Abstract
Cosmic voids, the less dense patches of the Universe, are promising laboratories to extract cosmological information. Thanks to their unique low density character, voids are extremely sensitive to diffuse components such as neutrinos and dark energy, and represent ideal environments to study modifications of gravity, where the effects of such modifications are expected to be more prominent. Robust void-related observables, including for example redshift-space distortions (RSD) and weak lensing around voids, are a promising way to chase and test new physics. Cosmological analysis of the large-scale structure of the Universe predominantly relies on the high density regions. Current and upcoming surveys are designed to optimize the extraction of cosmological information from these zones, but leave voids under-exploited. A dense, large area spectroscopic survey with imaging capabilities is ideal to exploit the power of voids fully. Besides helping illuminate the nature of dark energy, modified gravity, and neutrinos, this survey will give access to a detailed map of under-dense regions, providing an unprecedented opportunity to observe and study a so far under-explored galaxy population.
Introduction: The "Clean Room" of the Cosmos
In the quest to understand the fundamental laws of the Universe, cosmologists have traditionally focused on where the "stuff" is: galaxies, clusters, and the intricate filaments of the cosmic web. However, these high-density regions are physically "messy." Processes like virialization—where gravity scrambles initial conditions—and shell crossing make it difficult to extract fundamental cosmological information using standard linear models.
Cosmic voids, the vast under-dense regions that fill most of the volume of our Universe, offer a compelling alternative. They act as a cosmological "clean room." Because they are nearly empty, they are simpler, more linear environments that retain a "better memory" of the Universe's initial conditions. In these regions, the complex baryonic physics that often obscures cosmological signals is minimized, allowing the effects of diffuse components like dark energy and neutrinos to become the primary drivers of evolution.
Methodologies for Probing the Empty
Turning "nothing" into data requires sophisticated observational techniques. The paper outlines four primary methods for extracting cosmological constraints from voids:
- Redshift-Space Distortions (RSD): By measuring the peculiar velocities of galaxies as they move away from the centers of voids, researchers can calculate the growth rate of cosmic structures ($f(z)$).
- Alcock-Paczynski (AP) Test: This geometric test relies on the assumption that, when averaged over large samples, stacked voids should be spherical. Any observed distortion in their shape provides a direct measurement of the Universe’s expansion history and the dark energy equation of state.
- Weak Lensing: Scientists measure how the paths of light from distant galaxies are bent as they pass around the edges of voids. This allows for a map of the underlying matter density and provides a rigorous test of General Relativity.
- Void Size Function: Simply counting the number of voids across different size scales is a metric highly sensitive to the sum of neutrino masses and the nature of dark energy.
Key Insights: Dark Energy and Neutrinos
Voids are uniquely sensitive to the components of the Universe that are hardest to detect in dense clusters.
Dark Energy and Modified Gravity: Voids are the only environments where dark energy is the undisputed dominant force. Furthermore, many theories of "modified gravity" include screening mechanisms that hide their effects in dense regions. In the low-density environment of a void, these mechanisms are inactive, allowing modified gravity effects to flourish and become detectable.
Neutrino Sensitivity: Neutrinos are "hot" particles that do not cluster easily. Because the ratio of neutrinos to cold dark matter is higher in voids than in high-density clusters, voids serve as a precision laboratory for determining the sum of neutrino masses.
Galaxy Evolution: Voids also provide a controlled environment to study the "nature vs. nurture" debate in galaxy evolution. Galaxies found in voids tend to be bluer, more star-forming, and possess smaller disks than their counterparts in dense regions. This suggests that their evolution is driven almost entirely by internal ("nature") processes, free from the environmental ("nurture") pressures of dense clusters.
Current Results and Future Outlook
Even using data not originally optimized for void science, the field is already yielding competitive results. Analysis of the SDSS BOSS (Sloan Digital Sky Survey) data has achieved a 10% accuracy on the matter density ($\Omega_m$) and 12% on the growth rate ($f/b$). Remarkably, the Alcock-Paczynski test using voids currently outperforms traditional galaxy clustering methods by a factor of approximately four in constraining matter density.
However, to reach the next level of precision, several hurdles must be overcome:
- Simulation Resolution: There is an urgent need for large-volume N-body simulations (using tools like COLA or FastPM) that can resolve low-mass halos across massive volumes to provide necessary covariance matrices.
- Theoretical Modeling: Models must improve their handling of "galaxy bias" and the "void-in-cloud" process, where small voids are crushed by surrounding high-density regions.
- Survey Optimization: While upcoming missions like DESI, SPHEREx, and Euclid will provide valuable data, the authors specifically advocate for the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope (formerly WFIRST). Its combination of high tracer density and large area is considered the ideal setup to resolve the internal sub-structure of under-dense regions.
Conclusion
Cosmic voids represent an under-exploited frontier in our map of the Universe. By shifting our focus from the brightest clusters to the emptiest spaces, we can bypass the complexities of non-linear physics and gain a clearer view of dark energy, neutrino mass, and the very nature of gravity itself.
Summary updated