TL;DR
This paper presents a two-stage process combining dark fermentation and microbial electrolysis to efficiently produce biohydrogen from various agro-industrial wastewaters and by-products. This integrated approach significantly boosts hydrogen yields and COD removal compared to dark fermentation alone, offering a promising pathway for sustainable bioenergy production within a biorefinery concept.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The world faces a growing need for sustainable and renewable energy sources to reduce reliance on fossil fuels and mitigate climate change. Hydrogen is a promising clean energy carrier, but its large-scale production is currently dominated by energy-intensive processes with significant environmental impacts, such as natural gas reforming. Biohydrogen production from organic waste streams offers a more sustainable alternative, but traditional methods like dark fermentation (DF) often result in incomplete conversion of organic matter and lower hydrogen yields. Microbial electrolysis cells (MECs) can further enhance hydrogen production by utilizing the by-products of DF, but integrating these technologies effectively with complex, real-world waste streams remains a challenge. This study addresses the need for a robust and efficient biohydrogen production system that can valorize diverse agro-industrial wastewaters and by-products, moving towards a circular economy and biorefinery framework.
Methods
The study employed a two-stage process:
- Dark Fermentation (DF): Batch experiments were conducted in serum flasks using six different agro-industrial substrates (ricotta cheese whey, fruit juice wastewater, fruit processing wastewater, paper mill wastewater, sugar production wastewater, and vinasse residues). Substrates were diluted to a specific organic content (≤ 3 gCOD/L), buffered, and inoculated with anaerobic sludge. Fermentation was carried out at 37°C under anaerobic conditions. Hydrogen production and gas composition were monitored using micro-gas chromatography. Metabolic end-products were analyzed at the end of the batch.
- Microbial Electrolysis Cell (MEC): The effluents from the DF stage were used as feedstock for MECs. These were cylindrical, two-chamber reactors separated by an anion exchange membrane. Carbon felt served as the anode, and a platinum-iridium mesh as the cathode. The MECs were operated at 37°C. Chronoamperometry was used to measure current density and coulombic efficiency. Hydrogen production, cathodic recovery, and energy yield were quantified.
Novelty: While both DF and MECs are established technologies, their combined application to a diverse range of complex agro-industrial wastewaters and by-products within a biorefinery framework, and a systematic comparison of their performance, is a key contribution. The study also provides detailed characterization of the substrates and the microbial communities in the anodic biofilm.
Datasets
The study utilized six different agro-industrial wastewaters and by-products as substrates:
- Ricotta cheese whey (CW)
- Fruit juice production wastewater (FJW)
- Fruit processing wastewater (FPW)
- Paper mill wastewater (PW)
- Sugar production wastewater (SW)
- Vinasse residues from spirits production (VB2)
These substrates were collected from various industrial sources and characterized for their chemical and biochemical composition (COD, sugars, proteins, glycerol, etc.). No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study evaluated the performance of the proposed technology on existing waste streams.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Synergistic Enhancement: Coupling DF with MEC significantly amplifies hydrogen production, achieving up to a 13-fold increase compared to DF alone. This highlights the effectiveness of utilizing fermentation by-products in the MEC stage.
- Waste Valorization Potential: The study demonstrates that a wide array of agro-industrial wastes, often considered problematic, can be transformed into a valuable product (biohydrogen) within a biorefinery concept.
- Substrate Composition Matters: The composition of the wastewater, particularly the presence of easily degradable metabolites like sugars and ethanol, strongly influences both DF and MEC performance. Simpler compositions (like FJW) often led to better MEC results.
- High Energy Yields: The MEC stage consistently demonstrated energy yields exceeding 100%, meaning the energy recovered from hydrogen combustion was greater than the electrical energy input. This is crucial for the economic viability of the process.
- Microbial Community Insights: The anodic biofilm in the MEC, particularly for the best-performing FJW substrate, was dominated by Geovibrio ferrireducens, suggesting its significant role in efficient substrate conversion to electricity.
Key Results
- Maximum Overall Hydrogen Yield: 1608.6 ± 266.2 mL H₂/gCOD consumed.
- Maximum COD Removal: 78.5 ± 5.7%.
- Highest Hydrogen Yield (DF alone): 95.1 ± 26.4 mL H₂/gCODinitial (from CW).
- Highest Hydrogen Yield (MEC stage): 1478.2 ± 267.6 mL H₂/gCODconsumed (from FJW effluent).
- Best Cathodic Hydrogen Recovery: 101.4 ± 0.9% (from FJW effluent).
- Highest Energy Yield (MEC stage): 725.0 ± 7.8% (from FJW effluent).
- Net Electric Energy Yield: Ranged from 11.0 ± 0.2 to 25.2 ± 8.2 Wh/mol H₂ produced, significantly lower than abiotic electrolysis.
Limitations and Future Work
- Bench-Scale Limitations: The study was conducted at a bench scale, and the results are not directly representative of industrial-scale processes. Scaling up the coupled DF-MEC technology is a critical next step.
- Substrate Variability: The performance varied significantly among the tested substrates, influenced by their complex compositions. Further research is needed to optimize pretreatment or process parameters for less amenable substrates.
- Techno-Economic Feasibility: While promising, the techno-economic aspects of the coupled system, including material costs, reactor design, and hydrogen management, require further investigation to ensure industrial feasibility.
- Microbial Community Function: While Geovibrio ferrireducens was identified as a key player in high-performance anodes, its precise electrochemical activity and the roles of other community members need more detailed investigation.
- Specific Substrate Optimization: For substrates like VB2 (vinasse), which already has a valorization chain (fertilizer), a careful evaluation is needed to determine if replacing it with H₂ production is economically viable. For CW, developing exploitation systems is a potential area for future research.
Summary updated