Cortical population activity within a preserved neural manifold underlies multiple motor behaviors

Juan Álvaro Gallego, Matthew G. Perich, Stephanie Naufel, Christian Éthier, Sara A. Solla, Lee E. MillerNature Communications 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

The primary motor cortex (M1) controls a vast array of movements, but how it achieves this flexibility has been a mystery. This paper reveals that M1's motor control relies on a set of stable, underlying "neural modes" that are largely preserved across different tasks. These modes are flexibly combined, allowing M1 to generate diverse behaviors without needing entirely new neural machinery for each one.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The nervous system, particularly the primary motor cortex (M1), is responsible for generating a wide range of complex movements. Traditionally, researchers tried to understand this by looking for individual neurons that "encode" specific movement parameters (like direction or force). However, this approach has been hampered by the observation that single neuron activity is often variable and unstable across different conditions. This has led to the hypothesis that motor control might be based on the coordinated activity of entire neural populations, rather than individual neurons.

The "neural manifold" framework offers a way to study population activity. It suggests that the activity of a population of neurons is constrained to a lower-dimensional subspace within the high-dimensional space of all possible neural states. This subspace, the neural manifold, is thought to be spanned by a set of "neural modes" that reflect the underlying network connectivity. While this framework has been useful for studying single tasks, a key question remained: how does M1 generate different behaviors? Does it use entirely different neural manifolds for each task, or are there commonalities that allow for flexibility? This paper tackles this by investigating whether the neural manifolds and their underlying modes are preserved across a variety of skilled motor tasks.

Methods

The researchers recorded neural population activity from M1 in macaque monkeys performing various skilled wrist and reach-to-grasp tasks. To analyze this high-dimensional neural data, they employed several key techniques:

  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): Used to identify the dominant patterns of neural covariance, defining the "neural manifold" for each task. The basis vectors of these manifolds are called "neural modes."
  • Principal Angles: A geometric measure to quantify the similarity in orientation between neural manifolds from different tasks. Small principal angles indicate that the manifolds are well-aligned, suggesting preserved neural structure.
  • Demixed Principal Component Analysis (dPCA): A more advanced technique used to identify neural modes whose activity covaries with specific behavioral parameters (like time, task, or target). This allowed them to categorize modes as "task-independent" or "task-specific."
  • Canonical Correlation Analysis (CCA): Used to compare the "latent activity" (the time-dependent activation of neural modes) between different tasks.
  • Neural Decoders: Used to predict muscle activity (EMG) from the activity of neural modes, to understand how neural signals translate into motor commands.

Datasets

The study used neural and EMG data recorded from three rhesus macaque monkeys performing a variety of skilled motor tasks. These tasks included:

  • Wrist Tasks:
    • 1-D isometric wrist tasks
    • 2-D isometric wrist task
    • Movement task
    • Elastic-loaded movement task
  • Reach-to-Grasp Tasks:
    • Power grip task
    • Ball grasp, transport, and drop task

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Manifold" is Stable, the "Activity" is Flexible: The core idea is that the underlying structure of neural activity (the manifold and its modes) is remarkably stable across different tasks, while the way these modes are activated changes to produce different behaviors.
  • Neural Modes as Building Blocks: Instead of individual neurons encoding specific parameters, the research suggests that M1 uses a set of "neural modes" as fundamental computational units. These modes are like building blocks that can be combined in different ways.
  • Task-Independent Mapping to Muscles: A particularly surprising finding is that some neural modes, whose activity is largely independent of the specific task, can reliably predict muscle activity. This suggests a direct pathway from these general neural signals to motor output.
  • Implications for Learning: The preservation of neural manifolds across tasks implies that learning one task might significantly facilitate learning another, as the underlying neural machinery is already in place.

Key Results

  • Preserved Neural Manifolds: The neural manifolds associated with different motor tasks showed surprisingly similar orientations, as quantified by small principal angles between them. This similarity was significantly greater than expected by chance.
  • Task-Independent Neural Modes: dPCA analysis revealed that a substantial portion of neural variance (up to ~60%) could be explained by neural modes whose activity was independent of the specific task. These modes could be categorized into those related to general temporal progression within a trial and those related to target direction.
  • Task-Independent EMG Prediction: Decoders built using only the "target-related" task-independent neural modes could predict muscle activity (EMG) with over 50% accuracy compared to decoders using all neural modes. This highlights a direct, task-independent link between certain neural modes and motor output.
  • EMG Manifolds Less Preserved: In contrast to neural manifolds, the corresponding muscle activity (EMG) manifolds were much less aligned across tasks, suggesting that the preserved neural structure is not simply a reflection of similar motor output patterns.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Task Set: While the study included a variety of wrist and reach-to-grasp tasks, it would be interesting to see if these findings generalize to even more diverse motor behaviors or non-motor functions.
  • Correlation vs. Causation: The study demonstrates strong correlations between neural modes and behavior, but directly probing causal relationships would require further experimental manipulation.
  • Generalizability to Other Cortical Areas: The authors hypothesize that this "flexible combination of preserved modes" mechanism might be a general principle for other cortical areas. Future work could explore this in sensory or cognitive domains.
  • Understanding the "Why": While the study identifies that neural modes are preserved and flexibly combined, further research could delve deeper into the underlying network connectivity and computational principles that give rise to these stable modes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Populations of cortical neurons flexibly perform different functions; for the primary motor cortex (M1) this means a rich repertoire of motor behaviors. We investigate the flexibility of M1 movement control by analyzing neural population activity during a variety of skilled wrist and reach-to-grasp tasks. We compare across tasks the neural modes that capture dominant neural covariance patterns during each task. While each task requires different patterns of muscle and single unit activity, we find unexpected similarities at the neural population level: the structure and activity of the neural modes is largely preserved across tasks. Furthermore, we find two sets of neural modes with task-independent activity that capture, respectively, generic temporal features of the set of tasks and a task-independent mapping onto muscle activity. This system of flexibly combined, well-preserved neural modes may underlie the ability of M1 to learn and generate a wide-ranging behavioral repertoire.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gallego2018cortical,
  author = {Juan Álvaro Gallego and Matthew G. Perich and Stephanie Naufel and Christian Éthier and Sara A. Solla and Lee E. Miller},
  title = {{Cortical population activity within a preserved neural manifold underlies multiple motor behaviors}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-018-06560-z},
}
Figure