Cost and Benefit Analysis for E-Service Applications

Jie Lü, Guangquan ZhangJournal of the Association for Information Systems 2002

Abstract

Companies are adopting Internet-based electronic services (E-services) to attract customers, share business information, maintain relationships, and conduct transactions. However, early-stage adopters often lack knowledge regarding the organizational and relational impacts of these services. This research explores the relationships between cost factors, benefit factors, and customer satisfaction in E-service applications. By identifying changes in service functions and operations, the study proposes a cost-benefit relationship model to guide the development of customer-oriented E-services.

Introduction

By the early 2000s, the initial "dot-com" hype had evolved into a need for businesses to rigorously justify their digital presence. Despite this, standardized models to measure the organizational and relational impacts of moving services online were scarce. Existing frameworks often focused narrowly on either the customer's usability perspective or internal supplier efficiency. This paper addresses this gap by presenting an integrated approach that connects technical functions and their associated costs directly to business benefits and customer satisfaction.

Methodology: The FCBS Framework

The researchers developed the FCBS (Function, Cost, Benefit, Satisfaction) framework to categorize E-service evaluation into four interconnected pillars:

  1. Functions (F): Technical capabilities ranging from basic contact information to complex online transactions.
  2. Costs (C): Initial setup and ongoing operational expenses, including security, training, and maintenance.
  3. Benefits (B): Strategic outcomes such as expanded market reach, improved brand image, and cost reduction.
  4. Satisfaction (S): The quality of service delivery, measured through usability, efficiency, and security.
The FCBS research framework for E-service evaluation.

To validate this framework, a two-stage study was conducted. First, a web search identified 100 Australian companies in the Tourism and IT sectors from the Yellow Pages Online. Second, a survey collected 48 detailed responses regarding their E-service implementations. Statistical analysis, specifically One-way ANOVA, was used to test hypotheses about how different levels of cost investment influenced specific business benefits.

Key Insights and Strategic Value

The study revealed several critical findings regarding the strategic nature of E-services:

  • The Maintenance-Benefit Link: A significant statistical correlation was found between maintenance costs and strategic gains. Companies investing more in ongoing maintenance saw higher returns in broadening market reach and gaining competitive advantages. This underscores that E-service is a dynamic asset requiring continuous investment rather than a one-time setup.
  • Image vs. Transactionality: "Enhancing perceived company image" (B14) was rated as the highest ideal benefit. While companies prioritized their digital image, actual transactional complexity remained low; only 15% of sampled companies supported online payments at the time.
  • Organizational Barriers: The primary hurdles were not purely financial. A lack of staff expertise and difficulties integrating web services with internal applications were cited as major barriers, highlighting the "hidden" human capital costs of digital transformation.

Results and Relationship Modeling

The analysis confirmed that 62% of companies viewed their E-service applications as successful. Maintenance (C2) and Security (C5) emerged as the most critical cost factors, with average importance ratings of 3.9 and 3.7 out of 5, respectively.

Mapping relationships between specific E-service benefits and costs.

Hypothesis testing confirmed that maintenance cost levels significantly impacted "Broadening market reach" ($p = 0.0461$) and "Gaining competitive advantages" ($p = 0.0015$). However, the impact of legal issue costs on company image was not statistically significant ($p = 0.0643$).

Conclusion

While limited by its sample size of 48 Australian firms, this research provides a foundational model for evaluating E-services. Future work aims to utilize Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to capture more complex, multi-factor dependencies. The study emphasizes that for E-services to provide strategic value, companies must look beyond initial implementation and focus on the ongoing relationship between technical functions, operational costs, and long-term business benefits.

Summary updated

Abstract

Companies are adopting Internet-based electronic services (E-services) attracting customers, sharing of business information, maintaining business relationships and conducting business transactions. Companies in the earlier stages of employing E-services have little information and knowledge on its potential organizational and relational impacts. Through few years practice of E-services, companies have obtained related knowledge. They urgently need to assess the costs to move service online against the benefits received via adopting E-service, and identify the impact of E-service adoption in companies’ relationships with their customers as a result of innovative use of E-services.\nThe initial objective of the research is to explore the relationships between cost factors, benefit factors and customer satisfaction for an E-service application. A further objective is to find a potential path for developing a customer oriented E-service application from its current implementation through identifying the types of changes taking place in the service functions and operations as a result of increased use of E-services. Though conducting a survey, this paper, as a stage report of the project, presents a research framework for E-service evaluation, identifies main cost and benefit factors of E-service and analyses the relationships between these factors. Finally, a cost benefit relationship model is proposed.
BibTeX
@article{lu2002cost,
  author = {Jie Lü and Guangquan Zhang},
  title = {{Cost and Benefit Analysis for E-Service Applications}},
  journal = {Journal of the Association for Information Systems},
  year = {2002},
}
Figure