COVID-19 Plateau: A Phenomenon of Epidemic Development under Adaptive Prevention Strategies

Ziqiang Wu, Hao Liao, Alexandre Vidmer, Ming-Yang Zhou, Wei ChenarXiv 2020 · OpenReview

Abstract

Since the beginning of the COVID-19 spreading, the number of studies on the epidemic models increased dramatically. It is important for policymakers to know how the disease will spread and what are the effects of the policies and environment on the spreading. In this paper, we propose two extensions to the standard SIR model: (a) we consider the prevention measures adopted based on the current severity of the infection. Those measures are adaptive and change over time; (b) multiple cities and regions are considered, with population movements between those cities and regions, while taking into account that each region may have different prevention measures. Although the adaptive measures and mobility of the population were often observed during the pandemic, these effects are rarely explicitly modeled and studied in the classical epidemic models. The model we propose gives rise to a plateau phenomenon: the number of people infected by the disease stays at the same level during an extended period of time. We show what are conditions need to be met in order for the spreading to exhibit a plateau period in a single city. In addition, this phenomenon is interdependent when considering multiple cities. We verify from the real-world data that the plateau phenomenon does exist in many regions of the world in the current COVID-19 development. Finally, we provide theoretical analysis on the plateau phenomenon for the single-city model and derive a series of results on the emergence and the ending of the plateau, as well as on the height and length of the plateau. Our theoretical results match well with our experimental findings.

Introduction

Standard epidemiological models, such as the Susceptible-Infected-Recovered (SIR) model, typically predict a "bell curve" trajectory: infections rise to a peak and then decline as herd immunity is reached or static interventions take hold. However, the COVID-19 pandemic revealed a different pattern in many regions: the "plateau phenomenon," where the number of active cases remains relatively stable for extended periods.

This paper argues that traditional models fail to capture this because they treat prevention measures as static. In reality, public health policy operates as a feedback loop—restrictions tighten as cases rise and relax as they fall. By modeling this adaptive behavior and the impact of inter-city mobility, we can explain why these plateaus emerge and how they can be managed.

Methodology: Modeling Adaptive Prevention and Mobility

To capture the dynamics of the pandemic more accurately, we introduced two major extensions to the standard SIR framework:

  1. Adaptive Prevention Strategy: We introduced a prevention threshold ($\theta$). If new daily cases exceed this threshold, the contact rate ($r$) is reduced through stricter measures. Conversely, if cases remain below the threshold for a set period (e.g., 14 days), measures are relaxed, and the contact rate increases. A "reaction speed" parameter ($k$) accounts for delays in policy implementation and public compliance.
  2. Multi-City Mobility Model: Recognizing that regions are interconnected, we modeled population movement between cities. This allows for the study of how a plateau in one city might be synchronized with or exported to another.
Comparison of infection dynamics under constant vs. adaptive strategies in single and multi-city environments.

Our model was validated using real-world data from the DXY platform. Out of 213 countries analyzed, 77 exhibited a clear plateau phenomenon lasting more than one month. Detailed fitting for countries like Poland and the Philippines showed high accuracy, with coefficients of determination ($D^2$) exceeding 0.90.

Key Insights: The Plateau as a Managed Steady State

A central finding of this research is that the plateau is not a natural viral feature but a result of human intervention. It represents a state where the effective reproduction number ($R_t$) is forced to hover around 1.0 through constant policy adjustments.

One of the most significant theoretical results is the formula for plateau height ($I_P$). In an ideal model, the number of infected individuals during the plateau is directly proportional to the prevention threshold divided by the recovery rate ($I_P = \theta / \gamma$). This provides policymakers with a predictable lever: by adjusting the threshold $\theta$, they can directly influence the steady-state case load.

The effect of varying the prevention threshold (theta) on the height of the infection plateau.

Furthermore, our multi-city model demonstrates inter-city synchronization. Interestingly, even a city maintaining a constant (non-adaptive) prevention strategy can be forced into a plateau if it is connected to other cities that employ adaptive strategies. This highlights the necessity of regional and global coordination in pandemic management.

Conclusion

The plateau phenomenon represents a "low-cost" equilibrium, balancing public health requirements with economic activity by avoiding the extremes of total lockdown or unmitigated spread. While our current model simplifies certain real-world factors—such as the asymmetric speed of tightening versus relaxing measures and the impact of vaccination—it provides a robust mathematical foundation for understanding the long-term steady states observed globally. Future research will focus on integrating waning immunity and specific intervention types into this adaptive framework.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since the beginning of the COVID-19 spreading, the number of studies on the epidemic models increased dramatically. It is important for policymakers to know how the disease will spread and what are the effects of the policies and environment on the spreading. In this paper, we propose two extensions to the standard SIR model: (a) we consider the prevention measures adopted based on the current severity of the infection. Those measures are adaptive and change over time; (b) multiple cities and regions are considered, with population movements between those cities and regions, while taking into account that each region may have different prevention measures. Although the adaptive measures and mobility of the population were often observed during the pandemic, these effects are rarely explicitly modeled and studied in the classical epidemic models. The model we propose gives rise to a plateau phenomenon: the number of people infected by the disease stays at the same level during an extended period of time. We show what are conditions need to be met in order for the spreading to exhibit a plateau period in a single city. In addition, this phenomenon is interdependent when considering multiple cities. We verify from the real-world data that the plateau phenomenon does exist in many regions of the world in the current COVID-19 development. Finally, we provide theoretical analysis on the plateau phenomenon for the single-city model and derive a series of results on the emergence and the ending of the plateau, as well as on the height and length of the plateau. Our theoretical results match well with our experimental findings.
BibTeX
@misc{wu2020covid,
  author = {Ziqiang Wu and Hao Liao and Alexandre Vidmer and Ming-Yang Zhou and Wei Chen},
  title = {{COVID-19 Plateau: A Phenomenon of Epidemic Development under Adaptive Prevention Strategies}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2011.03376},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2011.03376},
}
Figure