Cosmic-ray electron transport in the galaxy M 51

Julien Dörner, Patrick Reichherzer, Julia Becker Tjus, Volker HeesenAstronomy & Astrophysics 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper uses a 3D simulation of cosmic-ray electron (CRE) transport in the face-on galaxy M51 to show that galactic winds are crucial for explaining observed radio emissions. The best-fit model requires a wind that is significantly weaker (by a factor of 5) than what's inferred from star formation rates, suggesting a more nuanced understanding of galactic outflows is needed.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how cosmic rays, particularly high-energy electrons (CREs), move through galaxies is key to unraveling processes like star formation and galactic evolution. CREs lose energy through synchrotron and inverse Compton radiation, producing the radio continuum emission we observe. However, modeling this transport is complex because it involves diffusion (random scattering) and advection (bulk motion with plasma, like galactic winds), as well as energy losses. Previous 1D models simplified galaxy geometry and transport processes, limiting their ability to capture the full picture. This paper aims to address this by using a more realistic 3D model for the nearby spiral galaxy M51, allowing for a better quantification of diffusion and advection's roles and their impact on CREs.

Methods

The researchers employed the open-source transport framework CRPropa (v3.1) to solve the 3D cosmic-ray transport equation. This equation describes how CRE density changes over time and space due to diffusion, advection, and energy losses. They incorporated:

  • Diffusion: Modeled as isotropic diffusion, with a diffusion coefficient that was found to be energy-independent, a common assumption supported by previous studies.
  • Advection: Modeled as a galactic wind, with its speed parameterized by the star formation rate (SFRD) of the galaxy.
  • Energy Loss: Included synchrotron and inverse Compton losses, calculated based on the magnetic field strength and interstellar radiation field.
  • 3D Geometry: Utilized a cylindrical model for M51, accounting for radial and vertical variations in magnetic fields and star formation.

The core of their method involved numerically solving the transport equation using stochastic differential equations (SDEs) within CRPropa, simulating 10^5 pseudo-particles. They then compared the simulated CRE spectral index (a measure of energy distribution) with observational data from M51 to find the best-fit parameters.

Datasets

The study primarily uses observational data for the galaxy M51, specifically:

  • Magnetic Field Strength: Radial profiles from Heesen et al. (2019, 2022).
  • Star Formation Rate Surface Density (SFRD): Derived from GALEX far-ultraviolet and Spitzer mid-infrared data (Leroy et al. 2008).
  • CRE Spectral Index: Observational data from Heesen et al. (2019).

No new datasets were introduced; the focus was on applying a 3D model to existing observational data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Advection is Crucial, but Weaker Than Expected: The 3D model strongly indicates that advection (galactic wind) plays a significant role in CRE escape, especially in the inner galaxy. However, the best fit requires a wind speed that is about 5 times lower than what's inferred from the galaxy's star formation rate. This suggests our understanding of how star formation drives galactic winds might be too simplistic.
  • Inner vs. Outer Galaxy Dynamics Differ: The study reveals a clear distinction in CRE transport mechanisms between the inner and outer regions of M51. The inner galaxy is dominated by advective escape, while the outer galaxy involves a combination of both diffusion and advection.
  • Energy-Independent Diffusion Fits Best: Contrary to some theoretical expectations, an energy-independent diffusion coefficient provided a much better fit to the observed CRE spectra than models with energy-dependent diffusion. This supports previous findings and simplifies the transport model.
  • 3D Modeling Unlocks New Insights: Moving from 1D to 3D modeling is essential for accurately constraining galactic wind properties. The 3D approach allows for a more direct link between CRE signatures and outflow strength, opening avenues for studying winds in other face-on galaxies.

Key Results

  • The best-fit model for M51's CRE spectrum requires an energy-independent diffusion coefficient of $D_0 \approx 2 \times 10^{28} \text{ cm}^2/\text{s}$.
  • A variable scale height for the magnetic field and galaxy geometry (Model C) provided a better fit than constant scale heights.
  • The optimal advection speed normalization factor ($f_{adv}$) was found to be approximately 0.2, meaning the wind speed is about 5 times weaker than initially inferred from the SFRD.
  • In the inner galaxy ($r_{gc} \lesssim 7 \text{ kpc}$), advection dominates CRE escape. In the outer galaxy, both diffusion and advection contribute.
  • Energy loss timescales for CREs above 2 GeV are significantly shorter than escape timescales, leading to a steepening of the CRE spectrum.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Wind Velocity Simplification: The paper assumes a constant wind velocity with height within the galactic disk. Future work could explore more complex, height-dependent wind profiles.
  • Magnetic Field Model: While the magnetic field strength profile is based on observations, its 3D structure is simplified. A more detailed, anisotropic magnetic field model could improve accuracy.
  • Source Distribution: While CRE sources are linked to star formation regions, the exact injection spectrum and spatial distribution could be refined.
  • Extrapolation to Other Galaxies: The findings for M51 provide a template, but further studies are needed to see if these conclusions about wind strength and transport mechanisms generalize to other face-on galaxies. The authors suggest this work opens the possibility of systematically investigating galactic winds in face-on galaxies.

Summary updated

Abstract

i>Context.<i/> Indirect observations of the cosmic-ray electron (CRE) distribution via synchrotron emission is crucial for deepening the understanding of the CRE transport in the interstellar medium, and in investigating the role of galactic outflows.<i>Aims.<i/> In this paper, we quantify the contribution of diffusion- and advection-dominated transport of CREs in the galaxy M51 considering relevant energy loss processes.<i>Methods.<i/> We used recent measurement from M 51 that allow for the derivation of the diffusion coefficient, the star formation rate, and the magnetic field strength. With this input, we solved the 3D transport equation numerically including the spatial dependence as provided by the measurements, using the open-source transport framework CRPropa (v3.1). We included 3D transport (diffusion and advection), and the relevant loss processes.<i>Results.<i/> We find that the data can be described well with the parameters from recent measurements. For the best fit, it is required that the wind velocity, following from the observed star formation rate, must be decreased by a factor of 5. We find a model in which the inner galaxy is dominated by advective escape and the outer galaxy is composed by both diffusion and advection.<i>Conclusions.<i/> Three-dimensional modelling of cosmic-ray transport in the face-on galaxy M51 allows for conclusions about the strength of the outflow of such galaxies by quantifying the need for a wind in the description of the cosmic-ray signatures. This opens up the possibility of investigating galactic winds in face-on galaxies in general.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dorner2023cosmic,
  author = {Julien Dörner and Patrick Reichherzer and Julia Becker Tjus and Volker Heesen},
  title = {{Cosmic-ray electron transport in the galaxy M 51}},
  booktitle = {Astronomy \& Astrophysics},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=945KXdal9x},
}
Figure