Countrywide natural experiment reveals impact of built environment on physical activity

Tim Althoff, Boris Ivanovic, Jennifer L. Hicks, Scott L. Delp, Abby C. King, Jure LeskovecarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

Public health experts have long observed that residents of walkable cities, such as New York or Chicago, are significantly more active than those in car-dependent suburbs. However, a persistent "chicken or the egg" question has complicated urban planning: Does a walkable environment cause people to walk more, or do naturally active people simply choose to live in walkable places? This phenomenon, known as residential self-selection, makes it difficult to isolate the true impact of urban design on public health.

To address this, researchers conducted a massive longitudinal study using smartphone data to observe a "natural experiment." By tracking the activity levels of the same individuals before and after they relocated between cities with different walkability levels, the study sought to disentangle environmental influence from personal preference.

Methodology

The study leveraged a dataset from over 2 million smartphone users (via the Azumio Argus app), identifying 7,447 relocations across 1,609 U.S. cities. Researchers used weather update pings as a proxy for location and objective smartphone accelerometry to record minute-by-minute step counts for up to 90 days before and after each move. The built environment was quantified using Walk Score, a metric measuring proximity to local amenities.

Figure 3: Relocations to and from New York City illustrate how moving to a more walkable environment increases daily steps, while moving to a less walkable one decreases them symmetrically.

Key Insights: The Symmetry of Impact

The research revealed that the environment's effect on behavior is remarkably symmetric. When individuals moved to a city with a higher Walk Score, their daily step counts increased; conversely, moving to a less walkable city resulted in a nearly identical decrease in activity. This change was not a temporary "honeymoon phase" but remained sustained for at least three months following the move.

Crucially, the added activity was predominantly Moderate-to-Vigorous Physical Activity (MVPA)—brisk walking (≥100 steps/minute) that is most strongly linked to reduced risks of cardiovascular disease and diabetes. Because people moving between cities of similar walkability showed no change in activity, the study provides strong evidence that the built environment itself, rather than the act of moving or personal motivation, is the primary catalyst for behavior change.

Quantitative Results and National Projections

The relationship between walkability and activity is linear and predictable. A move resulting in a 50-point increase in Walk Score adds approximately 1,100 steps per day. For those making major moves to highly walkable areas, the fraction of people meeting national aerobic activity guidelines (150 minutes of MVPA per week) nearly doubled, rising from 21.5% to 42.5%.

Figure 5: The change in daily steps is directly proportional to the change in walkability score across thousands of relocations.

Simulations based on these findings suggest that if all U.S. cities were improved to the walkability level of Chicago or Philadelphia (Walk Score 78), an estimated 33 million more Americans would meet physical activity guidelines. These results were consistent across most demographics, including age, gender, and BMI, suggesting that urban design is a universal lever for public health.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the study provides robust causal evidence, it is limited by the demographics of smartphone health-app users, who tend to be younger and of higher socioeconomic status. Additionally, while city-level Walk Scores are useful, future research could benefit from neighborhood-level granularity to identify which specific features—such as park access or transit quality—drive the greatest increases in activity. Despite these limitations, the study confirms that urban design is not just a matter of aesthetic preference but a powerful tool for improving population health at scale.

Summary updated

Abstract

While physical activity is critical to human health, most people do not meet recommended guidelines. More walkable built environments have the potential to increase activity across the population. However, previous studies on the built environment and physical activity have led to mixed findings, possibly due to methodological limitations such as small cohorts, few or single locations, over-reliance on self-reported measures, and cross-sectional designs. Here, we address these limitations by leveraging a large U.S. cohort of smartphone users (N=2,112,288) to evaluate within-person longitudinal behavior changes that occurred over 248,266 days of objectively-measured physical activity across 7,447 relocations among 1,609 U.S. cities. By analyzing the results of this natural experiment, which exposed individuals to differing built environments, we find that increases in walkability are associated with significant increases in physical activity after relocation (and vice versa). These changes hold across subpopulations of different genders, age, and body-mass index (BMI), and are sustained over three months after moving.The added activity observed after moving to a more walkable location is predominantly composed of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA), which is linked to an array of associated health benefits across the life course. A simulation experiment demonstrates that substantial walkability improvements (i.e., bringing all US locations to the walkability level of Chicago or Philadelphia) may lead to 10.3% or 33 million more Americans meeting aerobic physical activity guidelines. Evidence against residential self-selection confounding is reported. Our findings provide robust evidence supporting the importance of the built environment in directly improving health-enhancing physical activity, in addition to offering potential guidance for public policy activities in this area.
BibTeX
@misc{althoff2024countrywide,
  author = {Tim Althoff and Boris Ivanovic and Jennifer L. Hicks and Scott L. Delp and Abby C. King and Jure Leskovec},
  title = {{Countrywide natural experiment reveals impact of built environment on physical activity}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2406.04557},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04557},
}
Figure