Cortical State Determines Global Variability and Correlations in Visual Cortex

Marieke L. Schölvinck, Aman B. Saleem, Andrea Benucci, Kenneth D. Harris, Matteo CarandiniJournal of Neuroscience 2015 · DOI

Abstract

The response of neurons in sensory cortex to repeated stimulus presentations is highly variable. To investigate the nature of this variability, we compared the spike activity of neurons in the primary visual cortex (V1) of cats with that of their afferents from lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN), in response to similar stimuli. We found variability to be much higher in V1 than in LGN. To investigate the sources of the additional variability, we measured the spiking activity of large V1 populations and found that much of the variability was shared across neurons: the variable portion of the responses of one neuron could be well predicted from the summed activity of the rest of the neurons. Variability thus mostly reflected global fluctuations affecting all neurons. The size and prevalence of these fluctuations, both in responses to stimuli and in ongoing activity, depended on cortical state, being larger in synchronized states than in more desynchronized states. Contrary to previous reports, these fluctuations invested the overall population, regardless of preferred orientation. The global fluctuations substantially increased variability in single neurons and correlations among pairs of neurons. Once this effect was removed, pairwise correlations were reduced and were similar regardless of cortical state. These results highlight the importance of cortical state in controlling cortical operation and can help reconcile previous studies, which differed widely in their estimate of neuronal variability and pairwise correlations.

Introduction

A fundamental characteristic of sensory cortex is the high degree of trial-to-trial variability in neuronal responses to identical stimuli. This phenomenon has long raised questions about whether such "noise" is an inherent limitation of neural hardware, inherited from peripheral inputs, or a functional byproduct of cortical network dynamics. Previous research has yielded conflicting results, with some suggesting variability is passed from the thalamus and others arguing it arises from feature-specific spontaneous activity. Understanding the origin and structure of this variability is crucial, as correlated noise significantly impacts the information-encoding capacity of neural populations.

Methods

Researchers recorded neural activity in anesthetized cats using two primary methods: single-unit recordings to compare individual neurons in the Lateral Geniculate Nucleus (LGN) and the Primary Visual Cortex (V1), and 10×10 multielectrode arrays to capture large-scale V1 population activity. The study analyzed 53 single neurons from both LGN and V1, alongside 23 population recording sessions. Stimuli included rapidly flashed stationary gratings and periods of ongoing activity (blank screens).

Central to the analysis was the Global Noise Model. This model posits that a neuron's variability is not purely random but is driven by global, population-wide fluctuations. By defining "global noise" as the summed activity of all other recorded neurons, the researchers tested whether an individual neuron's response could be predicted by its average stimulus response combined with a weighted version of these global fluctuations.

Results

The study found that V1 neurons exhibit significantly higher variability than their LGN counterparts, indicating that the cortex is the primary generator of this noise rather than just a passive relay.

Trial-to-trial response variability in V1 (A) vs. LGN (B) neurons.

Quantitative analysis confirmed this disparity. The Fano factor, a standard measure of variability, was approximately 2.7 in V1 compared to 1.0 in the LGN. This nearly threefold increase in variability was consistent across various timescales, as shown by the variability index.

Quantifying variability: Variance-to-mean relationships and variability indices for V1 and LGN populations.

A key finding was the predictive power of "peer" activity. The global noise model explained up to 84% of the variance in some neurons, suggesting that trial-to-trial fluctuations are largely shared across the population. Interestingly, these fluctuations were independent of orientation preference; neurons were affected by the same global "tide" regardless of their specific tuning.

Furthermore, the study identified cortical state—the degree of synchronization in brain activity—as the primary determinant of these fluctuations. In highly synchronized states, global fluctuations were massive, whereas they nearly vanished in desynchronized states. This state-dependency explains the wide variance in correlation estimates reported in previous literature. Once global noise was mathematically removed, residual pairwise correlations became minimal and consistent across different cortical states.

Discussion

These findings suggest that cortical variability is a collective property governed by the brain's internal state. While the study was conducted under anesthesia, which allows for controlled state shifts, future research in awake, behaving animals is necessary to confirm these dynamics during active task performance. Identifying the biological mechanisms—such as top-down feedback or neuromodulatory systems like acetylcholine—that drive these global fluctuations remains a critical next step in understanding cortical operation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The response of neurons in sensory cortex to repeated stimulus presentations is highly variable. To investigate the nature of this variability, we compared the spike activity of neurons in the primary visual cortex (V1) of cats with that of their afferents from lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN), in response to similar stimuli. We found variability to be much higher in V1 than in LGN. To investigate the sources of the additional variability, we measured the spiking activity of large V1 populations and found that much of the variability was shared across neurons: the variable portion of the responses of one neuron could be well predicted from the summed activity of the rest of the neurons. Variability thus mostly reflected global fluctuations affecting all neurons. The size and prevalence of these fluctuations, both in responses to stimuli and in ongoing activity, depended on cortical state, being larger in synchronized states than in more desynchronized states. Contrary to previous reports, these fluctuations invested the overall population, regardless of preferred orientation. The global fluctuations substantially increased variability in single neurons and correlations among pairs of neurons. Once this effect was removed, pairwise correlations were reduced and were similar regardless of cortical state. These results highlight the importance of cortical state in controlling cortical operation and can help reconcile previous studies, which differed widely in their estimate of neuronal variability and pairwise correlations.
BibTeX
@article{scholvinck2015cortical,
  author = {Marieke L. Schölvinck and Aman B. Saleem and Andrea Benucci and Kenneth D. Harris and Matteo Carandini},
  title = {{Cortical State Determines Global Variability and Correlations in Visual Cortex}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.4994-13.2015},
}
Figure