Cosmology from the Highly-Redshifted 21 cm Line

Steven R. Furlanetto, Adam Lidz, Abraham Loeb, Matthew McQuinn, Jonathan R. Pritchard, Paul R. Shapiro, James Aguirre, Marcelo A. Alvarez, D. C. Backer, Judd D. Bowman, Jack O. Burns, C. L. Carilli, Renyue Cen, Asantha Cooray, Nickolay Y. Gnedin, Lincoln J. Greenhill, Zoltán Haiman, Jacqueline N. Hewitt, Joseph Lazio, Andrei Mesinger, Piero Madau, M. F. Morales, S. Peng Oh, J. B. Peterson, Y. M. Pihlström, Max Tegmark, Hy Trac, O. Zahn, Matías ZaldarriagaarXiv 2009 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

One of the next decade's most exciting prospects is to explore the cosmic "dark ages," during which the first stars in the Universe formed, with the 21 cm line of neutral hydrogen. At z > 6, this light redshifts into the low-frequency radio regime and can be observed with new generations of wide-field arrays. These experiments have the potential to observe enormous volumes and to improve both cosmological and astrophysical constraints dramatically. In this white paper, we describe how the next decade will see the first steps toward unlocking this potential, allowing us to answer two key questions about the fundamental physics of our Universe and the intergalactic medium: Does the standard cosmological model describe the Universe during the "dark ages?" How did the intergalactic medium evolve during this important time, ending with the reionization of hydrogen?

Introduction

While contemporary cosmology has benefited from high-quality data from the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and local galaxy surveys, a significant observational gap remains: the "dark ages" and the subsequent Epoch of Reionization (EoR). This era, spanning redshifts $6 < z < 50$, represents approximately 60% of the observable volume of the Universe. However, it remains largely inaccessible to traditional optical telescopes because the first stars had not yet fully illuminated the intergalactic medium (IGM).

The evolution of the Universe from the CMB through the dark ages and reionization, highlighting the role of radio arrays in probing these eras.

The challenge lies in determining whether the standard cosmological model holds true during this epoch. Probing this era is essential for understanding the nature of dark matter, the evolution of the IGM, and fundamental parameters such as neutrino mass and cosmic curvature. The 21 cm neutral hydrogen line offers a unique, data-rich window into this formative period.

The 21 cm Signal and Methodology

The primary tool for this exploration is the 21 cm hyperfine transition of neutral hydrogen. As radiation from the early Universe travels toward Earth, it is redshifted into the low-frequency radio regime, typically tens to hundreds of MHz. This signal provides a three-dimensional map of the early Universe, offering approximately $3 \times 10^{16}$ independent measurements—nearly a billion times more information than the CMB.

Key Analytical Techniques

  • Global Signal Measurement: Single-dipole experiments aim to measure the sky-averaged brightness temperature. This provides a "quick look" at the thermal history of the IGM, revealing the timing of the first star formation and the subsequent heating of the gas.
  • Power Spectrum Analysis: Researchers utilize the statistical fluctuations of the 21 cm background to extract cosmological data. This approach is more feasible than direct imaging in the early stages of experimentation.
  • Redshift-Space Distortions: By analyzing the "peculiar velocities" of gas driven by gravity, scientists can separate cosmological signals from astrophysical "contaminants" like star formation. The $\mu^4$ component of these distortions is particularly valuable as it remains relatively insensitive to complex astrophysical processes, providing a direct window into the matter power spectrum.
The predicted global 21 cm brightness temperature signal relative to the CMB, showing characteristic absorption and emission features across redshift (z) and frequency (v).

Projected Capabilities and Results

This research synthesizes theoretical models with the projected capabilities of upcoming radio arrays, including the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA), PAPER, LOFAR, and the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope. Future "Second-Generation" and "Imaging" arrays are expected to feature collecting areas between $10^5$ and $10^6$ m².

The potential for scientific advancement is substantial:

  • Parameter Constraints: Second-generation arrays are projected to improve constraints on dark energy density, matter density, and neutrino mass by factors of 1.4 to 3.0 compared to the Planck satellite.
  • Cosmic Curvature: There is a long-term potential to tighten constraints on the Universe's curvature by up to two orders of magnitude.
  • Reionization Timeline: Initial experiments will focus on constraining the evolution of the neutral hydrogen fraction ($x_{HI}$), helping to reconcile discrepancies between CMB data and quasar absorption spectra.

Challenges and Future Outlook

The most significant hurdle is the presence of overwhelming foreground noise. The polarized Galactic synchrotron foreground is approximately four orders of magnitude ($10,000\times$) stronger than the 21 cm signal. Successfully isolating the signal requires unprecedented precision in instrument calibration and a sophisticated understanding of ionospheric effects.

Looking forward, the field will progress from statistical measurements to precise parameter estimation and, eventually, direct high-redshift imaging. To escape terrestrial radio frequency interference (RFI) and the Earth's ionosphere entirely, researchers are even considering the possibility of a far-side Lunar Radio Array. These steps will be crucial in unlocking the full cosmological potential of the 21 cm line.

Summary updated

Abstract

One of the next decade's most exciting prospects is to explore the cosmic "dark ages," during which the first stars in the Universe formed, with the 21 cm line of neutral hydrogen. At z&gt;6, this light redshifts into the low-frequency radio regime and can be observed with new generations of wide-field arrays. These experiments have the potential to observe enormous volumes and to improve both cosmological and astrophysical constraints dramatically. In this white paper, we describe how the next decade will see the first steps toward unlocking this potential, allowing us to answer two key questions about the fundamental physics of our Universe and the intergalactic medium: Does the standard cosmological model describe the Universe during the "dark ages?" How did the intergalactic medium evolve during this important time, ending with the reionization of hydrogen?
BibTeX
@misc{furlanetto2009cosmology,
  author = {Steven R. Furlanetto and Adam Lidz and Abraham Loeb and Matthew McQuinn and Jonathan R. Pritchard and Paul R. Shapiro and James Aguirre and Marcelo A. Alvarez and D. C. Backer and Judd D. Bowman and Jack O. Burns and C. L. Carilli and Renyue Cen and Asantha Cooray and Nickolay Y. Gnedin and Lincoln J. Greenhill and Zoltán Haiman and Jacqueline N. Hewitt and Joseph Lazio and Andrei Mesinger and Piero Madau and M. F. Morales and S. Peng Oh and J. B. Peterson and Y. M. Pihlström and Max Tegmark and Hy Trac and O. Zahn and Matías Zaldarriaga},
  title = {{Cosmology from the Highly-Redshifted 21 cm Line}},
  year = {2009},
  eprint = {0902.3259},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0902.3259},
}
Figure