Critical Role of Surface Energy in Guiding Crystallization of Solution-Coated Conjugated Polymer Thin Films

Fengjiao Zhang, Erfan Mohammadi, Xuyi Luo, Joseph Strzalka, Jianguo Mei, Ying DiaoLangmuir 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper establishes a clear link between substrate surface energy and the morphology and charge transport properties of solution-coated conjugated polymer thin films. By systematically varying surface energy and developing a free energy model, the authors provide crucial design rules for optimizing these materials for electronic applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The performance of organic electronic devices, particularly those based on semiconducting polymers, is highly sensitive to the morphology of the thin films. This morphology, in turn, is strongly influenced by the substrate on which the film is deposited. However, despite this known relationship, a lack of established design rules for selecting appropriate substrates has hindered the rational development of these materials. This paper aims to bridge this gap by systematically investigating how substrate surface energy dictates thin film morphology and, consequently, charge transport properties, with the ultimate goal of providing predictive design guidelines.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Substrate Preparation: They functionalized silicon wafers to create a range of surface energies, utilizing self-assembled monolayers (SAMs), polymer coatings (PVP:HDA), and oxygen plasma treatments. This allowed for precise control over the surface energy from 20.5 mN/m to 67.2 mN/m.
  • Thin Film Deposition: A meniscus-guided coating technique was used to deposit thin films of a donor-acceptor (D-A) conjugated polymer (DPP2T-TT). This method was chosen for its controllability and relevance to large-scale manufacturing processes.
  • Morphology Characterization: A suite of advanced techniques was employed to analyze the film structure:
  • Cross-polarized optical microscopy (C-POM): To qualitatively assess crystallinity and molecular alignment.
  • UV-Vis spectroscopy: To quantify the degree of backbone alignment.
  • Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): To examine the mesoscale morphology and fibril formation.
  • Grazing Incidence X-ray Diffraction (GIXD): To precisely determine molecular stacking, crystallinity, and in-plane orientation.
  • Device Fabrication and Characterization: Organic field-effect transistors (OFETs) were fabricated using both top-gate and bottom-gate configurations to measure charge carrier mobility.
  • Free Energy Modeling: A classical nucleation theory-based model was developed to quantitatively relate substrate surface energy to the heterogeneous nucleation barrier in thin films.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements rather than pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Surface Energy is King: The study unequivocally demonstrates that substrate surface energy is a primary determinant of conjugated polymer thin film morphology. Lower surface energies consistently lead to improved crystallinity, molecular ordering, and domain alignment.
  • Nucleation Barrier Modulation: The authors propose and validate a compelling hypothesis: substrate surface energy dictates thin film morphology by modulating the free energy barrier to heterogeneous nucleation. Lower surface energy substrates reduce this barrier, allowing for more ordered growth.
  • Morphology-Performance Link: The improved morphology directly translates to significantly enhanced charge transport properties. A 10-fold increase in charge carrier mobility was observed on the lowest surface energy substrate.
  • Model Predicts Trends: The developed free energy model successfully predicts the observed trends in surface-energy-dependent morphology, providing a powerful tool for rational material design.
  • Beyond Morphology: The study also highlights the critical role of substrate chemistry in influencing interfacial trap density, which can further impact device performance, especially in bottom-gate devices.

Key Results

  • Substrate surface energy was successfully tuned from 20.5 mN/m to 67.2 mN/m.
  • Decreasing surface energy led to a ~22% increase in crystallinity and a 14% decrease in FWHM (indicating improved molecular ordering).
  • In-plane alignment improved significantly, with the GIXD dichroic ratio increasing from ~1 (isotropic) to 5.2 on the lowest surface energy substrate.
  • Top-gate OFETs showed a 10-fold increase in hole mobility (from 0.03 ± 0.01 cm²/Vs to 0.22-0.29 cm²/Vs) when moving from high to low surface energy substrates.
  • Bottom-gate OFETs exhibited a three-orders-of-magnitude change in mobility due to the combined effects of morphology and interfacial trap density.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model's Quantitative Limits: While the free energy model accurately predicts trends, it does not quantitatively predict morphology changes, particularly abrupt transitions observed between certain substrates.
  • Other Influencing Factors: The authors acknowledge that other factors, such as domain growth rate, solvent evaporation, and fluid flow, can also play significant roles in determining final morphology and are not fully captured by the current model.
  • Generalizability: While the study validates the model's generality with a second polymer (PII-2T) and a different deposition technique (spin-coating), further exploration with a wider range of polymers and solvents is warranted.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that their methodology and mechanistic understanding can be used for the rational selection of solvents and substrates to promote thin film crystallization and enhance solid-state properties in organic semiconductors.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is well-known that substrate surface properties have a profound impact on the morphology of thin films solution coated atop and the resulting solid-state properties. However, design rules for guiding the substrate selection have not yet been established. Such design rules are particularly important for solution-coated semiconducting polymers, as the substrate-directed thin film morphology can impact charge transport properties by orders of magnitude. We hypothesize that substrate surface energies dictate the thin film morphology by modulating the free energy barrier to heterogeneous nucleation. To test this hypothesis, we systematically vary the substrate surface energy via surface functionalization techniques. We perform in-depth morphology and device characterizations to establish the relationship between substrate surface energy, thin film morphology and charge transport properties, employing donor-acceptor (D-A) conjugated polymers. We find that decreasing the substrate surface energy progressively increases thin film crystallinity, degree of molecular ordering, and extent of domain alignment. Notably, the enhanced morphology on the lowest surface energy substrate leads to a 10-fold increase in the charge carrier mobility. We further develop a free energy model relating the substrate surface energy to the penalty of heterogeneous nucleation from solution in the thin film geometry. The model correctly predicts the experimental trend, thereby validating our hypothesis. This work is a significant step toward establishing design rules and understanding the critical role of substrates in determining morphology of solution-coated thin films.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2017critical,
  author = {Fengjiao Zhang and Erfan Mohammadi and Xuyi Luo and Joseph Strzalka and Jianguo Mei and Ying Diao},
  title = {{Critical Role of Surface Energy in Guiding Crystallization of Solution-Coated Conjugated Polymer Thin Films}},
  booktitle = {Langmuir},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.langmuir.7b02807},
}
Figure