COVID-19 Disease Map, a computational knowledge repository of SARS-CoV-2 virus-host interaction mechanisms

Marek Ostaszewski, Anna Niarakis, Alexander Mazein, Inna Kuperstein, Robert D. Phair, Aurelio Orta‐Resendiz, Vidisha Singh, Sara Sadat Aghamiri, Márcio Luís Acencio, Enrico Glaab, Andreas Ruepp, Gisela Fobo, Corinna Montrone, Barbara Brauner, Goar Frishman, Luis Cristóbal Monraz Gómez, Julia Somers, Matti Hoch, Shailendra K. Gupta, Julia Scheel, Hanna Borlinghaus, Tobias Czauderna, Falk Schreiber, Arnau Montagud, Miguel Ponce-de-León, Akira Funahashi, Yusuke Hiki, Noriko Hiroi, Takahiro Yamada, Andreas Dräger, Alina Renz, Muhammad Naveez, Zsolt Böcskei, Francesco Messina, Daniela Börnigen, Liam Fergusson, Marta Zaffira Conti, Marius Rameil, Vanessa Nakonecnij, Jakob Vanhoefer, Leonard Schmiester, Muying Wang, Emily E. Ackerman, Jason E. Shoemaker, Jeremy Zucker, Kristie Oxford, Jeremy Teuton, Ebru Kocakaya, Gökçe Yağmur Summak, Kristina Hanspers, Martina Kutmon, Susan L. Coort, Lars Eijssen, Friederike Ehrhart, Rex Devasahayam Arokia Balaya, Denise Slenter, Marvin Martens, Nhung Pham, Robin Haw, Bijay Jassal, Lisa Matthews, M Orlic-Milacic, Andrea Senff‐Ribeiro, Karen Rothfels, Veronica Shamovsky, Ralf Stephan, Cristoffer Sevilla, Thawfeek Varusai, Jean‐Marie Ravel, Rupsha Fraser, Vera Ortseifen, Silvia Marchesi, Piotr Gawron, Ewa Smula, Laurent Heirendt, Venkata Satagopam, Guanming Wu, Anders Riutta, Martin Golebiewski, Stuart Owen, Carole Goble, Xiaoming Hu, Rupert W. Overall, Dieter Maier, Angela Bauch, Benjamin M. Gyori, John A. Bachman, Carlos Vega, Valentin Grouès, Miguél Vázquez, Pablo Porras, Luana Licata, Marta Iannuccelli, Francesca Sacco, Anastasia Nesterova, Anton Yuryev, Anita de Waard, Dénes Türei, Augustin Luna, Özgün BaburbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

We describe a large-scale community effort to build an open-access, interoperable, and computable repository of COVID-19 molecular mechanisms - the COVID-19 Disease Map. We discuss the tools, platforms, and guidelines necessary for the distributed development of its contents by a multi-faceted community of biocurators, domain experts, bioinformaticians, and computational biologists. We highlight the role of relevant databases and text mining approaches in enrichment and validation of the curated mechanisms. We describe the contents of the Map and their relevance to the molecular pathophysiology of COVID-19 and the analytical and computational modelling approaches that can be applied for mechanistic data interpretation and predictions. We conclude by demonstrating concrete applications of our work through several use cases and highlight new testable hypotheses.

Introduction

The rapid onset of the COVID-19 pandemic led to an unprecedented "infodemic" of scientific data. While thousands of papers were published, knowledge remained fragmented across disparate journals, databases, and formats. Biological pathways are inherently complex, involving intricate virus-host interactions across multiple organs and cell types. To transform this raw data into actionable medical insights, a unified, high-resolution, and computable map is required—one that can be processed by algorithms to predict drug efficacy or the impact of viral mutations.

Methodology and Technical Ecosystem

The COVID-19 Disease Map is a global biocuration effort involving over 230 experts from 120 institutions. The framework is built upon three primary pillars:

  1. Standardized Biocuration: Experts manually translated literature into formal systems biology languages, specifically SBML (mathematical modeling), SBGNML (graphical notation), and GPML (WikiPathways).
  2. Interoperability: A technical ecosystem was established to allow these formats to interact. For instance, tools like CaSQ convert static diagrams into executable Boolean models.
  3. Knowledge Enrichment: Automated text-mining pipelines, such as INDRA and BioKB, scan the CORD-19 dataset to suggest and validate new interactions.
The COVID-19 Disease Map ecosystem, illustrating the workflow from manual curation to computational analysis.

Repository Contents and Data Integration

The project integrates massive data streams, including the CORD-19 literature set, interaction databases (IMEx Consortium, SIGNOR 2.0, OmniPath), and transcriptomics for validation. The resulting repository provides a structured overview of the molecular landscape of the infection, categorized by source and format.

Summary of the COVID-19 Disease Map contents, access points, and technical formats across different sources.

Key Insights and Mechanistic Modeling

The "computable" nature of the map allows for in silico experiments, enabling researchers to simulate protein knockdowns to observe effects on viral replication. Key findings include:

  • Pathway Crosstalk: The map identified interactions between IFN-1 signaling and metabolic pathways, such as heme catabolism.
  • Novel Regulators: Analysis identified potential regulators like NFE2L2, suggesting new therapeutic targets.
  • Transcription Factor Activity: Case studies mapped RNA-seq data to identify active TFs (e.g., STAT1, NFKB1) downstream of viral proteins like Nsp1 and Orf3a.
  • Apoptosis Signaling: The map revealed overactivation of circuits leading to BAX protein overexpression, explaining viral-induced cell death in lung tissue.

Limitations and Future Outlook

The COVID-19 Disease Map is a living document. Current limitations include the use of a "generic" host cell model rather than cell-type specific ones. Future iterations will aim to incorporate host susceptibility factors—such as age, genetics, and comorbidities—and improve kinetic modeling as more experimentally validated mathematical parameters become available. This foundational infrastructure serves as a blueprint for responding to future global health crises.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We describe a large-scale community effort to build an open-access, interoperable, and computable repository of COVID-19 molecular mechanisms - the COVID-19 Disease Map. We discuss the tools, platforms, and guidelines necessary for the distributed development of its contents by a multi-faceted community of biocurators, domain experts, bioinformaticians, and computational biologists. We highlight the role of relevant databases and text mining approaches in enrichment and validation of the curated mechanisms. We describe the contents of the Map and their relevance to the molecular pathophysiology of COVID-19 and the analytical and computational modelling approaches that can be applied for mechanistic data interpretation and predictions. We conclude by demonstrating concrete applications of our work through several use cases and highlight new testable hypotheses.
BibTeX
@misc{ostaszewski2020covid,
  author = {Marek Ostaszewski and Anna Niarakis and Alexander Mazein and Inna Kuperstein and Robert D. Phair and Aurelio Orta‐Resendiz and Vidisha Singh and Sara Sadat Aghamiri and Márcio Luís Acencio and Enrico Glaab and Andreas Ruepp and Gisela Fobo and Corinna Montrone and Barbara Brauner and Goar Frishman and Luis Cristóbal Monraz Gómez and Julia Somers and Matti Hoch and Shailendra K. Gupta and Julia Scheel and Hanna Borlinghaus and Tobias Czauderna and Falk Schreiber and Arnau Montagud and Miguel Ponce-de-León and Akira Funahashi and Yusuke Hiki and Noriko Hiroi and Takahiro Yamada and Andreas Dräger and Alina Renz and Muhammad Naveez and Zsolt Böcskei and Francesco Messina and Daniela Börnigen and Liam Fergusson and Marta Zaffira Conti and Marius Rameil and Vanessa Nakonecnij and Jakob Vanhoefer and Leonard Schmiester and Muying Wang and Emily E. Ackerman and Jason E. Shoemaker and Jeremy Zucker and Kristie Oxford and Jeremy Teuton and Ebru Kocakaya and Gökçe Yağmur Summak and Kristina Hanspers and Martina Kutmon and Susan L. Coort and Lars Eijssen and Friederike Ehrhart and Rex Devasahayam Arokia Balaya and Denise Slenter and Marvin Martens and Nhung Pham and Robin Haw and Bijay Jassal and Lisa Matthews and M Orlic-Milacic and Andrea Senff‐Ribeiro and Karen Rothfels and Veronica Shamovsky and Ralf Stephan and Cristoffer Sevilla and Thawfeek Varusai and Jean‐Marie Ravel and Rupsha Fraser and Vera Ortseifen and Silvia Marchesi and Piotr Gawron and Ewa Smula and Laurent Heirendt and Venkata Satagopam and Guanming Wu and Anders Riutta and Martin Golebiewski and Stuart Owen and Carole Goble and Xiaoming Hu and Rupert W. Overall and Dieter Maier and Angela Bauch and Benjamin M. Gyori and John A. Bachman and Carlos Vega and Valentin Grouès and Miguél Vázquez and Pablo Porras and Luana Licata and Marta Iannuccelli and Francesca Sacco and Anastasia Nesterova and Anton Yuryev and Anita de Waard and Dénes Türei and Augustin Luna and Özgün Babur},
  title = {{COVID-19 Disease Map, a computational knowledge repository of SARS-CoV-2 virus-host interaction mechanisms}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.10.26.356014},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure