Creation of a Digital Library by the Communities and for the Communities

He Daqing, Daqing He, Dan Wu, Wayne Graves, Martin KleinData Inf. Manag 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper summarizes a panel discussion at JCDL 2019 focused on the future of the ACM Digital Library (ACM DL). It highlights the need for community-driven development to create a more user-centered and collaborative digital library, addressing current barriers and exploring new features for improved access and personalization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ACM Digital Library (ACM DL) is a vital resource for the computing community, serving as a repository for a vast collection of ACM publications. However, the rapidly evolving landscape of digital content publishing and the increasing diversity of digital artifacts necessitate a re-evaluation of how such libraries are developed and function. The paper addresses the challenge of ensuring that digital libraries like ACM DL remain relevant, user-friendly, and adaptable to the evolving needs of their communities. Specifically, it tackles the question of how to foster a collaborative relationship between the digital library community and ACM DL to identify critical barriers and guide future development towards more user-centered services.

Methods

The core of this paper is a summary of a panel discussion and subsequent Q&A session. The panel itself was structured around four presentations:

  • ACM DL Visions, Goals, and New Roadmap: This presentation provided a historical overview of ACM DL and outlined its ongoing improvement efforts, focusing on scalability and the diversity of artifacts handled.
  • ACM DL Users' Views on Access and Organization: This presentation shared results from an online survey conducted to understand user perspectives on accessing and organizing information within ACM DL, both current and future.
  • ACM DL Users' Views on Personalization and Notification: Another presentation based on the same survey, this focused on user attitudes towards personalization and notification features within the DL.
  • Piloting a ResourceSync Interface for the ACM DL: This presentation introduced a technical approach using sitemaps and HTTP links to enable a pull-based, machine-accessible interface for ACM DL resources, aiming to improve interoperability.

The "methods" for generating the insights in this paper are therefore primarily qualitative, stemming from the synthesis of these presentations and the subsequent open discussion. The survey conducted for the panel served as a data collection method for the presentations on user views.

Datasets

The paper mentions an online survey conducted using Wuhan University's resources between May 12, 2019, and May 22, 2019. This survey collected responses from 146 individuals (63 male, 80 female) across various disciplines and age groups, with a majority from East Asia. The survey focused on user access, organization, personalization, and notification preferences related to the ACM DL. No other specific datasets are mentioned for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Community-Driven Development is Crucial: The overarching theme is that digital libraries should be built "by the communities and for the communities." This implies a need for active collaboration between ACM DL developers and the broader digital library community.
  • Beyond Just Publications: Users increasingly view ACM DL not just as a paper collection but as a knowledge repository. This suggests a need for richer content types (datasets, figures, tables, supplementary materials) and diverse access formats (HTML5 beyond PDF).
  • Personalization is Key, but Varies by User: Users desire personalized experiences, but preferences differ significantly based on region, user group (student vs. non-student), and academic vs. non-academic roles. For instance, students might prioritize social platforms, while non-students focus on recent publications and citations.
  • Subject Area Focus is Important: While search is critical, users also heavily rely on browsing by subject areas, special interest groups, and classification schemes. Improving these organizational structures is vital.
  • Interoperability Through Standards: Technical approaches like ResourceSync and Signposting, leveraging HTTP links, are seen as promising for enhancing interoperability between systems and making ACM DL resources more machine-accessible.
  • Balancing Features and Privacy: The introduction of personalization and notification features raises concerns about privacy and the potential for misuse. ACM DL aims to address this by being transparent and not selling user data.

Key Results

  • Survey Highlights Diverse Motivations: The survey revealed that users have different motivations for engaging with ACM DL. Some seek updates on specific topics or recent publications, while others focus on getting familiar with a subject area or finding specific authors.
  • User Preferences for New Features: Users expressed interest in features like customizable interfaces, intelligent notifications, personalized search results, social platforms for sharing research, and improved access to supplementary materials.
  • Technical Advancements in Progress: The development of a new ACM DL site (dlnext.acm.org) is underway, incorporating features like article classification, filtering, query suggestion, and cross-language search.
  • ResourceSync Piloting: A pilot for a ResourceSync interface was presented, demonstrating a standardized, machine-accessible way to access ACM DL resources, moving away from individual FTP access.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Opt-Out Mechanisms Needed: The paper acknowledges the need for users to be able to opt-out of certain features if they are not interested, ensuring a personalized experience without being overwhelmed.
  • Ensuring a Safe Space: Concerns were raised about potential social network-like issues (bullying, harassment) with increased user interaction. ACM DL plans to rely on community moderation and flagging systems.
  • Evaluating Organizations and Individuals: A key area for future work is developing better ways for administrators to evaluate organizations and individuals within communities, potentially through enhanced author page representations and metrics.
  • Improving Search Beyond Google: While ACM DL aims to improve its academic search capabilities, the paper acknowledges the challenge of competing with general search engines like Google and leaves the judgment to users.
  • Collaboration and Experimentation: The authors emphasize the need for ongoing collaboration and suggest creating opportunities for the community to experiment with new ideas and contribute to the development of ACM DL.
  • Balancing Recommendation Scope and Privacy: Future work will focus on expanding the scope of recommendations while carefully considering privacy implications and ensuring user data is protected.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{daqing2020creation,
  author = {He Daqing and Daqing He and Dan Wu and Wayne Graves and Martin Klein},
  title = {{Creation of a Digital Library by the Communities and for the Communities}},
  journal = {Data Inf. Manag},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.2478/dim-2020-0001},
}
Figure