Coupled Antigen and BLIMP1 Asymmetric Division With a Large Segregation Between Daughter Cells Recapitulates the Temporal Transition From Memory B Cells to Plasma Cells and a DZ-to-LZ Ratio in the Germinal Center

Elena Merino Tejero, Danial Lashgari, Rodrigo García-Valiente, Jiaojiao He, Philippe A. Robert, Michael Meyer‐Hermann, Jeroen E. J. Guikema, Huub Hoefsloot, Antoine H. C. van KampenFrontiers in Immunology 2021 · DOI

Abstract: Memory B cells and antibody-secreting plasma cells are generated within germinal centers during affinity maturation in which B-cell proliferation, selection, differentiation, and self-renewal play important roles. The mechanisms behind memory B cell and plasma cell differentiation in germinal centers are not well understood. However, it has been suggested that cell fate is (partially) determined by asymmetric cell division, which involves the unequal distribution of cellular components to both daughter cells. To investigate what level and/or probability of asymmetric segregation of several fate determinant molecules, such as the antigen and transcription factors (BCL6, IRF4, and BLIMP1) recapitulates the temporal switch and DZ-to-LZ ratio in the germinal center, we implemented a multiscale model that combines a core gene regulatory network for plasma cell differentiation with a model describing the cellular interactions and dynamics in the germinal center. Our simulations show that BLIMP1 driven plasma cell differentiation together with coupled asymmetric division of antigen and BLIMP1 with a large segregation between the daughter cells results in a germinal center DZ-to-LZ ratio and a temporal switch from memory B cells to plasma cells that have been observed in experiments.

Introduction

When the body fights a pathogen, it creates Germinal Centers (GCs)—microscopic "training camps" in the lymph nodes where B cells evolve to produce high-affinity antibodies. This process must solve two major logistical problems: maintaining a specific structural ratio (roughly 2:1) between the Dark Zone (DZ) and Light Zone (LZ), and managing a "temporal switch" where the GC transitions from producing Memory B Cells (MBCs) early in the response to Plasma Cells (PCs) later on.

Biologists have long debated how a single B cell "decides" its fate. A leading hypothesis is Asymmetric Cell Division (ACD): the idea that when a B cell divides, internal components like antigens and transcription factors are split unevenly between daughter cells. This study investigates which specific molecules must be segregated asymmetrically to replicate observed biological dynamics.

Methods: A Multiscale Modeling Approach

The researchers developed a multiscale model (MSM) to bridge the gap between single-cell biochemistry and organ-level dynamics. This framework consists of two primary components:

  1. Agent-Based Model (ABM): Simulates thousands of individual B cells moving and interacting with helper T cells within the GC environment.
  2. Gene Regulatory Network (GRN): A system of differential equations within each cell agent representing three master-regulator proteins: BCL6 (maintaining the germinal center state), IRF4, and BLIMP1 (driving plasma cell differentiation).
Schematic of the multiscale model showing the Germinal Center zones (LZ/DZ), cell types (CC, CB, PC, MBC), and the core gene regulatory network.

The model was calibrated using microarray data for initial protein concentrations and established literature for B-cell migration and division rates. The researchers then varied the "polarity" (segregation level) and probability of asymmetric division for both captured antigens and the three transcription factors.

Results: The Necessity of Asymmetric Division

The simulations revealed that symmetry is a failure in the context of GC dynamics. If B cells divide perfectly symmetrically, the DZ-to-LZ ratio becomes unstable, and the system fails to produce a meaningful number of plasma cells.

The Coupling of Antigen and BLIMP1

The most significant finding was that asymmetry in antigen alone is insufficient. The model only successfully replicated biological reality when Antigen and BLIMP1 were coupled in their asymmetric distribution. When one daughter cell inherits a disproportionate amount of both, it receives a "double-shove" toward the plasma cell fate, while the other daughter remains in the GC to continue evolving.

Illustration of asymmetric cell division (ACD) scenarios showing the unequal segregation of antigen (Ag) and transcription factors between daughter cells.

Key results from the coupled asymmetry model include:

  • Structural Stability: Maintenance of the biologically observed DZ-to-LZ ratio of ~2.
  • Efficiency: A 33-fold increase in plasma cell production (roughly 25,000 PCs) compared to symmetric models.
  • Temporal Accuracy: Successful replication of the "Memory-first, Plasma-later" output. Early in the reaction, low BLIMP1 levels favor MBC production; as BLIMP1 accumulates, the asymmetric "shove" becomes strong enough to drive PC differentiation.

Discussion and Future Directions

This computational study identifies BLIMP1 as a primary driver of the temporal switch in B-cell fate. However, several limitations remain. The model uses a simplified definition of Memory B cells, and while it points to BLIMP1 as the "smoking gun," physical evidence of BLIMP1 segregation in live B cells is still needed from "wet lab" imaging studies.

Future research should focus on high-resolution imaging of single-cell bursts to confirm if the predicted segregation levels match the physical reality of B-cell division. Understanding these mechanisms is crucial for improving our knowledge of how long-term immunity is established and maintained.

Summary updated

Abstract

Memory B cells and antibody-secreting plasma cells are generated within germinal centers during affinity maturation in which B-cell proliferation, selection, differentiation, and self-renewal play important roles. The mechanisms behind memory B cell and plasma cell differentiation in germinal centers are not well understood. However, it has been suggested that cell fate is (partially) determined by asymmetric cell division, which involves the unequal distribution of cellular components to both daughter cells. To investigate what level and/or probability of asymmetric segregation of several fate determinant molecules, such as the antigen and transcription factors (BCL6, IRF4, and BLIMP1) recapitulates the temporal switch and DZ-to-LZ ratio in the germinal center, we implemented a multiscale model that combines a core gene regulatory network for plasma cell differentiation with a model describing the cellular interactions and dynamics in the germinal center. Our simulations show that BLIMP1 driven plasma cell differentiation together with coupled asymmetric division of antigen and BLIMP1 with a large segregation between the daughter cells results in a germinal center DZ-to-LZ ratio and a temporal switch from memory B cells to plasma cells that have been observed in experiments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tejero2021coupled,
  author = {Elena Merino Tejero and Danial Lashgari and Rodrigo García-Valiente and Jiaojiao He and Philippe A. Robert and Michael Meyer‐Hermann and Jeroen E. J. Guikema and Huub Hoefsloot and Antoine H. C. van Kampen},
  title = {{Coupled Antigen and BLIMP1 Asymmetric Division With a Large Segregation Between Daughter Cells Recapitulates the Temporal Transition From Memory B Cells to Plasma Cells and a DZ-to-LZ Ratio in the Germinal Center}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Immunology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fimmu.2021.716240},
}

Loading related content...

Figure