Cortical Face-Selective Responses Emerge Early in Human Infancy

Heather L. Kosakowski, Michael B. Cohen, Lyneé Herrera, Isabel Nichoson, Nancy Kanwisher, Rebecca SaxebioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that key brain regions involved in face processing, including the FFA, STS, and MPFC, show face-selective responses in infants as young as 2-5 months old. This suggests that the neural machinery for recognizing faces is surprisingly mature early in life, challenging theories that rely heavily on extensive visual experience for its development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In adults, specific brain areas like the Occipital Face Area (OFA), Fusiform Face Area (FFA), Superior Temporal Sulcus (STS), and Medial Prefrontal Cortex (MPFC) are known to be highly responsive to faces. However, the developmental timeline of when these face-selective responses emerge in the infant brain has been unclear. Previous studies often lacked sufficient sample sizes or didn't compare face responses to a broad range of other visual categories, making it difficult to definitively establish face selectivity. This paper aims to pinpoint the age at which these critical face-processing regions become functionally specialized in infants, providing crucial constraints on theories of early cortical development.

Methods

The researchers employed awake infant functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) to measure brain activity. To overcome the challenges of infant fMRI (motion, short attention spans), they combined data from two existing datasets, significantly increasing their sample size (n=65 infants, aged 2.6-9.6 months). Infants viewed dynamic videos of faces, bodies, objects, and scenes.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Combined Datasets: Merging data from two different MRI scanner coils (Coil 2011 and Coil 2021) to achieve a larger sample, despite differences in image resolution.
  • Large Anatomical Parcels: Due to distortions in the Coil 2011 data, they used larger anatomical regions of interest (ROIs) to define search spaces for face-selective voxels, sacrificing some spatial precision for broader coverage.
  • Cross-Validated fROI Analysis: A rigorous approach where functional regions of interest (fROIs) were identified within each individual infant's brain. This method accounts for individual anatomical variability and uses a leave-one-subrun-out procedure to ensure independent estimation of response magnitudes.
  • Linear Mixed-Effects Models: Statistical models were used to analyze beta values (representing neural response strength) and test for category selectivity, age effects, and laterality.

Datasets

The study utilized two combined awake infant fMRI datasets:

  • Coil 2011 Dataset: Collected from June 2016 to July 2019 using a Siemens Trio 3T scanner.
  • Coil 2021 Dataset: Collected from July 2019 to February 2020 using a Siemens Prisma 3T scanner with higher resolution.

The combined dataset comprised 65 infants with usable data, ranging in age from 2.6 to 9.6 months.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Early Maturation of Face Processing: The most striking finding is that face selectivity is not a late-developing phenomenon. Regions like FFA, STS, and MPFC are already showing robust responses to faces within the first few months of life.
  • Differential Development of OFA: While FFA, STS, and MPFC show early face selectivity, the OFA (in the inferior occipital gyrus) appears to develop this selectivity later, with significant responses only observed in older infants in this study. This suggests a potential developmental sequence in the face processing network.
  • Implications for Experience-Dependent Theories: The early emergence of face selectivity, particularly in FFA, challenges theories that posit extensive visual experience as a prerequisite for the development of specialized face processing. This suggests a strong innate predisposition for face perception.
  • Functional Specialization in Infancy: The study demonstrates that even in very young infants, distinct cortical regions are already specialized for processing faces, indicating a sophisticated level of neural organization at this early age.

Key Results

  • FFA, STS, and MPFC: Face-selective responses were present in the approximate locations of FFA, STS, and MPFC in the youngest infants (2-5 months).
  • OFA: Face-selective responses were observed in the approximate location of OFA in older infants (5-9 months) but not in the youngest group.
  • Magnitude of Response: While face selectivity was present early, the overall magnitude of the face response was smaller in infants compared to children and adults. This magnitude increased with age.
  • No Strong Laterality: Unlike adults, where face processing is often lateralized to the right hemisphere, this study did not find significant hemispheric differences in face selectivity in infants.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Resolution and Spatial Accuracy: The use of large anatomical parcels, especially for the Coil 2011 data, means the precise location of the identified fROIs is approximate. Future studies with higher resolution imaging and better anatomical registration could refine these findings.
  • Limited Early Age Range: The study's youngest participants were 2-5 months old. There are no data from infants younger than this, leaving open the possibility that face selectivity might emerge even earlier.
  • Temporal Resolution: While fMRI provides good spatial resolution, its temporal resolution is limited. This makes it difficult to pinpoint the exact moment face selectivity first arises within the 2-5 month window.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest the need for more data per infant and denser longitudinal sampling to precisely identify the age of first face-selective responses in each region and to investigate potential sequential development across regions. Further research could also explore the relationship between infant face selectivity and later face recognition abilities, and investigate the development of multi-modal responses in STS.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT In human adults, multiple cortical regions respond robustly to faces, including the occipital face area (OFA) and fusiform face area (FFA), implicated in face perception, and the superior temporal sulcus (STS) and medial prefrontal cortex (MPFC), implicated in higher level social functions. When in development does face selectivity arise in each of these regions? Here, we combined two awake infant functional magnetic resonance neuroimaging (fMRI) datasets to create a sample size twice the size of previous reports (n=65 infants, 2.6-9.6 months). Infants watched movies of faces, bodies, objects, and scenes while fMRI data were collected. Despite variable amounts of data from each infant, individual subject whole-brain activations maps revealed a significant response to faces compared to non-face visual categories in the approximate location of OFA, FFA, STS, and MPFC. To determine the strength and nature of face selectivity in these regions, we used cross-validated functional region of interest (fROI) analyses. Across this larger sample size, face responses in OFA, FFA, STS, and MPFC were significantly greater than responses to bodies, objects, and scenes. Even the youngest infants (2-5 months) showed significantly face-selective responses in FFA, STS, and MPFC, but not OFA. These results demonstrate that face selectivity is present in multiple cortical regions within months of birth, providing powerful constraints on theories of cortical development. Significance Statement Social cognition often begins with face perception. In adults, several cortical regions respond robustly to faces, yet little is known about when and how these regions first arise in development. To test whether face selectivity changes in the first year of life, we combined two datasets, doubling the sample size relative to previous reports. In the approximate location of the fusiform face area (FFA), superior temporal sulcus (STS), and medial prefrontal cortex (MPFC) but not occipital face area (OFA), face selectivity was present in the youngest group. These findings demonstrate that face-selective responses are present across multiple lobes of the brain very early in life.
BibTeX
@misc{kosakowski2021cortical,
  author = {Heather L. Kosakowski and Michael B. Cohen and Lyneé Herrera and Isabel Nichoson and Nancy Kanwisher and Rebecca Saxe},
  title = {{Cortical Face-Selective Responses Emerge Early in Human Infancy}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.12.04.471085},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure