant limitation of entanglement, such as the Entanglement of Formation (EoF), is its "monogamy" and rapid decay with distance. In the $XY$ model, entanglement between spins typically vanishes beyond a few lattice sites. In contrast, quantum discord ($\mathcal{D}$)—which encompasses both entanglement and other non-classical correlations—persists over much larger distances.

Comparison of entanglement and quantum discord across varying site separations $r$ and transverse fields $\lambda$.

As shown in Figure 1, while entanglement $\mathcal{E}$ quickly drops to zero as the separation $r$ increases, quantum discord $\mathcal{D}$ remains non-zero. Crucially, the derivative of discord with respect to the transverse field $\lambda$ exhibits a sharp peak at the critical point $\lambda = 1$, even for large $r$. This makes discord an effective "long-range sensor" for detecting phase transitions where entanglement fails.

Thermal Scaling and Criticality

Real-world quantum systems are rarely at absolute zero. Thermal fluctuations can smear out the signatures of QPTs. The authors propose an "Estimated Thermal Critical Point" (ETCP) based on the maxima of the discord derivative at finite temperatures $T$. They find that for sufficiently large site separations, these points follow a predictable scaling law: $\lambda_{T_c} = \alpha T^\nu + 1$.

Scaling of the estimated thermal critical point $\lambda_{T_c}$ as a function of temperature $T$.

Figure 4 illustrates this scaling behavior for various anisotropy parameters $\gamma$. The excellent fit between the numerical data and the scaling ansatz suggests a universal method for locating critical regions in thermalized spin chains, particularly when focusing on long-range correlations that filter out short-range non-critical noise.

Factorization and Finite-Size Fidelity

The model also exhibits "factorization," where at a specific field strength $\lambda_f = \sqrt{1-\gamma^2}$, the ground state becomes a simple product state with zero correlations. The study reveals that this phenomenon is intrinsically linked to an energy level crossing in finite systems. Because of the energy gap between the ground and first excited states, this factorization point remains identifiable even at finite temperatures.

Furthermore, the research addresses the practical question of system size. By calculating the fidelity between the ground states of finite chains ($N$ spins) and the infinite thermodynamic limit, the authors found that for $N=10$, the fidelity exceeds 0.995 across most of the parameter space. This high degree of similarity indicates that small-scale quantum simulators can effectively model infinite-system physics.

Conclusion

This work establishes quantum discord as a superior metric for studying long-range criticality and thermal effects in spin chains. The discovery of robust scaling laws and the high fidelity of small-system approximations provide valuable tools for both theoretical many-body physics and the development of practical quantum simulation platforms. Future research may extend these findings to non-integrable systems and higher-dimensional lattices.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the long-range quantum correlations in the anisotropic $XY$ model. By first examining the thermodynamic limit, we show that employing the quantum discord as a figure of merit allows one to capture the main features of the model at zero temperature. Furthermore, by considering suitably large site separations we find that these correlations obey a simple scaling behavior for finite temperatures, allowing for efficient estimation of the critical point. We also address ground-state factorization of this model by explicitly considering finite-size systems, showing its relation to the energy spectrum and explaining the persistence of the phenomenon at finite temperatures. Finally, we compute the fidelity between finite and infinite systems in order to show that remarkably small system sizes can closely approximate the thermodynamic limit.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{campbell2013criticality,
  author = {Steve Campbell and Jonathan G. Richens and N. Lo Gullo and Thomas Busch},
  title = {{Criticality, factorization, and long-range correlations in the anisotropic<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mrow><mml:mi>X</mml:mi><mml:mi>Y</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:math>model}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physreva.88.062305},
}
Figure