CoSAEmb: Contrastive Section-aware Aspect Embeddings for Scientific Articles

Shruti Singh, Mayank SinghACL 2024

TL;DR

This paper introduces CoSAEmb, a novel method for learning rich representations of scientific articles by considering their full text and breaking it down into section-specific embeddings. By using a contrastive learning framework with margin gradation, CoSAEmb effectively captures both local (section-level) and global (abstract-level) information, leading to improved performance on downstream tasks like information retrieval.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Representing the complex information contained within scientific articles is a significant challenge. Existing methods often rely solely on the title and abstract, or encode information at the sentence level. However, these approaches fail to capture the nuanced details and distinct aspects discussed throughout the full text of a paper. This limitation hinders the ability of models to accurately understand and utilize the wealth of information present in research publications, impacting applications like recommendation systems and information retrieval.

Methods

CoSAEmb employs a supervised contrastive training framework built upon an encoder-only transformer model (specifically SciBERT). The core innovation lies in learning "section embeddings" for different parts of a paper (Introduction, Related Works, Methods, Results, Conclusion) and the abstract. These embeddings are then brought closer together in the embedding space for the same paper, while pushing embeddings from different papers further apart.

The contrastive learning uses a triplet loss function, where triplets are constructed to capture three types of context:

  • Local Information Context: Triplets are formed using consecutive sentence chunks within the same section, ensuring that adjacent parts of a section are represented closely.
  • Global Information Context: Triplets combine section embeddings with the abstract embedding, forcing them to be similar.
  • Analogical or Contrastive Context: Triplets leverage citation information to ensure that papers cited by a query paper are closer in the embedding space than un-cited papers.

A key aspect of CoSAEmb is "margin gradation," where the margin for the triplet loss is incrementally increased from inter-document to global to local context. This hierarchy prioritizes capturing fine-grained intra-document similarity.

Datasets

  • S2ORC dataset: Used for training, containing 97,402 scientific papers.
  • SPECTER training dataset: Used for constructing inter-document triplets (684,100 triplets).
  • CSFCube benchmark: Used for evaluation, focusing on faceted recommendation.
  • SCIREPEVAL benchmark: Used for evaluation, a comprehensive benchmark for scientific document representations across 25 tasks.
  • Full-text Paragraph Retrieval Dataset: A custom dataset of 1500 papers from arXiv (cs.CL and cs.AI) for evaluating paragraph retrieval.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Full-text is crucial: The paper strongly argues that relying solely on titles and abstracts is insufficient for capturing the full richness of scientific documents.
  • Section-level embeddings matter: Breaking down papers into their constituent sections and learning embeddings for each allows for a more granular understanding of a paper's content.
  • Contrastive learning for structure: Using contrastive learning effectively organizes embeddings in the latent space, ensuring that related content (sections within a paper, cited papers) is clustered together.
  • Margin gradation for hierarchy: The proposed margin gradation scheme is a novel way to enforce a hierarchy of similarity, prioritizing local context over global or inter-document context.
  • Reusability of existing models: CoSAEmb can be applied to any existing encoder-only transformer model without requiring retraining from scratch, making it a flexible approach.

Key Results

  • CoSAEmb shows improved performance on information retrieval from a paper's full-text compared to models trained only on titles and abstracts.
  • On the CSFCube benchmark, CoSAEmb demonstrates comparable performance to state-of-the-art models, with a slight edge in R-Precision for most aspects, particularly the "method" facet.
  • On the SCIREPEVAL benchmark, CoSAEmb's performance is comparable, though slightly worse than some existing models. The authors suggest this might indicate that full-text information isn't always necessary for all tasks in this benchmark.
  • In full-text paragraph retrieval, CoSAEmb (with margin gradation) shows improved performance over SciBERT and SPECTER.

Limitations and Future Work

  • SCIREPEVAL performance: While comparable, CoSAEmb did not outperform existing models on SCIREPEVAL, suggesting that for certain tasks, full-text utilization might not be universally beneficial.
  • Domain adaptation: The paper focuses on scientific articles. Future work could explore adapting CoSAEmb to other domains with long documents, such as legal or historical texts.
  • Generalization to diverse tasks: The current work focuses on learning embeddings. Extending this to generalize to diverse downstream tasks, as mentioned in related work, could be a future direction.
  • Efficiency of long document transformers: While CoSAEmb reuses existing models, the paper acknowledges the ongoing research into efficient transformers for long documents and their potential impact.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{singh2024cosaemb,
  author = {Shruti Singh and Mayank Singh},
  title = {{CoSAEmb: Contrastive Section-aware Aspect Embeddings for Scientific Articles}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure