Cortical surface electrical potentials are composed of multiple bandlimited frequency components, including high-gamma

Jesse A. Livezey, Ahyeon Hwang, Kseniya Usovich, Maximilian E. Dougherty, Edward F. Chang, Kristofer E. BouchardbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper challenges the prevailing view that high-frequency brain signals (like high-gamma) are purely broadband. Using novel robust regression techniques on rat and human ECoG data, the authors demonstrate that these signals are actually composed of multiple distinct, band-limited components, including high-gamma. This finding has significant implications for understanding neural processing and developing more precise brain-computer interfaces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Neuroscience often grapples with decomposing complex, noisy brain signals into their underlying biophysical components. Cortical surface electrical potentials (CSEPs), measured via electrocorticography (ECoG), are a prime example. While the high-gamma band (70-150 Hz) is known to be highly predictive of behavior and stimuli, there's a persistent debate: is this high-frequency activity a single, broadband (power-law) phenomenon, or is it composed of more specific, band-limited signals? Existing methods often struggle to disentangle these possibilities due to averaging over long time windows and the inherent noise floor of clinical equipment, leading to a poorly understood spectral structure of time-varying high-frequency CSEPs.

Methods

The authors introduce a novel Additive robust regression model. This method builds upon robust regression techniques (like Huber loss) to handle noisy, single-trial data. Crucially, it incorporates an additional additive term that accounts for "shoulders" in the power spectrum, which are often missed by simple power-law fits. This allows for a more accurate estimation of broadband components while mitigating bias introduced by band-limited signals. They also employed UoI-NMFcluster, a noise-robust non-negative matrix factorization algorithm, to decompose multi-unit triggered average neural spectrograms into distinct "generator" components. For analyzing the highest variance spectral component, they utilized Principal Component Analysis (PCA) on the cross-frequency covariance matrix, ensuring data was mean-centered to avoid misinterpretations.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary datasets:

  1. Rat auditory cortex ECoG data: Recorded from six female Sprague Dawley rats in response to white noise auditory stimuli. This dataset was used to investigate the spectral structure of evoked CSEPs in the high-frequency range.
  2. Human ventral sensorimotor cortex ECoG data: A previously published dataset from four native English-speaking human subjects undergoing chronic ECoG implantation for epilepsy treatment. This data was collected during speech production tasks (consonant-vowel syllables) and was used to test the predictive power of different spectral components.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High-gamma isn't just broadband: The long-held assumption that high-gamma is a single broadband (power-law) component is challenged. The data strongly suggests it's a combination of broadband and distinct band-limited signals.
  • Bandlimited components are key for speech: The raw high-gamma amplitude, rather than a power-law fit, was more predictive of spoken syllables, indicating that the band-limited aspects of high-gamma carry crucial information.
  • The "broadband" signal might be an artifact: The study suggests that previous findings of broadband dominance in the highest variance spectral component might be due to improper data handling (specifically, not mean-centering before PCA), leading to the misinterpretation of static mean values as broadband fluctuations.
  • Distinct components, distinct origins: The decomposition of multi-unit triggered average neural spectrograms revealed distinct spectrotemporal components, hinting at different biophysical origins for different frequency bands. This opens the door to layer-specific neural processing biomarkers.

Key Results

  • Rat auditory cortex: Evoked CSEPs in rats showed multiple distinct high-frequency peaks, not just a single broadband response. Multi-unit triggered average neural spectrograms could be decomposed into components with temporally localized, band-limited power in the gamma, high-gamma, ultra-high gamma, and multi-unit activity ranges.
  • Human speech production:
    • Classification accuracy for spoken syllables was significantly higher when using raw high-gamma amplitudes compared to amplitudes derived from power-law fits. This indicates that the power-law component alone does not capture the full predictive information in high-gamma.
  • Electrodes with high classification importance (i.e., those crucial for predicting speech) tended to have larger errors in power-law fits, consistent with the presence of a band-limited component that deviates from a pure power-law model.
  • The highest variance spectral component in human ECoG signals was found to be low-frequency and band-limited, not broadband, when analyzed with proper mean-centering in PCA.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that while the Additive model improves power-law estimation, it doesn't fully capture the complexity of all neural spectra.
  • The comparability of classification importance (α) across subjects might be slightly reduced due to variations in the number of CV classes and trial distributions.
  • The current analysis of the highest variance component using PCA doesn't exclude the possibility of broadband components being mixed into lower-magnitude principal components.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that future work could incorporate spectrotemporal decomposition into generative models to improve inference on time-varying power-law spectra.
  • Exploring more direct parameterizations of amplitude distributions (e.g., Rayleigh or Rice distributions) could better model asymmetries and tails.
  • Jointly estimating power-law and band-limited signals, rather than treating band-limited components as outliers, is a promising direction.
  • The findings suggest that distinct frequency components could serve as biomarkers for processing in different cortical layers, which warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract A common challenge in neuroscience is how to decompose noisy, multi-source signals measured in experiments into biophysically interpretable components. Analysis of cortical surface electrical potentials (CSEPs) measured using electrocorticography arrays (ECoG) typifies this problem. We hypothesized that high frequency (70-1,000 Hz) CSEPs are composed of broadband (i.e., power-law) and bandlimited components with potentially differing biophysical origins. In particular, the high-gamma band (70-150 Hz) has been shown to be highly predictive for encoding and decoding behaviors and stimuli. Despite its demonstrated importance, whether high-gamma is composed of a bandlimited signal is poorly understood. To address this gap, we recorded CSEPs from rat auditory cortex and demonstrate that the evoked CSEPs are composed of multiple distinct frequency components, including high-gamma. We then show, using a novel robust regression method, that at fast timescales and on single trials during speech production, human high-gamma amplitude cannot be explained by a modulating power-law component; thus, high-gamma is band-limited. Furthermore, we show that the power-law component is less predictive of produced speech compared to the raw high-gamma amplitude. Finally, we show that the largest variance component of human ECoG signals is low-frequency and band-limited, not broadband. Together these results demonstrate that there are multiple, band-limited components of high frequency power in cortical surface electrical potentials, including the high-gamma band, which may have different biophysical origins. Significance Statement Electrocortigraphy (ECoG) records cortical surface electrical potentials (CSEPs). ECoG is utilized in both humans and animal models to understand distributed cortical processing and for brain machine interfaces. The spectral structure of evoked CSEPs is greatly debated. To address this issue, we recorded from rat auditory cortex using µ ECoG and human ventral sensory-motor cortex during speech production with high-density ECoG. Using novel analytic approaches, we found that evoked CSEPs are composed of multiple band-limited components, including high-gamma. These results contrast with the dominant thinking in the field that the high-frequency power in ECoG is broadband. Our results raise the possibility that distinct frequency components of ECoG are biomarkers of processing in different cortical layers.
BibTeX
@misc{livezey2022cortical,
  author = {Jesse A. Livezey and Ahyeon Hwang and Kseniya Usovich and Maximilian E. Dougherty and Edward F. Chang and Kristofer E. Bouchard},
  title = {{Cortical surface electrical potentials are composed of multiple bandlimited frequency components, including high-gamma}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.07.22.501176},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure