Max Tegmark, Michael A. Strauss, Michael R. Blanton, Kevork N. Abazajian, Scott Dodelson, H. B. Sandvik, Xiaomin Wang, David H. Weinberg, Idit Zehavi, Neta A. Bahcall, F. Hoyle, David J. Schlegel, Román Scoccimarro, Michael S. Vogeley, Andreas A. Berlind, Tamás Budavári, Andrew J. Connolly, Daniel J. Eisenstein, Douglas P. Finkbeiner, Joshua A. Frieman, James E. Gunn, Lam Hui, Bhuvnesh Jain, David Johnston, S. Kent, H. Lin, Reiko Nakajima, R. C. Nichol, Jeremiah P. Ostriker, Adrian Pope, Ryan Scranton, Uroš Seljak, Ravi K. Sheth, Albert Stebbins, Alexander S. Szalay, István Szapudi, Yongzhong Xu, James Annis, J. Brinkmann, Scott Burles, F. J. Castander, István Csabai, J. Loveday, Mamoru Doi, M. Fukugita, Bruce Gillespie, G. S. Hennessy, David W. Hogg, Željko Ivezić, G. R. Knapp, D. Q. Lamb, Brian Lee, Robert H. Lupton, Timothy A. McKay, Peter Kunszt, Jeffrey A. Munn, Liam O’Connell, J. Peoples, Jeffrey R. Pier, M. Richmond, Constance M. Rockosi, Donald P. Schneider, Christopher Stoughton, D. L. Tucker, D. E. vanden Berk, B. Yanny, Donald G. YorkPhysical2004 · DOI · arXiv
We measure cosmological parameters using the three-dimensional power spectrum $P(k)$ from over 200 000 galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) in combination with Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) and other data. Our results are consistent with a "vanilla" flat adiabatic cold dark matter model with a cosmological constant without tilt $(n_s=1),$ running tilt, tensor modes, or massive neutrinos. Adding SDSS information more than halves the WMAP-only error bars on some parameters, tightening $1\sigma$ constraints on the Hubble parameter from $h\approx{0.74}_{-0.07}^{+0.18}$ to $h\approx{0.70}_{-0.03}^{+0.04},$ on the matter density from ${\Omega}_{m}\approx 0.25\pm 0.10$ to ${\Omega}_{m}\approx 0.30\pm 0.04$ $(1\sigma)$ and on neutrino masses from $<11$ to $<0.6\mathrm{eV}$ (95%). SDSS helps even more when dropping prior assumptions about curvature, neutrinos, tensor modes and the equation of state. Our results are in substantial agreement with the joint analysis of WMAP and the Two Degree Field Galaxy Redshift Survey, which is an impressive consistency check with independent redshift survey data and analysis techniques. In this paper, we place particular emphasis on clarifying the physical origin of the constraints, i.e., what we do and do not know when using different data sets and prior assumptions. For instance, dropping the assumption that space is perfectly flat, the WMAP-only constraint on the measured age of the Universe tightens from ${t}_{0}\approx{16.3}_{-1.8}^{+2.3}\mathrm{Gyr}$ to ${t}_{0}\approx{14.1}_{-0.9}^{+1.0}\mathrm{Gyr}$ by adding SDSS and SN Ia data. Including tensors, running tilt, neutrino mass and equation of state in the list of free parameters, many constraints are still quite weak, but future cosmological measurements from SDSS and other sources should allow these to be substantially tightened.
Introduction
This landmark 2004 paper by Max Tegmark and the SDSS collaboration represents a pivotal moment in modern cosmology: the transition into the era of "precision cosmology." By combining the first major results from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) with the first-year data from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP), the authors effectively pinned down the "vital signs" of our universe with unprecedented accuracy.
Data and Methodology
The core of the SDSS contribution is the three-dimensional power spectrum $P(k)$, which measures how "clumpy" the universe is at different scales. This was combined with WMAP's first-year temperature and polarization data of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). The authors employed Monte Carlo Markov Chains (MCMC) to explore a high-dimensional parameter space, initially focusing on 6 "vanilla" parameters and expanding to 13 to test more complex physics.
The primary datasets: CMB temperature/polarization spectra and the SDSS matter power spectrum $P(k)$.
Key technical improvements in this analysis include marginalizing over galaxy bias ($b$)—treating it as a nuisance parameter to account for the unknown relationship between galaxies and dark matter—and modeling non-linearities to account for gravitational clumping on small scales.
Breaking Degeneracies
In the early 2000s, CMB data alone suffered from "degeneracies," where different physical models produced nearly identical CMB signatures. For example, a universe with a high expansion rate and low matter density can look similar to one with a lower expansion rate and higher density. By adding "late-time" data from the SDSS galaxy survey, these degeneracies are broken. The SDSS galaxy data measures the "shape" of the power spectrum, which intersects the WMAP uncertainty regions at a sharp angle, collapsing the error bars and confirming a "vanilla" flat $\Lambda$CDM universe.
Key Results
The data is remarkably consistent with the simplest possible version of the $\Lambda$CDM model: one that is perfectly flat, has no "tilt" in its initial fluctuations ($n_s = 1$), and no massive neutrinos.
Posterior probability distributions for cosmological parameters. The narrowing of peaks illustrates the increased precision from combining datasets.
Significant improvements in parameter constraints include:
Hubble Parameter ($h$): Tightened from $0.74^{+0.18}_{-0.07}$ (WMAP only) to $0.70^{+0.04}_{-0.03}$.
Matter Density ($\Omega_m$): Tightened from $0.25 \pm 0.10$ to $0.30 \pm 0.04$.
Neutrino Mass ($M_\nu$): The 95% confidence upper limit on the sum of neutrino masses was slashed from 11 eV to $< 0.6$ eV.
Age of the Universe: Without assuming flatness, WMAP alone gives a wide range (~16.3 Gyr). Adding SDSS and Supernovae data forces the model toward flatness, resulting in a much more precise age of ~14.1 Gyr.
Limitations and Future Work
Despite the success, galaxy bias remains the "weakest link," as more complex, scale-dependent models could shift results. Non-linear redshift distortions ("fingers of god") also limit the use of small-scale data ($k > 0.15 h/\text{Mpc}$). While the results favor a cosmological constant ($w = -1$), constraints on whether dark energy changes over time remain relatively weak. Future datasets, including the Lyman-alpha forest, are expected to further refine these fundamental constants and test the "running" of the spectral tilt.
Summary updated
Abstract
We measure cosmological parameters using the three-dimensional power spectrum $P(k)$ from over 200 000 galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) in combination with Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) and other data. Our results are consistent with a ``vanilla'' flat adiabatic cold dark matter model with a cosmological constant without tilt ${(n}_{s}=1),$ running tilt, tensor modes, or massive neutrinos. Adding SDSS information more than halves the WMAP-only error bars on some parameters, tightening $1\ensuremath{\sigma}$ constraints on the Hubble parameter from $h\ensuremath{\approx}{0.74}_{\ensuremath{-}0.07}^{+0.18}$ to $h\ensuremath{\approx}{0.70}_{\ensuremath{-}0.03}^{+0.04},$ on the matter density from ${\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{m}\ensuremath{\approx}0.25\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.10$ to ${\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{m}\ensuremath{\approx}0.30\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.04$ $(1\ensuremath{\sigma})$ and on neutrino masses from $<11$ to $<0.6\mathrm{eV}$ (95%). SDSS helps even more when dropping prior assumptions about curvature, neutrinos, tensor modes and the equation of state. Our results are in substantial agreement with the joint analysis of WMAP and the Two Degree Field Galaxy Redshift Survey, which is an impressive consistency check with independent redshift survey data and analysis techniques. In this paper, we place particular emphasis on clarifying the physical origin of the constraints, i.e., what we do and do not know when using different data sets and prior assumptions. For instance, dropping the assumption that space is perfectly flat, the WMAP-only constraint on the measured age of the Universe tightens from ${t}_{0}\ensuremath{\approx}{16.3}_{\ensuremath{-}1.8}^{+2.3}\mathrm{Gyr}$ to ${t}_{0}\ensuremath{\approx}{14.1}_{\ensuremath{-}0.9}^{+1.0}\mathrm{Gyr}$ by adding SDSS and SN Ia data. Including tensors, running tilt, neutrino mass and equation of state in the list of free parameters, many constraints are still quite weak, but future cosmological measurements from SDSS and other sources should allow these to be substantially tightened.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tegmark2004cosmological,
author = {Max Tegmark and Michael A. Strauss and Michael R. Blanton and Kevork N. Abazajian and Scott Dodelson and H. B. Sandvik and Xiaomin Wang and David H. Weinberg and Idit Zehavi and Neta A. Bahcall and F. Hoyle and David J. Schlegel and Román Scoccimarro and Michael S. Vogeley and Andreas A. Berlind and Tamás Budavári and Andrew J. Connolly and Daniel J. Eisenstein and Douglas P. Finkbeiner and Joshua A. Frieman and James E. Gunn and Lam Hui and Bhuvnesh Jain and David Johnston and S. Kent and H. Lin and Reiko Nakajima and R. C. Nichol and Jeremiah P. Ostriker and Adrian Pope and Ryan Scranton and Uroš Seljak and Ravi K. Sheth and Albert Stebbins and Alexander S. Szalay and István Szapudi and Yongzhong Xu and James Annis and J. Brinkmann and Scott Burles and F. J. Castander and István Csabai and J. Loveday and Mamoru Doi and M. Fukugita and Bruce Gillespie and G. S. Hennessy and David W. Hogg and Željko Ivezić and G. R. Knapp and D. Q. Lamb and Brian Lee and Robert H. Lupton and Timothy A. McKay and Peter Kunszt and Jeffrey A. Munn and Liam O’Connell and J. Peoples and Jeffrey R. Pier and M. Richmond and Constance M. Rockosi and Donald P. Schneider and Christopher Stoughton and D. L. Tucker and D. E. vanden Berk and B. Yanny and Donald G. York},
title = {{Cosmological parameters from SDSS and WMAP}},
booktitle = {Physical},
year = {2004},
doi = {10.1103/physrevd.69.103501},
}