Covariance Operator Based Dimensionality Reduction with Extension to Semi-Supervised Settings

Minyoung Kim, Vladimir PavlovicAISTATS 2009 · OpenReview

Abstract

We consider the task of dimensionality reduction for regression (DRR) informed by real-valued multivariate labels. The problem is often treated as a regression task where the goal is to find a low dimensional representation of the input data that preserves the statistical correlation with the targets. Recently, Covariance Operator Inverse Regression (COIR) was proposed as an effective solution that exploits the covariance structures of both input and output. COIR addresses known limitations of recent DRR techniques and allows a closed-form solution without resorting to explicit output space slicing often required by existing IR-based methods. In this work we provide a unifying view of COIR and other DRR techniques and relate them to the popular supervised dimensionality reduction methods including the canonical correlation analysis (CCA) and the linear discriminant analysis (LDA). We then show that COIR can be effectively extended to a semi-supervised learning setting where many of the input points lack their corresponding multivariate targets. A study of benefits of proposed approaches is presented on several important regression problems in both fully-supervised and semi-supervised settings.

Introduction

In many machine learning tasks, the objective is to reduce the dimensionality of input data ($x$) while preserving the information necessary to predict a continuous, often multivariate, target ($y$). This is known as Dimension Reduction for Regression (DRR). Traditional approaches face significant hurdles, most notably the "slicing" problem. Methods like Sliced Inverse Regression (SIR) require grouping output values into discrete clusters, which fails when the output is high-dimensional or noisy, such as in 3D human pose estimation.

Furthermore, many modern kernel-based methods involve non-convex optimization, leading to sub-optimal local minima. Finally, most DRR methods are purely supervised, failing to leverage the vast amounts of unlabeled data available in real-world scenarios.

Methodology

This research builds upon Covariance Operator Inverse Regression (COIR), utilizing covariance operators in Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces (RKHS).

The Core Innovation

Instead of slicing the output space, COIR employs kernel matrices to capture the statistical relationship between inputs and outputs. This formulation leads to a closed-form solution via an eigenvalue problem, ensuring computational efficiency and a guaranteed global optimum. The authors prove that COIR provides a unifying framework, showing mathematical equivalence to Kernel Canonical Correlation Analysis (KCCA) and a generalized version of Kernel Linear Discriminant Analysis (KLDA).

Semi-Supervised Extension (SS-COIR)

To address label scarcity, the authors introduce manifold regularization. By using a graph Laplacian built from all data points, the model "smooths" the output kernel matrix. This assumes that if two input points are proximal on a manifold, their labels—even if unknown—should be similar.

Experiments and Results

The approach was evaluated on several benchmarks, including synthetic noisy curves, head pose estimation, and human body pose estimation using the CMU motion capture database.

Figure 5: Examples of skeleton poses and silhouettes from the CMU motion capture database used for high-dimensional pose estimation.

Key Findings

  • Superior Embeddings: In synthetic experiments, COIR produced smooth, discriminative 2D maps where points were clearly ordered by target values. In contrast, competing methods like mKDR or SIR produced cluttered or overlapping results.
  • Pose Estimation Accuracy: COIR achieved a test error of 5.863 (using GP regression), significantly outperforming mKDR (7.204) and KSIR (7.311).
  • Semi-Supervised Efficacy: On head pose tasks with only 10% labeled data, SS-COIR achieved an error of 0.418, compared to 1.294 for standard COIR trained only on the labeled subset. This demonstrates that unlabeled data significantly improves the learned representation.
Figure 3: Comparison of 2D embeddings for the synthetic noisy curves dataset across various methods. COIR (a) demonstrates superior preservation of the target structure.

Discussion and Future Work

COIR demonstrates that "slicing" is a special case of a more general kernel framework. By using smoother kernels like RBF, COIR becomes a flexible, robust version of SIR that handles high-dimensional targets effectively.

However, computational scaling remains a challenge, as kernel methods typically scale at $O(n^3)$. Future work may involve Nyström sampling for larger datasets or integrating these covariance operators with deep learning architectures. Additionally, the performance of SS-COIR relies on the manifold assumption; if the data is highly discontinuous, label propagation may be less effective.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the task of dimensionality reduction for regression (DRR) informed by real-valued multivariate labels. The problem is often treated as a regression task where the goal is to find a low dimensional representation of the input data that preserves the statistical correlation with the targets. Recently, Covariance Operator Inverse Regression (COIR) was proposed as an effective solution that exploits the covariance structures of both input and output. COIR addresses known limitations of recent DRR techniques and allows a closed-form solution without resorting to explicit output space slicing often required by existing IR-based methods. In this work we provide a unifying view of COIR and other DRR techniques and relate them to the popular supervised dimensionality reduction methods including the canonical correlation analysis (CCA) and the linear discriminant analysis (LDA). We then show that COIR can be effectively extended to a semi-supervised learning setting where many of the input points lack their corresponding multivariate targets. A study of benefits of proposed approaches is presented on several important regression problems in both fully-supervised and semi-supervised settings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kim2009covariance,
  author = {Minyoung Kim and Vladimir Pavlovic},
  title = {{Covariance Operator Based Dimensionality Reduction with Extension to Semi-Supervised Settings}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics},
  year = {2009},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=knfjrun5lJ},
}
Figure