Critical Factors of Subcontractor Evaluation and Selection: A Case Study in Vietnam

Viet-Khoa Vo-Ho, Cuong Phu Pham, Phuong Thanh Phan, Ngoc Bich Vu, My Tien Ha Duong, Loan Phuc Le, Quyen Le Hoang Thuy To NguyenJournal of Asian Finance Economics and Business 2021 · DOI

Introduction

In the rapidly evolving construction landscape of Vietnam, main contractors increasingly rely on specialized subcontractors to manage complex project requirements. This strategic outsourcing allows for a "sharing of benefits and risks," which is vital for operational efficiency. However, it introduces significant selection risk; choosing an inadequate subcontractor can trigger a cascade of project delays, budget overruns, and safety compromises. While traditional selection often prioritizes the lowest bid, such criteria are frequently insufficient in developing markets. This study addresses the need for a structured, localized framework for subcontractor evaluation in Vietnam, moving beyond subjective "gut feelings" toward a data-driven decision-making process.

Methodology

The research employed a multi-stage statistical approach to identify and categorize critical selection criteria. Initially, a comprehensive literature review identified 20 potential factors tailored to the Vietnamese context. Data was then collected via a survey of 96 industry professionals—including engineers, project managers, and supervisors—primarily based in Ho Chi Minh City.

The internal consistency of the survey data was verified using Cronbach’s Alpha, yielding a high reliability coefficient (>0.926). Subsequently, Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) using Principal Component Analysis (PCA) with Varimax rotation was performed to reduce the 20 variables into a manageable set of core factor groups. This technique uncovers the underlying structure of the data, identifying the primary dimensions that drive subcontractor selection.

Key Insights and Ideas

The EFA successfully distilled the 20 factors into four distinct dimensions that account for approximately 70% of the total variance in selection logic. These "Four Pillars" provide a comprehensive view of subcontractor suitability:

  1. Experience and Relationship: Focuses on previous history with stakeholders and project completion records.
  2. Competency: Evaluates technical staff, machinery, and safety protocols.
  3. Reputation: Considers legal compliance and transparency in cost estimation.
  4. Finance: Assesses annual revenue, profit margins, and overall asset health.
EFA results showing the four main factor groups and their explained variance.

Furthermore, the study revealed a high degree of stakeholder alignment, with a strong correlation (r = 0.786) between the rankings provided by contractors and supervisors. This suggests a maturing industry where different parties share a common understanding of subcontractor quality.

Key Results

The analysis identified "Reputation" (Mean: 4.41) as the single most influential factor, surpassing even "Price clarity" (Mean: 4.31). This finding underscores that in the Vietnamese market, the perceived risk of failure associated with an unproven subcontractor outweighs the potential savings of a lower bid.

The top five critical factors identified are:

  1. Reputation
  2. Price clarity (itemized bid price)
  3. Construction techniques
  4. Ability to perform as committed
  5. Subcontractor competence (qualified engineers and technicians)
Table of ranked subcontractor selection factors based on mean scores.

Statistical indicators confirmed the robustness of the model, with a Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (KMO) value of 0.811. The "Experience and Relationship" group emerged as the most significant dimension, explaining 22.04% of the total variance.

Conclusion

While this study provides a robust framework for subcontractor selection in Vietnam, it is limited by its sample size and regional focus. Future research should aim for a larger, more geographically diverse sample to enhance generalizability. Additionally, the authors suggest integrating these identified factors into Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) models, such as the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), to develop automated scoring systems for real-time bidding scenarios.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{voho2021critical,
  author = {Viet-Khoa Vo-Ho and Cuong Phu Pham and Phuong Thanh Phan and Ngoc Bich Vu and My Tien Ha Duong and Loan Phuc Le and Quyen Le Hoang Thuy To Nguyen},
  title = {{Critical Factors of Subcontractor Evaluation and Selection: A Case Study in Vietnam}},
  journal = {Journal of Asian Finance Economics and Business},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.13106/jafeb.2021.vol8.no3.0297},
}
Figure