Cosmic-muon characterization and annual modulation measurement with Double Chooz detectors

T. Abrahão, H. Almazán, J. C. dos Anjos, S. Appel, E. Baussan, J. C. Barrière, T. J. C. Bezerra, L. Bezrukov, Timothée Goubault de Brugière, C. Buck, J. Busenitz, A. Cabrera, L. Camilleri, R. Carr, M. Cerrada, E. Chauveau, P. Chimenti, J. I. Crespo-Anadón, J. Dawson, J. Dhooghe, Z. Djurcic, M. Dracos, A. Etenko, M. Fallot, D. Franco, M. Franke, H. Furuta, I. Gil‐Botella, L. Giot, A. Givaudan, M. Gögger-Neff, H. Gómez, L. F. G. Gonzalez, M. C. Goodman, T. Hara, J. Haser, D. Hellwig, A. Hourlier, M. Ishitsuka, J. Jochum, C. Jollet, K. Kale, Philipp Kampmann, M. Kaneda, D. M. Kaplan, T. Kawasaki, E. Kemp, H. de Kerret, M. Kuze, T. Lachenmaier, C. Lane, T. Laserre, C. Lastoria, D. Lhuillier, H.p. Lima, M. Lindner, J. M. López-Castaño, J. M. LoSecco, Б. Лубсандоржиев, J. Maeda, C. Mariani, J. Maricic, T. Matsubara, G. Mention, A. Meregaglia, T. Miletic, A. Minotti, Y. Nagasaka, D. Navas-Nicolás, P. Novella, L. Oberauer, M. Obolensky, A. Onillón, A. Oralbaev, C. Palomares, Iuri Muniz Pepe, G. Pronost, B. Reinhold, B. Rybolt, Y. Sakamoto, R. Santorelli, S. Schönert, S. Schoppmann, R. Sharankova, V. V. Sinev, M. Skorokhvatov, M. Soiron, P. Soldin, A. Stahl, I. Stancu, L.f.f. Stokes, M. Strait, F. Suekane, S. Sukhotin, T. Sumiyoshi, Yujing SunJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

A study on cosmic muons has been performed for the two identical near and far neutrino detectors of the Double Chooz experiment, placed at ∼120 and ∼300 m.w.e. underground respectively, including the corresponding simulations using the MUSIC simulation package. This characterization has allowed us to measure the muon flux reaching both detectors to be (3.64 ± 0.04) × 10⁻⁴ cm⁻²s⁻¹ for the near detector and (7.00 ± 0.05) × 10⁻⁵ cm⁻²s⁻¹ for the far one. The seasonal modulation of the signal has also been studied observing a positive correlation with the atmospheric temperature, leading to an effective temperature coefficient of αT = 0.212 ± 0.024 and 0.355 ± 0.019 for the near and far detectors respectively. These measurements, in good agreement with expectations based on theoretical models, represent one of the first measurements of this coefficient in shallow depth installations.

Introduction

Cosmic muons, secondary particles generated by the interaction of cosmic rays with the Earth's atmosphere, represent a significant background for underground neutrino experiments. The Double Chooz experiment, designed to measure the neutrino mixing angle $\theta_{13}$, utilizes two identical detectors located at relatively shallow depths of approximately 120 and 300 meters water equivalent (m.w.e.). At these depths, the muon flux remains high, necessitating a precise characterization to improve neutrino signal extraction and to study atmospheric particle physics. This paper presents a detailed analysis of the muon flux and its seasonal modulation, providing critical data in the 20–40 GeV energy regime.

Experimental Setup and Methodology

The Double Chooz experiment consists of a Near Detector (ND) and a Far Detector (FD). Each detector is a multi-layered cylindrical structure designed to identify neutrino interactions via inverse beta decay. To distinguish muons from neutrino signals, the detectors employ an Inner Detector (ID) and an Inner Veto (IV) system.

Schematic cross-section of a Double Chooz detector showing the nested vessels and veto systems.

The analysis utilized approximately 151 days of data from the ND and 673 days from the FD. Muon identification relied on detecting large energy deposits in both the ID and IV, ensuring high purity in the selected sample. Key technical components included the MUSIC (MUon SImulation Code) for 3D transport modeling and atmospheric temperature profiles from NASA’s Atmospheric Infrared Sounder (AIRS) satellite to calculate an "effective temperature" ($T_{eff}$) for the atmosphere above the site.

Overburden Modeling

Because the detectors are at shallow depths, the local topography—the "overburden"—strongly influences the angular distribution and energy spectrum of the muons. The team developed high-resolution 3D digitized maps of the terrain above both detector halls to accurately model these effects.

3D topographic maps of the rock overburden for the Near (left) and Far (right) detector sites.

These maps were integrated into the MUSIC simulation package to track muon energy loss and scattering through the rock. The irregular shape of the hill above the Far hall, as seen in the topographic maps, explains the more complex, "lumpy" angular distribution observed in the FD data compared to the ND.

Seasonal Modulation and Results

A key focus of the study was the annual modulation of the muon rate. Atmospheric temperature fluctuations cause the atmosphere to expand or contract, altering the density profile. In warmer months, the decreased density allows parent mesons (pions and kaons) to decay into muons more frequently before interacting with air molecules, leading to a "summer surge" in the muon flux.

The measured muon flux values were:

  • Near Detector: $(3.64 \pm 0.04) \times 10^{-4} \text{ cm}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$
  • Far Detector: $(7.00 \pm 0.05) \times 10^{-5} \text{ cm}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$

The sensitivity of the muon rate to temperature changes is quantified by the temperature coefficient $\alpha_T$. The team measured $\alpha_T = 0.212 \pm 0.024$ for the Near detector and $0.355 \pm 0.019$ for the Far detector. These results align closely with theoretical predictions and help fill the "low energy" end of the global curve when compared to deeper experiments like Borexino or IceCube.

Conclusion

The Double Chooz collaboration has successfully characterized the cosmic muon environment at its shallow-depth experimental sites. While some discrepancies remain in the angular modeling due to the precision of the ND overburden digitization and the complexities of low-energy muon interactions (<20 GeV), the overall results validate current atmospheric models across several orders of magnitude. Future extended data-taking will further reduce statistical uncertainties and potentially reveal shorter-term atmospheric correlations beyond the annual cycle.

Summary updated

Abstract

A study on cosmic muons has been performed for the two identical near and far neutrino detectors of the Double Chooz experiment, placed at ∼120 and ∼300 m.w.e. underground respectively, including the corresponding simulations using the MUSIC simulation package. This characterization has allowed us to measure the muon flux reaching both detectors to be (3.64 ± 0.04) × 10-4 cm-2s-1 for the near detector and (7.00 ± 0.05) × 10-5 cm-2s-1 for the far one. The seasonal modulation of the signal has also been studied observing a positive correlation with the atmospheric temperature, leading to an effective temperature coefficient of αT = 0.212 ± 0.024 and 0.355 ± 0.019 for the near and far detectors respectively. These measurements, in good agreement with expectations based on theoretical models, represent one of the first measurements of this coefficient in shallow depth installations.
BibTeX
@article{abrahao2017cosmic,
  author = {T. Abrahão and H. Almazán and J. C. dos Anjos and S. Appel and E. Baussan and J. C. Barrière and T. J. C. Bezerra and L. Bezrukov and L. Bezrukov and Timothée Goubault de Brugière and C. Buck and J. Busenitz and A. Cabrera and L. Camilleri and R. Carr and M. Cerrada and E. Chauveau and P. Chimenti and P. Chimenti and J. I. Crespo-Anadón and J. Dawson and J. Dhooghe and Z. Djurcic and M. Dracos and A. Etenko and M. Fallot and D. Franco and M. Franke and H. Furuta and I. Gil‐Botella and L. Giot and A. Givaudan and M. Gögger-Neff and H. Gómez and L. F. G. Gonzalez and M. C. Goodman and T. Hara and J. Haser and D. Hellwig and A. Hourlier and M. Ishitsuka and J. Jochum and C. Jollet and K. Kale and Philipp Kampmann and M. Kaneda and D. M. Kaplan and T. Kawasaki and E. Kemp and H. de Kerret and E. Kemp and M. Kuze and T. Lachenmaier and C. Lane and T. Laserre and C. Lastoria and D. Lhuillier and H.P. Lima and M. Lindner and J. M. López-Castaño and J. M. LoSecco and Б. Лубсандоржиев and J. Maeda and C. Mariani and J. Maricic and T. Matsubara and G. Mention and A. Meregaglia and T. Miletic and A. Minotti and Y. Nagasaka and D. Navas-Nicolás and P. Novella and L. Oberauer and M. Obolensky and A. Onillón and A. Oralbaev and C. Palomares and Iuri Muniz Pepe and G. Pronost and B. Reinhold and B. Rybolt and Y. Sakamoto and R. Santorelli and S. Schönert and S. Schoppmann and R. Sharankova and V. V. Sinev and V. V. Sinev and M. Skorokhvatov and M. Soiron and P. Soldin and A. Stahl and I. Stancu and L.F.F. Stokes and M. Strait and F. Suekane and S. Sukhotin and T. Sumiyoshi and Yujing Sun},
  title = {{Cosmic-muon characterization and annual modulation measurement with Double Chooz detectors}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2017/02/017},
}
Figure