Cosmic-ray deuteron excess from a primary component

Xing-Jian Lv, Xiaojun Bi, Kun Fang, Peng-Fei Yin, Mengjie ZhaoarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have found that standard models of cosmic-ray propagation cannot explain the surprising abundance of deuterons recently measured by the AMS-02 experiment. By recalculating nuclear cross-sections and proposing a novel "primary" deuteron component—generated via proton-proton fusion and helium fragmentation near cosmic-ray sources—the authors provide a new framework that resolves the "deuteron excess" while remaining consistent with other chemical abundances in our galaxy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the standard model of cosmology, most deuterium was created shortly after the Big Bang. However, the amount of deuterium (deuterons) found in cosmic rays (CRs) is much higher than expected from primordial nucleosynthesis alone. Traditionally, astrophysicists explained this by "secondary production": heavier cosmic rays (like Helium-4) smash into gas in the interstellar medium (ISM), fragmenting into deuterons during their million-year journey through the galaxy.

Recently, the AMS-02 experiment on the International Space Station measured a deuteron flux significantly higher than these secondary models predict, especially at energies above 5 GV. While some researchers suggested this could be fixed by simply accounting for fragmentation from even heavier nuclei (like Carbon or Oxygen), this paper argues that those models actually rely on overestimated production cross-sections. The "deuteron excess" remains a mystery that requires a new physical mechanism.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-step approach to re-evaluate the deuteron flux:

  1. Cross-Section Recalculation: They updated the deuteron production cross-sections using the latest data from particle accelerators. They specifically looked at how projectiles (from protons to Nickel) interact with both Hydrogen and Helium targets in the ISM.
  2. Propagation Modeling: They used GALPROP v57, a standard numerical tool for simulating CR propagation, but modified it with their refined cross-sections.
  3. Primary Component Modeling: They introduced a "primary" component—deuterons produced at the source (e.g., near supernova remnants) rather than during transit. This includes:
  4. Fragmentation: Heavier nuclei breaking apart in dense molecular clouds surrounding the CR source.
  5. Fusion: A novel $p + p \to D + \pi^+$ mechanism. Because the deuteron is the lightest composite nucleus, it is the only one that can be formed by the fusion of two protons at these energies.
  6. Solar Modulation: They applied the "force-field approximation" to account for how the Sun's magnetic field affects CR measurements reaching Earth.

Datasets

The study relies on several high-precision cosmic-ray datasets for calibration and comparison:

  • AMS-02: Primary deuteron flux and secondary-to-primary ratios (B/C, B/O).
  • DAMPE: High-energy measurements of B/C and B/O ratios.
  • PAMELA: Earlier measurements of deuteron and proton fluxes.
  • Accelerator Data: Nuclear cross-section measurements from various experiments (e.g., Lindstrom et al. [Li75], SKM-200 [Ab81], and He06) used to refine the fragmentation models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Standard Tools are Overestimating: The authors discovered that commonly used tools like GALPROP and USINE actually overestimate the production of deuterons from heavy nuclei fragmentation. This means the "secondary-only" explanation for the AMS-02 excess is even less likely than previously thought.
  • The Fusion Mechanism: The most innovative idea is the inclusion of proton-proton fusion at the source. While the cross-section for $p+p \to D$ is small, protons are so much more abundant than helium that this channel becomes a significant contributor to the primary deuteron flux.
  • Source-Site Acceleration: By producing deuterons in dense clouds near the source, these particles can be "picked up" by the source's shockwaves and accelerated to high energies, explaining why the excess is most visible at higher rigidities.
  • Spectral Consistency: The model successfully explains why the deuteron spectrum looks different from the Helium-3 spectrum, despite both being "secondary" particles. The difference lies in the unique fusion path available only to deuterons.

Key Results

  • Flux Fit: The combined model (Secondary + Primary Fragmentation + Primary Fusion) fits the AMS-02 deuteron data across the entire measured energy range.
  • Cross-Section Correction: The authors proposed a new scaling factor for heavy nuclei fragmentation ($\gamma^D_P = 0.3A_P^{1.05}$), which provides a much better fit to experimental data than previous parameterizations.
  • Energy Cutoff: To match the data, the primary fusion component requires a low-energy cutoff of approximately 4 GeV/n. This cutoff is likely a result of the non-thermal "seed" particles available for acceleration at the source.
  • Secondary Reduction: Updating the cross-sections resulted in a 15% reduction in the predicted secondary deuteron flux at 10 GV, further widening the gap that the primary component must fill.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Phenomenological Cutoff: The 4 GeV/n low-energy cutoff is currently "inserted" to fit the data. The authors acknowledge that a more rigorous treatment of the acceleration physics at the source is needed to derive this from first principles.
  • Solar Modulation: The force-field approximation is a simplified model. Future work could use more complex 3D drift models to better account for solar cycle variations.
  • Cross-Section Uncertainties: There is still a lack of direct measurements for deuteron production on Helium targets. The authors had to interpolate these values, leading to a remaining ~10% uncertainty in the secondary flux. New laboratory measurements of these specific nuclear reactions would greatly refine the model.

Summary updated

Abstract

The recent AMS-02 measurements of cosmic-ray (CR) deuteron fluxes suggest the presence of primary deuterons in quantities far exceeding predictions from Big Bang nucleosynthesis. This poses a significant challenge to modern astrophysics, as no known processes can account for such large amounts of deuterons without violating existing constraints~\cite{Epstein:1976hq}. In contrast, it is recently proposed that the AMS-02 measurements can be explained by a purely secondary origin when contributions from heavier nuclei are considered. In this study, we recalculate the secondary deuteron flux using production cross sections updated with the latest collider data. We find that some of the deuteron production cross sections are overestimated in the widely-used calculation tools for CR propagation, and a primary deuteron component is still necessary. We then propose a novel process for generating primary deuterons at CR sources through a fusion mechanism, which is naturally unique to deuterons. This model could explain the observed deuteron excess while maintaining consistency with other CR measurements.
BibTeX
@misc{lv2024cosmic,
  author = {Xing-Jian Lv and Xiaojun Bi and Kun Fang and Peng-Fei Yin and Mengjie Zhao},
  title = {{Cosmic-ray deuteron excess from a primary component}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2409.07139},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.07139},
}

Loading related content...

Figure