Critical State Calculation of Saddle-Shaped Unstable Region of the Axial-Flow Pump Based on Bifurcation SST k–ω Model

Kaiwen Pang, Xianbei Huang, Kai Yu, Baoyun Qiu, Qiang GuoJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a more accurate method for identifying the "critical state" of axial-flow pumps, a condition that can lead to instability and reduced efficiency. By using a modified turbulence model and analyzing pressure fluctuations at specific rotating points, the researchers propose a new criterion that overcomes the limitations of traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Axial-flow pumps, crucial for water transfer and supply, can enter an "unstable saddle-shaped region" during operation. This region is problematic because it can cause internal flow disturbances, hydraulic vibrations, and a sharp decline in efficiency. Identifying the precise "critical state" – the point at which the pump transitions into this unstable region – is vital for preventing these issues. However, existing methods for identifying this state have drawbacks. For instance, relying on the inflection point of the head-flow curve can be misleading due to a lag in observable changes. Similarly, using fixed monitoring points for pressure fluctuations has proven insensitive to the subtle shifts that occur at the critical state. This paper aims to address this gap by developing a more reliable criterion for detecting the critical state.

Methods

The researchers employed a modified turbulence model called the "bifurcation SST k–ω model" (BSKO model). This model is an adaptation of the standard SST k–ω model, specifically enhanced to account for the rotational effects present in pumps. The reliability of this BSKO model was first validated using numerical simulations of a water jet pump, comparing its performance against experimental data. Once validated, the BSKO model was applied to simulate the critical state of an axial-flow pump.

To pinpoint the critical state, the study focused on analyzing pressure fluctuations. While traditional approaches used fixed monitoring points, this research emphasized the importance of rotating monitoring points. Specifically, they arranged sensors at the leading edge of the blade suction near the shroud, which rotate with the impeller. The pressure fluctuation signals from these points were analyzed using Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) to examine their frequency domain characteristics.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention or introduce new datasets for training. Instead, it relies on:

  • Experimental data from a water jet pump (AxWJ-2): Used to validate the BSKO turbulence model.
  • Numerical simulation results of an axial-flow pump: The primary dataset generated by the authors' simulations to study the critical state.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Head-flow inflection point is insufficient: The study found that the head of the pump starts to decline at 0.55Qd, but significant internal flow changes, like vortex formation, occur earlier at 0.6Qd. This lag means the head-flow inflection point is not a precise indicator of the critical state.
  • Fixed monitoring points are unreliable: Pressure fluctuation signals at fixed locations within the pump showed little change in amplitude, main frequency, or periodicity at the critical state, making them unsuitable for accurate detection.
  • Rotating monitoring points are key: The critical state is best identified by monitoring pressure fluctuations at points that rotate with the impeller, particularly near the leading edge of the blade suction close to the shroud.
  • A new criterion emerges: The critical state is characterized by a significant shift in the main frequency of the pressure fluctuation signal and a substantial increase (approximately 10-fold) in its amplitude, accompanied by an increase in low-frequency fluctuations.

Key Results

  • Vortex formation precedes head decline: Leading-edge separation vortices were observed to form at 0.6Qd, while the head decline only became apparent at 0.55Qd.
  • BSKO model validation: The BSKO model demonstrated good agreement with experimental performance curves of a water jet pump, with average relative errors for head, efficiency, and power coefficients below 2.6%.
  • Proposed critical state criterion: A significant change in the pressure fluctuation signal at a rotating monitoring point near the blade suction shroud, specifically a 10-fold amplitude increase and a main frequency shift, reliably indicates the onset of the critical state.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study primarily focuses on numerical simulations. While the BSKO model was validated against experimental data for a water jet pump, direct experimental validation of the proposed critical state criterion on the axial-flow pump itself is not presented.
  • The paper mentions that the "viscosity term is too small to be ignored" in the vorticity transport equation but proceeds without considering it. This simplification might have minor implications.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that experimental validation of the proposed criterion on the axial-flow pump would be beneficial.
  • Further investigation into the influence of different pump designs and operating conditions on the critical state and the effectiveness of the proposed criterion could be explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study aims to investigate the critical state of the saddle-shaped unstable region of the axial-flow pump and propose a suitable criterion for identifying this state. The bifurcation SST k–ω model considered the rotation effect is used in the present work and verified in the numerical calculation of a water jet pump. Then, it is used to simulate the critical state of the axial-flow pump. Results show that the leading-edge separation vortex generates at 0.6Qd, while the head declines only at 0.55Qd. Therefore, using the inflection point of the head-flow curve as the critical state criterion is unsuitable. In addition, the fixed monitoring point is unsuitable for identifying the critical state due to the insensitivity to the amplitude, main frequency, and periodicity changes at the critical state. Finally, to identify the critical state, it is essential to arrange a monitoring point at the leading edge of the blade suction near the shroud, which should rotate with the impeller. The critical state criterion is that the main frequency position of the pressure fluctuation signal is offset at the monitoring point, and the amplitude is increased by 10 times.
BibTeX
@article{pang2023critical,
  author = {Kaiwen Pang and Xianbei Huang and Kai Yu and Baoyun Qiu and Qiang Guo},
  title = {{Critical State Calculation of Saddle-Shaped Unstable Region of the Axial-Flow Pump Based on Bifurcation SST k–ω Model}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse11081549},
}
Figure