Cost-effective implementation of the Paris Agreement using flexible greenhouse gas metrics

Katsumasa Tanaka, Oliviér Boucher, Philippe Ciais, Daniel Johansson, Johannes Morfeldt2020

TL;DR

This paper argues that the current "one-size-fits-all" approach to greenhouse gas (GHG) metrics for the Paris Agreement might not be the most cost-effective in the long run, especially considering potential temperature overshoot scenarios. The authors propose a more flexible, adaptive approach to GHG metrics that could save significant mitigation costs by better aligning with evolving climate pathways.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Paris Agreement aims to limit global warming to well below 2°C, preferably to 1.5°C, above pre-industrial levels. To track progress and facilitate international cooperation, a common set of greenhouse gas (GHG) metrics is used to convert emissions of various gases into a single "CO2-equivalent" value. The most widely adopted metric is the Global Warming Potential over 100 years (GWP100). However, the scientific community has debated the suitability of GWP100, and many alternative metrics have been proposed. This paper addresses the question of whether a fixed, time-invariant metric like GWP100 is the most economically efficient choice for implementing climate mitigation strategies, particularly in light of increasingly plausible scenarios where global temperatures temporarily exceed the Paris Agreement's targets (overshoot pathways). The authors highlight that the cost-effectiveness of different metrics might change over time and depend heavily on the specific climate pathway taken, a complexity not fully captured by a single, static metric.

Methods

The study employs a globally aggregated Integrated Assessment Model (IAM) called ACC2. This model simulates the Earth's physical climate system, carbon cycle, atmospheric chemistry, and the economy, allowing for the calculation of mitigation costs associated with different emission reduction scenarios. The core of the methodology involves:

  • Deriving Cost-Effective Pathways: The model generates pathways that meet specific temperature targets (2°C stabilization, and 1.5°C/2°C overshoot scenarios) while minimizing the net present value of global mitigation costs.
  • Calculating Global Cost-effective Potential (GCP): This metric represents the theoretically most economically efficient metric for a given pathway, derived from the ratio of shadow prices of different GHGs.
  • Estimating Metric Costs: The economic implications of using fixed metrics like GWP100, GWP20, GTP100, etc., are calculated by imposing these metrics as constraints in the pathway optimization. The "cost of metrics" is then quantified as the additional mitigation cost incurred compared to the unconstrained, cost-effective pathway (or equivalently, using GCP).
  • Sensitivity Analysis: The model's results are tested against variations in key parameters such as equilibrium climate sensitivity, discount rates, and marginal abatement cost (MAC) curves to assess the robustness of the findings.

Datasets

The study utilizes temperature pathways from the IPCC Special Report on "Global Warming of 1.5 °C" (SR15). Specifically, data from the Integrated Assessment Modeling Consortium (IAMC) 1.5 °C Scenario Explorer hosted by IIASA was used. This provided five classes of pathways: Below-1.5°C, 1.5°C-low-OS, 1.5°C-high-OS, Lower-2°C, and Higher-2°C.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Time-Dependency is Crucial: The most cost-effective metric for a specific GHG (like methane) is not static but changes over time, especially under overshoot pathways. This is because the relative importance of mitigating short-lived versus long-lived GHGs shifts as the climate system evolves and targets are approached or exceeded.
  • Overshoot Scenarios Matter: The choice of metric becomes significantly more important and can lead to larger cost differences under overshoot pathways compared to stabilization pathways. This is because overshoot scenarios often require more drastic and time-sensitive mitigation actions.
  • Flexibility Pays Off: A flexible approach to GHG metrics, where the "best available" metric is chosen and potentially updated over time, is more cost-effective than permanently relying on a single, fixed metric like GWP100. This flexibility can lead to substantial cost savings.
  • GWP100 is a Decent Short-Term Approximation: While not optimal in the long run, GWP100 appears to be a reasonable approximation of cost-effective metrics for the next few decades.

Key Results

  • The study found that using a flexible approach to GHG metrics, adapting the metric choice over time, can save mitigation costs compared to a fixed GWP100 approach. For instance, under the 1.5°C large overshoot pathway, a flexible approach could reduce additional costs from 2.3% to 0.46% when choosing from six GWPs.
  • The cost of using fixed metrics like GWP100 becomes larger under overshoot pathways. For example, it's 4.0% higher under a 1.5°C large overshoot pathway, compared to 1.4% under stabilization pathways.
  • The cost-effective time horizon for GWPs and GTPs varies depending on the pathway, ranging from 29 to 110 years.
  • The choice of metric significantly influences the distribution of costs over time and across different gases, with implications for regional and sectoral impacts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The study uses a simplified IAM (ACC2) that primarily captures global aspects and does not detail regional or sectoral changes.
  • MAC Curve Assumptions: The marginal abatement cost (MAC) curves are assumed to be time-invariant, which is a simplification. While some constraints are applied to mimic technological change and socioeconomic inertia, this is an area of potential refinement.
  • Future Metric Revisions: The authors suggest that the UNFCCC and parties to the Paris Agreement should consider periodically assessing the appropriateness of GHG metrics as future options unfold. This assessment could be integrated into the global stocktake process.
  • New Metrics: While the paper focuses on conventional GWPs and GTPs, it acknowledges the ongoing debate and development of newer metrics (like GWP*) that aim to improve the accuracy of aggregating emissions. Future work could explore the implications of these novel metrics.
  • Uncertainty: The study acknowledges uncertainties in climate sensitivity, discount rates, and MAC curves, and performs sensitivity analyses to address these. However, other factors like climate-carbon cycle feedbacks are noted as potentially important but not fully incorporated.

Summary updated

Abstract

Greenhouse gas (GHG) emission metrics, that is, conversion factors to evaluate the emissions of non-CO2 climate forcers on a common scale with CO2, serve crucial functions upon the implementation of the Paris Agreement. While different metrics have been proposed, they have not been investigated under a range of pathways, including those significantly overshooting the temperature targets of the Paris Agreement. Here we show that cost-effective metrics that minimize the overall cost of climate mitigation are time-dependent, primarily determined by the period remaining before the eventual stabilization, and strongly influenced by temperature overshoot. Our study suggests that flexibility should be maintained to adapt the choice of metrics in time as the future unfolds, if cost-effectiveness is a key consideration for global climate policy, instead of hardwiring the 100-year Global Warming Potential (GWP100) as a permanent feature of the Paris Agreement implementation as is currently under negotiation.
BibTeX
@misc{tanaka2020cost,
  author = {Katsumasa Tanaka and Oliviér Boucher and Philippe Ciais and Daniel Johansson and Johannes Morfeldt},
  title = {{Cost-effective implementation of the Paris Agreement using flexible greenhouse gas metrics}},
  year = {2020},
}
Figure