Cosmology with orthogonal nilpotent superfields

S. Ferrara, Рената Каллош, Jesse ThalerPhysical 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel supersymmetric model for inflationary cosmology that elegantly removes problematic "extra" particles like the inflatino and sinflaton from the spectrum. By employing "orthogonal nilpotent superfields" within supergravity, they construct a simpler, more consistent framework for single-field inflation, offering advantages for understanding the early universe.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Inflationary cosmology, the leading paradigm for explaining the early universe's rapid expansion, often relies on supersymmetry to address theoretical challenges. However, standard supersymmetric models can lead to unwanted particles (like the inflatino and sinflaton) that complicate cosmological models, particularly concerning the end of inflation and the creation of matter. These extra particles can also lead to issues with the stability of the inflaton field itself. This paper tackles the problem of building a consistent and simplified supersymmetric inflationary model by systematically removing these problematic extra fields from the theoretical framework.

Methods

The core of the paper's approach lies in the use of "orthogonal nilpotent superfields" within the framework of local supersymmetry and supergravity. Specifically, they introduce two chiral superfields:

  • S (Stabilizer Field): This field is constrained by a "nilpotency condition" of degree 2, meaning $S^2 = 0$. This constraint effectively removes the "sgoldstino" particle from the spectrum.
  • Φ (Inflaton Field): This field is combined with its conjugate into a real superfield B. The key constraints are:
  • Orthogonality: $SB = 0$, meaning S and B are "orthogonal" in a specific mathematical sense.
  • Nilpotency: $B^3 = 0$.

These constraints, when applied within local supersymmetry, lead to the remarkable outcome of removing not only the sgoldstino but also the sinflaton and the inflatino from the low-energy spectrum. The paper also explores "relaxed constraints" where the $SB=0$ condition is modified, leading to slightly different particle content but still offering advantages. The analysis involves working with superfield equations of motion and carefully choosing a "unitary gauge" to simplify the resulting action.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Elegant Particle Removal: The most striking insight is how the specific constraints ($S^2=0$ and $SB=0$) on these superfields automatically eliminate the sgoldstino, sinflaton, and inflatino. This is a significant simplification compared to models that require additional mechanisms to stabilize or remove these particles.
  • Inflatino-less Cosmology: The absence of the inflatino is particularly important. It resolves the long-standing problem of gravitino-inflatino mixing, which complicates the study of matter creation at the end of inflation.
  • Simplified Scalar Potential: The constraints lead to a non-standard form of the scalar potential in supergravity, where a term proportional to $|\nabla_W W|^2$ is absent. This simplification is a direct consequence of the inflatino's absence and offers advantages for model building.
  • Unitary Gauge Power: The choice of a specific "unitary gauge" (where certain fermionic fields vanish) is crucial. In this gauge, the model becomes remarkably simple, describing only a graviton, a massive gravitino, and a single real inflaton.
  • Orthogonal Nilpotent Superfields as a Powerful Tool: The paper demonstrates that these specific types of constrained superfields are a powerful tool for constructing consistent and phenomenologically viable supersymmetric cosmological models.

Key Results

  • A consistent supersymmetric model for single-field inflation is constructed within local supergravity.
  • The model, using orthogonal nilpotent superfields, naturally removes the sgoldstino, sinflaton, and inflatino from the low-energy spectrum.
  • In unitary gauge, the model describes a graviton, a massive gravitino, and a single real inflaton.
  • The absence of the inflatino eliminates gravitino-inflatino mixing, simplifying the study of reheating and matter creation.
  • A nonstandard scalar potential is derived, lacking a term that often complicates inflationary models.
  • Relaxed constraints are explored, showing that similar advantages can be achieved even if the sinflaton is not entirely removed.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Gravitino Scattering Unitarity: The authors acknowledge that a detailed study is needed to understand the implications of these constraints for gravitino scattering unitarity. The "infinitely relevant" operators imposed by the constraints mean that the effective cutoff of the theory might not be the Planck scale, but rather the scale at which scattering amplitudes violate unitarity.
  • Coupling to Matter: The paper suggests that future work should investigate how to couple these models to matter fields and explore the implications for reheating.
  • Observational Consequences: The authors express excitement about the potential for constructing elegant cosmological models and look forward to exploring new observational consequences arising from inflatino-less inflation.
  • Specific Kähler Potentials: While the general form of the Kähler potential is discussed, specific choices for the function $h(A)$ in the potential are mentioned as potentially leading to interesting features, which warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the application of a supersymmetric model with two constrained supermultiplets to inflationary cosmology. The first superfield $\mathbf{S}$ is a stabilizer chiral superfield satisfying a nilpotency condition of degree 2, ${\mathbf{S}}^{2}=0$. The second superfield $\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ is the inflaton chiral superfield, which can be combined into a real superfield $\mathbf{B}\ensuremath{\equiv}\frac{1}{2i}(\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Phi}}\ensuremath{-}\overline{\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Phi}}})$. The real superfield $\mathbf{B}$ is orthogonal to $\mathbf{S}$, $\mathbf{S}\mathbf{B}=0$, and satisfies a nilpotency condition of degree 3, ${\mathbf{B}}^{3}=0$. We show that these constraints remove from the spectrum the complex scalar sgoldstino, the real scalar inflaton partner (i.e. the ``sinflaton''), and the fermionic inflatino. The corresponding supergravity model with de Sitter vacua describes a graviton, a massive gravitino, and one real scalar inflaton, with both the goldstino and inflatino being absent in unitary gauge. We also discuss relaxed superfield constraints where ${\mathbf{S}}^{2}=0$ and $\mathbf{S}\overline{\mathbf{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}$ is chiral, which removes the sgoldstino and inflatino, but leaves the sinflaton in the spectrum. The cosmological model building in both of these inflatino-less models offers some advantages over existing constructions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ferrara2016cosmology,
  author = {S. Ferrara and Рената Каллош and Jesse Thaler},
  title = {{Cosmology with orthogonal nilpotent superfields}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.93.043516},
}

Loading related content...

Figure