CRISPR-mediated germline mutagenesis for genetic sterilization of Anopheles gambiae males

Andrea L. Smidler, Eryney Marrogi, Jamie Kauffman, Douglas G. Paton, Kathleen A. Westervelt, George M. Church, Kevin M. Esvelt, W. Robert Shaw, Flaminia CatterucciaScientific 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have adapted CRISPR-Cas9 technology to genetically sterilize male Anopheles gambiae mosquitoes, the primary vectors of malaria. This novel approach creates sterile males that are still competitive in mating, offering a promising new tool for the Sterile Insect Technique (SIT) to control malaria transmission.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Malaria remains a devastating global health challenge, and while current control methods like insecticide-treated nets and spraying have made progress, the rapid spread of insecticide resistance in mosquito populations threatens their long-term effectiveness. The Sterile Insect Technique (SIT) is a powerful, environmentally friendly method that involves releasing sterile males to mate with wild females, thereby reducing the overall population. However, adapting SIT to Anopheles mosquitoes has been difficult. Traditional sterilization methods (irradiation, chemicals) often impair male competitiveness, reducing their effectiveness in the field. This paper tackles the challenge of creating highly effective, genetically sterile Anopheles males that retain their mating ability, thereby overcoming a major hurdle in applying SIT to malaria vectors.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the precise application of CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing. The authors designed a system that targets the zero population growth (zpg) gene, which is crucial for germ cell development in Anopheles gambiae. They created two transgenic mosquito lines: one expressing Cas9 (the gene-editing enzyme) in its germline, and another expressing guide RNAs (gRNAs) specifically designed to target the zpg gene.

When these two lines are crossed, the resulting F1 offspring inherit both transgenes. The Cas9 enzyme, guided by the gRNAs, then induces mutations in the zpg gene within the developing germ cells of male mosquitoes. This process results in mosaic mutagenesis, meaning that not all cells are affected, but a significant proportion of germ cells in the testes are mutated. The researchers also incorporated a fluorescence reporter (Vas2-EYFP) to help identify males with defective germlines.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Targeted Sterilization Preserves Competitiveness: The most significant insight is that by precisely targeting a specific gene essential for sperm development (zpg) using CRISPR, it's possible to achieve genetic sterilization without severely compromising the male mosquito's ability to mate. This is a critical advantage over older methods that often rendered males weak and uncompetitive.
  • Mosaic Mutagenesis is Sufficient: The study demonstrates that even mosaic mutagenesis (where only some germ cells are affected) is enough to render the majority of males completely sterile. This suggests that a high degree of genetic disruption is not necessary for effective sterilization.
  • Fluorescence Screening Enhances Purity: The use of a Vas2-EYFP fluorescence reporter proved highly effective in identifying and selecting males with defective germlines, leading to a near-perfect selection of spermless males for experiments. This is a practical advancement for generating homogenous populations of sterile males.
  • Population Suppression Achieved in Lab: The competitive cage assays showed that these genetically sterile males, even with some fitness costs, could significantly reduce mosquito population numbers when released at field-relevant ratios, validating the potential of this approach.

Key Results

  • High Sterility Rate: Approximately 95% of the mutagenized male mosquitoes displayed complete genetic sterilization, meaning they produced no viable sperm.
  • Effective Infertility Induction: Females mated to these sterile males experienced similarly high levels of infertility.
  • Accurate Selection: Using the Vas2-EYFP fluorescence reporter allowed for 100% accurate selection of spermless males.
  • Population Reduction: In competition cages with wild-type males, the sterile males caused a striking reduction in mosquito population size, with an 83% decrease in hatched larvae observed.
  • Fitness Costs: While effective, the transgenic males showed some fitness costs, being approximately 4.1 times less likely to mate than wild-type males, likely due to the transgene's presence or position.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future directions:

  • Incomplete Penetrance: While 95% of males were sterile, 5% showed some level of fertility. Future work could involve using additional gRNAs or targeting other fertility genes to achieve near 100% sterility.
  • Female Sterilization: The current system does not automatically eliminate females from the released population, which is a requirement for SIT. Combining this genetic sterility with genetic sex separation systems (e.g., CRISPR targeting femaleless genes) is a necessary next step.
  • Large-Scale Production: Developing methods for large-scale production of these sterile males is crucial. The current system requires maintaining two transgenic lines, which is manageable but could be optimized.
  • Field Applicability: While promising, the system needs further optimization for field settings. This includes reducing fitness costs associated with transgenesis and conducting semi-field trials to compare its effectiveness against traditional sterilization methods.
  • Biological Questions: The availability of spermless males opens avenues for exploring the role of sperm in regulating female post-mating responses, which is still not fully understood.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rapid spread of insecticide resistance among anopheline mosquitoes threatens malaria elimination efforts, necessitating development of alternative vector control technologies. Sterile insect technique (SIT) has been successfully implemented in multiple insect pests to suppress field populations by the release of large numbers of sterile males, yet it has proven difficult to adapt to Anopheles vectors. Here we outline adaptation of a CRISPR-based genetic sterilization system to selectively ablate male sperm cells in the malaria mosquito Anopheles gambiae. We achieve robust mosaic biallelic mutagenesis of zero population growth (zpg, a gene essential for differentiation of germ cells) in F1 individuals after intercrossing a germline-expressing Cas9 transgenic line to a line expressing zpg-targeting gRNAs. Approximately 95% of mutagenized males display complete genetic sterilization, and cause similarly high levels of infertility in their female mates. Using a fluorescence reporter that allows detection of the germline leads to a 100% accurate selection of spermless males, improving the system. These males cause a striking reduction in mosquito population size when released at field-like frequencies in competition cages against wild type males. These findings demonstrate that such a genetic system could be adopted for SIT against important malaria vectors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{smidler2024crispr,
  author = {Andrea L. Smidler and Eryney Marrogi and Jamie Kauffman and Douglas G. Paton and Kathleen A. Westervelt and George M. Church and Kevin M. Esvelt and W. Robert Shaw and Flaminia Catteruccia},
  title = {{CRISPR-mediated germline mutagenesis for genetic sterilization of Anopheles gambiae males}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-54498-8},
}
Figure