Criteria for detection of possible risk factors for mental health problems in undergraduate university students

Daiki Ishimaru, Hiroyoshi Adachi, Teruhiro Mizumoto, Viktor Erdélyi, Hajime Nagahara, Shizuka Shirai, Haruo Takemura, Noriko Takemura, Mehrasa Alizadeh, Teruo Higashino, Yasushi Yagi, Manabu IkedaFrontiers in Psychiatry 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Mental health disorders often peak during late adolescence and early adulthood, yet university students frequently delay seeking help. This study establishes a data-driven framework for identifying undergraduate students at high risk for mental health problems using non-clinical indicators like sleep, diet, and study engagement. Academic staff should detect students who meet these criteria at the earliest and provide mental health support to reduce the duration of untreated illness (DUI) among undergraduate university students.

Introduction

University students are a vulnerable population for mental health issues, yet they often suffer from a long Duration of Untreated Illness (DUI) due to stigma or lack of self-awareness. Delayed intervention is linked to poorer clinical outcomes and higher dropout rates. While clinical assessments are the gold standard, they are often inaccessible in a general academic setting. This research, published in Frontiers in Psychiatry, seeks to bridge this gap by identifying "indirect" risk factors—lifestyle habits and school adaptation—that are easier for academic staff to monitor but still highly predictive of a student's mental state.

Methods and Study Population

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study of first-year students at Osaka University during the COVID-19 pandemic (Summer 2020). From an initial pool of 3,294 respondents, 1,644 students were selected for final analysis based on complete data and regular affiliation.

Flow chart of study participants and classification into high-risk groups based on depression and fatigue.

Students were categorized as "high-risk" if they reported both subjective depression and fatigue. The study utilized the Utrecht Work Engagement Scale for Students (UWES-S-J) to measure study engagement (vigor, dedication, and absorption) alongside self-reported sleep duration and meal frequency. To determine exact numerical thresholds (cut-off points), the team employed Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves and the Youden index.

Key Results and Predictive Criteria

The analysis revealed that a staggering 30.1% of the sample met the criteria for the high-risk group. The ROC analysis yielded three specific criteria for identifying these students:

  1. Study Engagement: A UWES-S-J score of < 37.5 points (out of 84).
  2. Sleep: < 6 hours of sleep on weekdays.
  3. Nutrition: < 2.5 meals per day on average.
ROC curves showing the predictive power of study engagement (UWES-S-J), sleep duration, and meal frequency.

As shown in the ROC curves, the UWES-S-J score was the strongest predictor, with an Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.631. Interestingly, while weekday sleep duration was a significant predictor, holiday sleep was not, suggesting that the inability to maintain a healthy schedule under academic pressure is a primary red flag.

Discussion and Practical Application

The authors intentionally chose cut-off points with high sensitivity (73%–82%). In an early-detection context, it is preferable to "over-flag" students for a check-in than to miss those who are truly struggling. Study engagement serves as a powerful proxy for deteriorating mental health; a drop in "vigor" or "dedication" to studies often precedes clinical crisis.

Limitations

Because the study is cross-sectional, it cannot determine causality (e.g., whether poor sleep causes depression or vice versa). Additionally, the data was collected during the COVID-19 pandemic, which may have influenced the prevalence of mental health issues and altered normal study habits. Future work may involve using "sensing technology" like wearables to automate the collection of these metrics for real-time monitoring.

Conclusion

By establishing specific cut-off values for accessible lifestyle metrics, this study provides academic staff with a practical toolkit to identify students who may need support. Early intervention based on these non-clinical signs can significantly reduce DUI and improve the long-term well-being of undergraduate students.

Summary updated

Abstract

Academic staff should detect students who meet these criteria at the earliest and provide mental health support to reduce DUI among undergraduate university students.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ishimaru2023criteria,
  author = {Daiki Ishimaru and Hiroyoshi Adachi and Teruhiro Mizumoto and Viktor Erdélyi and Hajime Nagahara and Shizuka Shirai and Haruo Takemura and Noriko Takemura and Mehrasa Alizadeh and Teruo Higashino and Yasushi Yagi and Manabu Ikeda},
  title = {{Criteria for detection of possible risk factors for mental health problems in undergraduate university students}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1184156},
}
Figure