Could Screw/Hook Insertion at the Apical with Rib Head Dislocation Effectively Retract the Corresponding Rib Head from Spinal Canal in Dystrophic Scoliosis Secondary to Type 1 Neurofibromatosis?

Li Song, Saihu Mao, Yanyu Ma, Benlong Shi, Zhen Liu, Zezhang Zhu, Jun Qiao, Yongrong QiuResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Rib head dislocation (RHD) in dystrophic scoliosis of type 1 neurofibromatosis (DS-NF1) is a unique disorder caused by skeletal dystrophy and scoliotic instability. No particular surgical manipulation is mentioned in the literature to instruct the spine surgeons to effectively obtain more migration of the dislocated rib head without resection. The present study aimed to investigate the effectiveness of screw/hook insertion at vertebrae with RHDs on the retraction of penetrated rib head from spinal canal.

Methods: 37 neurologically intact patients with DS-NF1 and concomitant 53 RHDs undergoing scoliosis surgery without rib head excision were retrospectively reviewed. We used pre and postoperative whole-spine radiographs to determine the Cobb angle and the vertebral translation (VT), and the CT scans to evaluate the intraspinal rib length (IRL) and rib-vertebral angle (RVA). The dislocated ribs were stratified into two groups according to the presence of screw/hook insertion at vertebrae with RHD: screw/hook group and non-screw/hook group.

Results: 37 dislocated ribs with screws/hooks insertion at corresponding vertebrae were assigned into the screw/hook group and the remaining 16 dislocated ribs consisted of the non-screw/hook group. In the screw/hook group, the correction rates of Cobb angle and VT were significantly higher than the non-screw/hook group after surgery (58.7±16.0% vs. 30.9±12.4%, p=0.003; 61.8±18.8% vs. 35.1±16.6%, p=0.001; respectively). Similarly, more correction rates of IRL and RVA were found in the screw/hook group than the non-screw/hook group (63.1±31.3% vs. 30.1±20.7%, p=0.008; 17.6±9.7% vs. 7.2±3.6%, p=0.006; respectively). Multiple linear regression analysis revealed that the correction rates of Cobb angle, VT and RVA contributed significantly to correction of IRL (β=0.389, 0.939 and 1.869, respectively; p=0.019, 0.001 and 0.002, respectively).

Conclusion: Screw/hook insertion at dystrophic vertebrae with RHDs contributed significantly to the degree of retraction of penetrated rib head from spinal canal. This effectiveness is mediated by more corrections of VT and RVA.

Introduction

Neurofibromatosis Type 1 (NF1) can lead to "dystrophic scoliosis," a severe and rapidly progressing curvature of the spine. A unique and hallmark complication of this condition is Rib Head Dislocation (RHD), where the head of the rib migrates into the spinal canal. This creates a high-stakes dilemma for surgeons: the dislocated rib head can compress the spinal cord, potentially causing paralysis. While surgical resection of the rib head is an option, it is a technically difficult procedure with its own neurological risks. This study investigates whether placing surgical hardware directly into the specific vertebrae where a rib has dislocated can effectively "pull" the rib out of the spinal canal, avoiding the need for resection.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective review of 37 neurologically intact patients (representing 53 dislocated ribs) who underwent surgery between 1998 and 2018 at the Nanjing Drum Tower Hospital. The cohort included 20 females and 17 males with a mean age of 14.8 years. Cases were divided into two groups based on the surgical approach at the RHD level:

Table 1: Distribution of patients and dislocated rib heads between the screw/hook and non-screw/hook groups.

Success was measured using pre- and post-operative CT scans and X-rays to track Intraspinal Rib Length (IRL), Vertebral Translation (VT), Rib-Vertebral Angle (RVA), and the Cobb angle.

Results

The group with direct fixation (Screw/Hook group) saw significantly better outcomes across all primary metrics. Specifically, the Intraspinal Rib Length (IRL) improved by 63.1% in the screw group, compared to only 30.1% in the non-screw group (p=0.008). Overall, the surgical interventions significantly improved the clinical and radiographic parameters of the patients.

Table 2: Comparison of pre-operative and post-operative clinical and radiographic parameters for the entire cohort.

Further analysis showed that the correction rates of the Cobb angle, VT, and RVA were all significantly higher in the Screw/Hook group. Multiple linear regression confirmed that corrections in VT and RVA were the primary drivers for the successful retraction of the rib head. Importantly, despite the technical difficulty of placing hardware in dystrophic bone, no neurological deficits were reported after surgery.

Discussion

The core finding of this study is the distinction between "passive" and "active" retraction. While correcting the overall spinal curve provides some passive pull on the rib, anchoring the specific affected vertebra allows for "active" retraction. This mechanical leverage effectively drags the segment back to the midline, pulling the rib out of the canal.

Traditionally, the apical vertebrae in NF1 are considered a "screw-forbidden zone" due to thin or deformed pedicles. However, this research suggests that with modern surgical aids like O-arm navigation, the risk of placing these screws is justified by the superior rib retraction achieved. This method reduces the risk of spinal cord injury without the complications associated with surgical rib head resection.

Conclusion

Screw/hook insertion at dystrophic vertebrae with RHDs significantly enhances the retraction of the penetrated rib head from the spinal canal. This effectiveness is primarily mediated by improved corrections of vertebral translation and the rib-vertebral angle, offering a safer surgical strategy for managing this complex condition in NF1 patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background. Rib head dislocation (RHD) in dystrophic scoliosis of type 1 neurofibromatosis (DS-NF1) is a unique disorder caused by skeletal dystrophy and scoliotic instability. No particular surgical manipulation is mentioned in the literature to instruct the spine surgeons to effectively obtain more migration of the dislocated rib head without resection. The present study aimed to investigate the effectiveness of screw/hook insertion at vertebrae with RHDs on the retraction of penetrated rib head from spinal canal. Methods. 37 neurologically intact patients with DS-NF1 and concomitant 53 RHDs undergoing scoliosis surgery without rib head excision were retrospectively reviewed. We used pre and postoperative whole-spine radiographs to determine the Cobb angle and the vertebral translation (VT), and the CT scans to evaluate the intraspinal rib length (IRL) and rib-vertebral angle (RVA). The dislocated ribs were stratified into two groups according to the presence of screw/hook insertion at vertebrae with RHD: screw/hook group and non-screw/hook group. Results. 37 dislocated ribs with screws/hooks insertion at corresponding vertebrae were assigned into the screw/hook group and the remaining 16 dislocated ribs consisted of the non-screw/hook group. In the screw/hook group, the correction rates of Cobb angle and VT were significantly higher than the non-screw/hook group after surgery (58.7±16.0% vs. 30.9±12.4%, p=0.003; 61.8±18.8% vs. 35.1±16.6%, p=0.001; respectively). Similarly, more correction rates of IRL and RVA were found in the screw/hook group than the non-screw/hook group (63.1±31.3% vs. 30.1±20.7%, p=0.008; 17.6±9.7% vs. 7.2±3.6%, p=0.006; respectively). Multiple linear regression analysis revealed that the correction rates of Cobb angle, VT and RVA contributed significantly to correction of IRL (β=0.389, 0.939 and 1.869, respectively; p=0.019, 0.001 and 0.002, respectively). Conclusion. Screw/hook insertion at dystrophic vertebrae with RHDs contributed significantly to the degree of retraction of penetrated rib head from spinal canal. This effectiveness is mediated by more corrections of VT and RVA.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2021could,
  author = {Li Song and Saihu Mao and Yanyu Ma and Benlong Shi and Zhen Liu and Zezhang Zhu and Jun Qiao and Yongrong Qiu},
  title = {{Could Screw/Hook Insertion at the Apical with Rib Head Dislocation Effectively Retract the Corresponding Rib Head from Spinal Canal in Dystrophic Scoliosis Secondary to Type 1 Neurofibromatosis?}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-846082/v1},
}
Figure