Critical period for vision-dependent modulation of postnatal retinal neurogenesis

Tatiana V. Tkatchenko, Tatyana V. Michurina, Stanislav I. Tomarev, Naoki Nakaya, Grigori Enikolopov, Andrei V. TkatchenkobioRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract

It is generally accepted that retinal neurogenesis in mammals ceases shortly after birth and that stem/progenitor cells found in the postnatal eyes of mice and humans are in a quiescent state. In the present study, we investigated postnatal retinal neurogenesis and its modulation by visual experience in a mouse model. Using transgenic mice expressing green fluorescent protein (GFP) under the control of nestin regulatory elements, we examined four age groups (P26, P45, P72, and P94) for the presence of proliferating progenitor cells. Contrary to previous beliefs, we found a significant number of proliferating progenitors at the retinal periphery in all age groups. Genetic cell fate mapping revealed that the majority of these cells differentiate into photoreceptors. While neurogenesis persists into adulthood, its intensity declines with age and correlates strongly with eye growth. Furthermore, visual form deprivation (VFD) significantly increased peripheral neurogenesis and ocular growth, but only during a specific "critical period" that ends around P70. This marks a definitive window for the vision-dependent modulation of postnatal retinal development.

Introduction

In the field of developmental biology, it has long been a "textbook truth" that while fish and amphibians grow new retinal cells throughout their lives, mammals cease this process shortly after birth. Any stem or progenitor cells remaining in the adult mammalian eye were thought to be permanently dormant, or quiescent. This study challenges that dogma by demonstrating that the postnatal mouse retina harbors active progenitor cells that continue to produce new neurons well into adulthood. Crucially, the research identifies a "critical period"—a specific window of time during which the retina remains sensitive to visual input and can modulate its neurogenic activity accordingly.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated toolkit of transgenic mouse models and high-resolution imaging to track retinal development:

  • Nestin-GFP Mice: These mice express Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP) under the control of nestin regulatory elements, effectively "lighting up" neural progenitor cells.
  • BrdU Labeling: A chemical tracer (BrdU) was injected to label cells actively dividing (proliferating) during specific experimental windows.
  • Genetic Cell Fate Mapping: Using a "Cre-Lox" system (Z/EG/Nestin-CreERT2 hybrid mice), the team permanently labeled progenitor cells with GFP at specific times via tamoxifen injection. This allowed them to track these cells weeks later to identify their mature neuronal types.
  • Visual Form Deprivation (VFD): To simulate blurred vision and induce experimental myopia (nearsightedness), handmade plastic diffusers were attached to one eye of the mice.
  • High-Resolution MRI: A 7-Tesla MRI system was used to precisely measure the axial length and circumference of the growing eyes to correlate physical growth with cellular activity.

Key Results

Persistent Neurogenesis in the Adult Retina

The study found proliferating progenitors in the retinal periphery—specifically the ciliary marginal zone (CMZ)—across all examined age groups, including 3-month-old "adult" mice (P94). While the intensity of neurogenesis declined with age, it did not disappear. At P26, the retina produced approximately 216 proliferating cells per millimeter of the ciliary margin; by P94, this dropped to approximately 16 cells/mm.

The Photoreceptor Factory

Fate mapping experiments revealed that the vast majority of these postnatal progenitor cells differentiate into photoreceptors. These new neurons were observed to develop mature characteristics, including outer segments and synaptic terminals, suggesting they integrate into the existing retinal architecture.

Visual Modulation and the P70 Cutoff

The most striking finding was the impact of visual experience on cell production. In young mice (P26), blurring the vision via VFD caused a massive 91% increase in the number of proliferating progenitors compared to the control eye. This increase in neurogenesis correlated almost perfectly ($R = -0.9958$) with the rate of ocular growth.

However, this plasticity is not indefinite. The susceptibility to VFD-induced neurogenesis and ocular growth declined steadily with age, ceasing completely around postnatal day 70 (P70). After this point, visual deprivation had no significant effect on the birth rate of new neurons, marking the end of the critical period for vision-dependent modulation.

Discussion and Implications

This research demonstrates that the mammalian retina is far more plastic than previously assumed. The discovery that the retina continues to produce photoreceptors postnatally—and that this process is regulated by visual input—opens new avenues for understanding myopia and retinal degeneration.

The study suggests a tight coupling between the expansion of the eye's physical dimensions and the addition of new retinal cells. The existence of a critical period ending at P70 in mice (which may correspond to ages 14–16 in humans) suggests that therapeutic interventions for vision disorders may be most effective during these early developmental windows. Future work will need to identify the specific molecular signaling cascades that translate a blurred visual image into a biological signal for progenitor cell division.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract It is generally accepted that retinal neurogenesis in mammals ceases shortly after birth and that stem/progenitor cells found in the postnatal eyes of mice and humans are in the quiescent state. In the present study, we have investigated postnatal retinal neurogenesis and its modulation by visual experience in the mouse model. Four age groups (P26, P45, P72, and P94) of transgenic mice expressing green fluorescent protein (GFP) in the retinal progenitor cells under the control of nestin regulatory elements were examined for the presence of nestin-GFP-positive proliferating progenitor cells in the retina. Contrary to the previously held belief, we found a significant number of proliferating progenitors at the retinal periphery in all age groups examined. The majority of these cells gave rise to photoreceptors as revealed by the genetic cell fate mapping experiments. The intensity of neurogenesis was declining with age, and strongly correlated with eye growth. Visual form deprivation resulted in a significant increase in the intensity of peripheral neurogenesis, which correlated strongly with the induced ocular growth. The susceptibility to both form-deprivation-induced increase in the peripheral neurogenesis and form-deprivation-induced increase in the ocular growth declined with age ceasing completely around P70, which marked the end of the critical period for the vision-dependent modulation of both ocular growth and postnatal retinal neurogenesis. Thus, neurogenesis in the peripheral retina of young mice is modulated by visual input, but only during a critical period in postnatal development.
BibTeX
@misc{tkatchenko2021critical,
  author = {Tatiana V. Tkatchenko and Tatyana V. Michurina and Stanislav I. Tomarev and Naoki Nakaya and Grigori Enikolopov and Andrei V. Tkatchenko},
  title = {{Critical period for vision-dependent modulation of postnatal retinal neurogenesis}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.08.30.458213},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure