Coulomb gap in a doped semiconductor near the metal-insulator transition: Tunneling experiment and scaling ansatz

Mark Lee, J. G. Massey, V. Lien Nguyen, B. I. ShklovskiǐPhysical 1999 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Electron tunneling experiments are used to probe Coulomb correlation effects in the single-particle density of states (DOS) of boron-doped silicon crystals near the critical density $n_c$ of the metal-insulator transition (MIT). At low energies ($\varepsilon < 0.5$ meV), a DOS measurement distinguishes between insulating and metallic samples with densities 10 to 15% on either side of $n_c$. However, at higher energies ($\sim 1$ meV $< \varepsilon < 50$ meV) the DOS of both insulators and metals show a common behavior, increasing with energy as $\varepsilon^m$ where $m$ is roughly 0.5. The observed characteristics of the DOS can be understood using a classical treatment of Coulomb interactions combined with a phenomenological scaling ansatz to describe the length-scale dependence of the dielectric constant as the MIT is approached from the insulating side.

Introduction

The Metal-Insulator Transition (MIT) is a fundamental phenomenon in condensed matter physics, representing the point where a material shifts from a conductor to an insulator. For decades, researchers have sought to reconcile two primary drivers of this transition: disorder-driven localization (Anderson localization) and interaction-driven effects, specifically the formation of a "Coulomb gap" in the single-particle density of states (DOS).

While established theories describe the "deep" metallic side (Altshuler-Aronov) and the "deep" insulating side (Efros-Shklovskii), the critical region right at the transition remained poorly understood. This 1999 study addresses this gap by investigating how the parabolic Coulomb gap of an insulator evolves into the square-root cusp of a metal using precise tunneling experiments and a novel theoretical scaling ansatz.

Methodology

Experimental Approach

The researchers fabricated metal-oxide-semiconductor (MOS) junctions using boron-doped silicon (Si:B) and aluminum electrodes. By measuring current-voltage ($I-V$) characteristics at ultra-low temperatures (down to 0.1 K), they directly probed the single-particle DOS. The study utilized a series of Si:B crystals with dopant densities ($n$) ranging from 81% to 110% of the critical density ($n_c$), allowing for observations on both sides of the transition.

Theoretical Framework: The Scaling Ansatz

To explain the experimental findings, the authors proposed a phenomenological model based on spatial dispersion. They argued that near the transition, the dielectric constant ($\kappa$) is not a fixed value but depends on the distance ($r$) between electrons. This scale-dependent $\kappa(r)$ allows for a unified description of the system as it approaches the critical point.

Divergence of the static dielectric constant $\kappa$ as the critical density $n_c$ is approached from the insulating side, supporting the scaling ansatz.

Key Results and Insights

Low-Energy Distinction vs. High-Energy Universality

The most striking experimental result was the energy-dependent behavior of the DOS. At very low energies (below 0.5 meV), the distinction between metals and insulators is sharp: insulators exhibit a clear parabolic gap ($N \propto \varepsilon^2$), while metals show a square-root cusp ($N \propto \varepsilon^{0.5}$).

However, at higher energies (between 1 meV and 50 meV), this distinction vanishes. The DOS for both regimes converges to a universal "backbone" following a power-law curve ($N(\varepsilon) \propto \varepsilon^m$, with $m \approx 0.5$). This suggests that the fundamental difference between a metal and an insulator only manifests at long length scales (low energies), while at short length scales (high energies), both are dominated by similar Coulomb repulsions.

Tunneling conductance spectra for Si:B samples across the metal-insulator transition. At low voltages, a clear distinction emerges between metallic ($n/n_c > 100\%$) and insulating ($n/n_c < 100\%$) regimes.

Scaling and Self-Compensation

The study successfully extracted critical exponents from the data, finding a dynamic scaling exponent $\eta \approx 2.1$ and a localization length exponent $\nu$ between 0.7 and 1.0. These values align with theoretical expectations and transport measurements. Furthermore, the authors argue that even in "uncompensated" silicon, the system undergoes "self-compensation" near the transition, creating the random charge distribution necessary for Coulomb gap formation.

Discussion and Conclusion

This work demonstrates that the transition from a parabolic gap to a square-root cusp is mediated by a scale-dependent dielectric constant. While the metal electrode used in tunneling could potentially screen interactions, the researchers maintained a sufficiently thick $SiO_2$ barrier to minimize this effect, ensuring the results reflect bulk properties.

Future research may focus on intentionally compensated samples to test the universality of the "backbone" DOS across different semiconductor systems. Ultimately, this study provides a vital bridge between the insulating and metallic regimes, highlighting the critical role of electron-electron interactions in the metal-insulator transition.

Summary updated

Abstract

Electron tunneling experiments are used to probe Coulomb correlation effects in the single-particle density of states (DOS) of boron-doped silicon crystals near the critical density ${n}_{c}$ of the metal-insulator transition (MIT). At low energies $(\ensuremath{\varepsilon}&lt;~0.5$ meV), a DOS measurement distinguishes between insulating and metallic samples with densities 10 to 15 % on either side of ${n}_{c}.$ However, at higher energies $(\ensuremath{\sim}1 \mathrm{meV}&lt;~\ensuremath{\varepsilon}&lt;~50$ meV) the DOS of both insulators and metals show a common behavior, increasing with energy as ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{m}$ where m is roughly 0.5. The observed characteristics of the DOS can be understood using a classical treatment of Coulomb interactions combined with a phenomenological scaling ansatz to describe the length-scale dependence of the dielectric constant as the MIT is approached from the insulating side.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee1999coulomb,
  author = {Mark Lee and J. G. Massey and V. Lien Nguyen and B. I. Shklovskiǐ},
  title = {{Coulomb gap in a doped semiconductor near the metal-insulator transition: Tunneling experiment and scaling ansatz}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.60.1582},
}

Loading related content...

Figure