COVID-19 incidence and R decreased on the Isle of Wight after the launch of the Test, Trace, Isolate programme

Michelle Kendall, Luke Milsom, Lucie Abeler‐Dörner, Chris Wymant, Luca Ferretti, Mark Briers, Chris Holmes, David Bonsall, Johannes Abeler, Christophe FrasermedRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

In May 2020, the UK introduced a Test, Trace, Isolate (TTI) programme in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. The programme was first rolled out on the Isle of Wight and included Version 1 of the NHS contact tracing app. We used COVID-19 daily case data to infer incidence of new infections and estimate the reproduction number $R$ for each of 150 Upper Tier Local Authorities in England, and at the National level, before and after the launch of the programme on the Isle of Wight. We used Bayesian and Maximum-Likelihood methods to estimate $R$, and compared the Isle of Wight to other areas using a synthetic control method. We observed significant decreases in incidence and $R$ on the Isle of Wight immediately after the launch. These results are robust across each of our approaches. Our results show that the sub-epidemic on the Isle of Wight was controlled significantly more effectively than the sub-epidemics of most other Upper Tier Local Authorities, changing from having the third highest reproduction number $R$ (of 150) before the intervention to the tenth lowest afterwards. While a causal link cannot yet be established, the findings highlight the need for further research to determine the causes of this reduction, as these might translate into local and national non-pharmaceutical intervention strategies.

Introduction

In the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, before the availability of vaccines or effective therapeutics, governments relied heavily on non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) to manage viral spread. While national lockdowns were effective at reducing transmission, their high economic and social costs necessitated more targeted strategies. The "Test, Trace, Isolate" (TTI) model emerged as a primary alternative, aiming to break transmission chains by identifying and isolating infected individuals and their contacts.

In May 2020, the Isle of Wight served as a unique "natural experiment" for the UK. It was the first region to roll out an integrated TTI programme, which combined manual contact tracing with a prototype smartphone app (Version 1 of the NHS app), several weeks before similar measures were implemented across the rest of England. This study quantifies the impact of this pilot by comparing the island’s epidemic trajectory against 149 other English local authorities.

Methodological Framework

To ensure the robustness of the findings, the researchers employed a multi-pronged statistical approach to analyze Pillar 1 (healthcare settings) and Pillar 2 (community) testing data:

  1. Back-calculation of Infection Times: Recognizing the lag between infection and a positive test result, the authors used lognormal and gamma distributions to estimate the actual dates of infection based on reported case data.
  2. Bayesian $R(t)$ Estimation: Using the EpiEstim package, the study estimated the instantaneous reproduction number ($R$), representing the average number of secondary infections generated by a single case.
  3. Synthetic Control Method: To account for the lack of a literal control group, the researchers constructed a "virtual" Isle of Wight. This was a weighted average of other English Upper Tier Local Authorities (UTLAs) that matched the real island's pre-intervention $R$ values, age distribution, and ethnicity.
  4. Maximum-Likelihood Estimation: As a secondary check, growth rates ($r$) and $R$ values were calculated using a separate mathematical framework to ensure consistency across different testing streams.

Key Findings

The Dramatic Shift in Transmission

The most significant finding was the relative change in the Isle of Wight’s epidemic status compared to the rest of the country. Before the TTI launch, the island was an outlier for high transmission, ranking 3rd highest for $R$ out of 150 UTLAs. Following the intervention, the island’s $R$ value plummeted, eventually ranking 10th lowest in the country.

Specifically, the Bayesian estimates showed $R$ on the Isle of Wight declining rapidly from approximately 1.0 on May 5th to 0.25 by May 23rd. Maximum-likelihood models supported this trend, estimating a drop from an $R$ of 1.3 pre-intervention to 0.5 during the study period.

Statistical Significance and Incidence

Using the synthetic control method, the difference in $R$ between the real Isle of Wight and its virtual counterpart was statistically significant at the 5% level for much of May. While per capita incidence on the island was near the national average in mid-April, it became significantly lower than the national average by late May, suggesting the intervention allowed the island to "beat" the national downward trend.

Controlling for Mobility

A critical question was whether the reduction in cases was simply due to islanders practicing stricter social distancing. However, Google Mobility Reports indicated that movement patterns on the Isle of Wight—including visits to workplaces, retail, and transit hubs—were nearly identical to the rest of the UK. This suggests that the divergence in infection rates was driven by the TTI programme rather than unique behavioral changes in mobility.

Discussion and Limitations

While the results are compelling, the authors emphasize that the study demonstrates correlation rather than definitive causation. The TTI launch was accompanied by significant local publicity, which may have increased general "COVID-awareness" and adherence to isolation protocols independently of the app's technical functionality.

During the pilot, the contact tracing app saw a 38% uptake (approximately 54,000 downloads). While the study could not perfectly isolate the app's contribution from manual tracing efforts, the speed of digital notification remains a critical theoretical advantage for suppressing fast-moving transmission chains.

Future research utilizing granular data from the Contact Tracing and Advisory Service (CTAS) and app-specific logs will be necessary to determine which specific component—testing speed, manual tracing, or digital notifications—was most responsible for the observed suppression. Additionally, the Isle of Wight's unique geography as an island may limit the direct generalizability of these findings to major mainland urban centers.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract In May 2020 the UK introduced a Test, Trace, Isolate programme in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. The programme was first rolled out on the Isle of Wight and included Version 1 of the NHS contact tracing app. We used COVID-19 daily case data to infer incidence of new infections and estimate the reproduction number R for each of 150 Upper Tier Local Authorities in England, and at the National level, before and after the launch of the programme on the Isle of Wight. We used Bayesian and Maximum-Likelihood methods to estimate R, and compared the Isle of Wight to other areas using a synthetic control method. We observed significant decreases in incidence and R on the Isle of Wight immediately after the launch. These results are robust across each of our approaches. Our results show that the sub-epidemic on the Isle of Wight was controlled significantly more effectively than the sub-epidemics of most other Upper Tier Local Authorities, changing from having the third highest reproduction number R (of 150) before the intervention to the tenth lowest afterwards. The data is not yet available to establish a causal link. However, the findings highlight the need for further research to determine the causes of this reduction, as these might translate into local and national non-pharmaceutical intervention strategies in the period before a treatment or vaccination becomes available.
BibTeX
@misc{kendall2020covid,
  author = {Michelle Kendall and Luke Milsom and Lucie Abeler‐Dörner and Chris Wymant and Luca Ferretti and Mark Briers and Chris Holmes and David Bonsall and Johannes Abeler and Christophe Fraser},
  title = {{COVID-19 incidence and R decreased on the Isle of Wight after the launch of the Test, Trace, Isolate programme}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.07.12.20151753},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure