Coverage and system efficiencies of insecticide-treated nets in Africa from 2000 to 2017

Samir Bhatt, Daniel J. Weiss, Bonnie Mappin, Ursula Dalrymple, Ewan Cameron, Donal Bisanzio, David L. Smith, Catherine L. Moyes, Andrew J. Tatem, Michael Lynch, Cristin Fergus, Joshua Yukich, Adam Bennett, Thomas P. Eisele, Jan Kolaczinski, Richard Cibulskis, Simon I Hay, Peter W. GethingeLife 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical issue of insecticide-treated net (ITN) distribution for malaria control in Africa, revealing that current inefficiencies in distribution and rapid net loss significantly hinder progress towards universal coverage. By developing a novel Bayesian modeling framework, the authors provide a more accurate picture of ITN coverage and demonstrate that improving system efficiencies could dramatically increase the impact of future ITN campaigns.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Malaria remains a major global health burden, and insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) are a cornerstone of control efforts. Despite massive investments and widespread distribution, achieving universal coverage – ensuring everyone at risk has access to and uses an ITN – remains a significant challenge. The authors highlight that existing estimates of ITN needs and coverage may be overly optimistic due to a lack of understanding of two key "inefficiencies": how evenly nets are distributed among households, and how quickly nets are lost from households after distribution. This gap in knowledge makes it difficult to accurately assess progress, plan future interventions, and optimize resource allocation.

Methods

The core of this paper is a sophisticated Bayesian hierarchical modeling framework. The authors developed a two-stage approach:

  1. Estimating Net Crop: This stage uses a compartmental stock-and-flow model to estimate the total number of ITNs (net crop) in households within each country over time. It integrates three data sources: manufacturer delivery data, national malaria control program (NMCP) distribution reports, and household survey data. A key innovation here is fitting a dynamic, country-specific net loss function directly to the data, rather than relying on external assumptions.
  2. Estimating Coverage Indicators: This stage uses the estimated net crop and household survey data to predict four key ITN coverage indicators: % households with at least one ITN, % households with enough ITNs for one per two people, % population with access to an ITN within their household, and % population who slept under an ITN the previous night. A novel aspect is the use of a zero-truncated Poisson model stratified by household size to accurately model net ownership and access patterns.

The model is designed to be data-driven, minimizing reliance on assumptions and providing uncertainty estimates (posterior credible intervals) for all outputs.

Datasets

The study utilized a comprehensive set of data:

  • Manufacturer Reports: Data on LLIN deliveries to countries from 2000-2013.
  • National Malaria Control Program (NMCP) Reports: Data on cITN and LLIN distributions within countries from 2000-2013.
  • Nationally Representative Household Surveys: 99 surveys from 39 sub-Saharan African countries between 2001-2013, providing data on ITN ownership, access, and use at the household level. These included data from Demographic and Health Surveys (DHS), Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys (MICS), and Malaria Indicator Surveys (MIS).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Net Loss is Faster Than Assumed: The study found that ITNs are lost from households much more rapidly than previously estimated, with a median retention time of only 23 months. This significantly impacts the sustained coverage achieved by distribution campaigns.
  • Over-allocation is Worsening: The proportion of ITNs distributed to households that already have enough nets (over-allocation) has increased over time, reaching 21% in 2013. This inefficiency means that a substantial number of nets are not reaching households that truly need them.
  • Efficiency is Key to Coverage: The model demonstrates that improving system efficiencies (reducing over-allocation and increasing net retention) can dramatically increase the population access achieved with a given number of distributed nets.
  • "Ownership Gap" Persists: While overall ownership of at least one ITN is improving, a significant gap remains in households owning enough ITNs for everyone (one per two people). This "ownership gap" is a major barrier to achieving universal coverage.
  • Use Gap is Small: Conversely, the "use gap" (people with access to an ITN but not using it) is relatively small, suggesting that the primary barrier to ITN use is lack of access, not unwillingness to use.

Key Results

  • In 2013, an estimated 21% (17%-26%) of ITNs were over-allocated.
  • The median retention time for LLINs in households was 23 months (20-28 months).
  • Under current "business-as-usual" conditions, an estimated 920 million additional ITNs would be required to achieve 80% population access by 2017, but this would only translate to 70% population use.
  • With minimized over-allocation and longer net retention (3-year median half-life), the same 920 million ITNs could achieve over 95% population access.
  • The study provides year-by-year estimates for four key ITN coverage indicators across sub-Saharan Africa from 2000-2013.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study acknowledges that NMCP distribution data may not capture all distribution activities (e.g., by non-governmental agencies) and that some older surveys had less detailed information.
  • Net Condition: The model considers nets as present or absent, without accounting for their condition (e.g., torn nets or diminished insecticidal properties). Future work could extend the model to incorporate net degradation.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: While the study provides insights into efficiency gains, it does not perform a formal cost-effectiveness analysis of different strategies.
  • Equity: The authors suggest that future work could extend the developed framework to consider equity in coverage versus malaria risk in more detail.
  • Behavioral Factors: The model focuses on access and physical presence of nets, acknowledging that effectiveness of nets in repelling mosquitoes when used is not explicitly modeled.

Summary updated

Abstract

Insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) for malaria control are widespread but coverage remains inadequate. We developed a Bayesian model using data from 102 national surveys, triangulated against delivery data and distribution reports, to generate year-by-year estimates of four ITN coverage indicators. We explored the impact of two potential 'inefficiencies': uneven net distribution among households and rapid rates of net loss from households. We estimated that, in 2013, 21% (17%-26%) of ITNs were over-allocated and this has worsened over time as overall net provision has increased. We estimated that rates of ITN loss from households are more rapid than previously thought, with 50% lost after 23 (20-28) months. We predict that the current estimate of 920 million additional ITNs required to achieve universal coverage would in reality yield a lower level of coverage (77% population access). By improving efficiency, however, the 920 million ITNs could yield population access as high as 95%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bhatt2015coverage,
  author = {Samir Bhatt and Daniel J. Weiss and Bonnie Mappin and Ursula Dalrymple and Ewan Cameron and Donal Bisanzio and David L. Smith and Catherine L. Moyes and Andrew J. Tatem and Michael Lynch and Cristin Fergus and Joshua Yukich and Adam Bennett and Thomas P. Eisele and Jan Kolaczinski and Richard Cibulskis and Simon I Hay and Peter W. Gething},
  title = {{Coverage and system efficiencies of insecticide-treated nets in Africa from 2000 to 2017}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.09672},
}
Figure