Cortical evoked activity is modulated by the sleep state in a ferret model of tinnitus. A case study

Linus Milinski, Fernando R. Nodal, Matthew K. J. Emmerson, Andrew J. King, Vladyslav V. Vyazovskiy, Victoria M. BajobioRxiv 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Subjective tinnitus is a phantom auditory perception occurring in the absence of an external acoustic stimulus, affecting approximately 15% of the global population. It is frequently associated with sleep disturbances, impaired mental health, and reduced quality of life. To date, effective treatments remain elusive. This study utilized adult ferrets exposed to mild noise trauma as an animal model to investigate the relationship between tinnitus and sleep. Using operant paradigms (silent gap and silence detection) and auditory brainstem response (ABR) recordings, we tracked the development of tinnitus and hearing impairment over six months. By evaluating sleep-wake architecture and auditory-evoked EEG activity, we found that animals exhibiting signs of tinnitus also developed significant sleep impairments. However, neural markers of tinnitus were notably reduced during sleep, suggesting that sleep states may transiently mitigate the phantom percept. These findings highlight the neurophysiological link between sleep and tinnitus, offering a potential new avenue for therapeutic research.

Introduction

Tinnitus research faces a persistent "chicken and egg" dilemma: does the aberrant brain activity associated with tinnitus directly disrupt sleep, or is sleep loss a secondary consequence of the psychological distress caused by the condition? Furthermore, while rodents are common in auditory research, their hearing ranges differ significantly from humans.

This study addresses these gaps by employing a ferret model, which shares a more human-like hearing range, to longitudinally track the emergence of noise-induced tinnitus. By monitoring sleep architecture and cortical activity over a six-month period, the researchers aimed to determine how the brain's state of vigilance influences the neural signatures of this phantom sound.

Methodology

The study utilized a longitudinal case-study design involving adult female ferrets. The experimental protocol consisted of three primary components:

Noise Overexposure (NOE)

To induce tinnitus and mild hearing loss, animals were exposed to a mild noise trauma consisting of two hours of 8 kHz narrowband noise at 98 dB SPL.

Behavioral Assessment

Ferrets were trained on two operant conditioning tasks to identify the presence of tinnitus:

  1. Silent Gap Detection: This task operates on the theory that a "phantom sound" may "fill in" a silent gap in background noise, making the gap harder for the animal to detect.
  2. Silence Detection: Animals were required to distinguish between true silence and low-level noise. Tinnitus sufferers often mistake silence for an internal sound, leading to specific performance deficits.

Physiological and Sleep Monitoring

Auditory Brainstem Responses (ABRs) were used to measure hearing thresholds. Additionally, chronic EEG/EMG implants allowed for the continuous tracking of sleep-wake cycles and Auditory Evoked Responses (AERs) across different states: Wakefulness, NREM sleep, and REM sleep.

Key Insights

Tinnitus vs. Hearing Loss: Impact on Sleep

A critical finding was the divergence in sleep quality based on the animal's specific sensory profile. One subject with severe hearing loss but minimal evidence of tinnitus actually experienced improved sleep stability (fewer awakenings) post-trauma, likely due to "sensory disconnection" from the environment. In contrast, animals showing clear behavioral markers of tinnitus suffered from significant sleep fragmentation, suggesting that the phantom percept itself—rather than just the loss of hearing—is the primary driver of sleep disruption.

The NREM Filter

During wakefulness, the brains of tinnitus-affected ferrets exhibited "hyper-responsiveness" to sounds, characterized by increased AER magnitudes. However, this pathological activity was significantly suppressed during NREM sleep. This suggests that NREM sleep may act as a natural neural buffer, potentially overriding or filtering out the aberrant signals associated with tinnitus.

Long-term Neural Plasticity

The study observed that tinnitus markers are not static. In one instance, frontal brain activity returned to baseline levels after six months, while occipital activity increased. This shift in neural activity coincided with a worsening of behavioral tinnitus symptoms, indicating a complex, evolving pattern of cortical plasticity over time.

Results Summary

  • Behavioral Impairment: Noise overexposure led to a significant rise in the "Tinnitus Index" (TI). For example, one subject's TI increased from 0.5 at one week post-trauma to 0.9 at six months.
  • Hearing Thresholds: ABR measurements confirmed frequency-specific shifts, with thresholds at the 8 kHz trauma frequency rising by 15–30 dB.
  • Sleep Fragmentation: In subjects with stable tinnitus, the number of wake episodes during a 48-hour period nearly doubled, increasing from 70 at baseline to 136 at the six-month mark.
  • Neural Suppression: AER magnitudes that spiked during wakefulness (e.g., from ~31 µV to ~47 µV) remained significantly lower and closer to baseline during NREM sleep (~23 µV to ~27 µV).

Discussion and Future Directions

While this study is limited by a small sample size ($n=3$ for chronic EEG), the longitudinal depth provides a rich look at the individual variability of tinnitus development. The findings suggest that the sleeping brain possesses an inherent mechanism to mitigate phantom sounds.

Future research should explore whether enhancing NREM sleep—through pharmacological or non-invasive electrical stimulation—could serve as a therapeutic strategy to reduce tinnitus severity. Additionally, further work is needed to disentangle the relationship between tinnitus and hyperacusis (increased sound sensitivity) to better understand the diverse ways noise trauma affects auditory processing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Subjective tinnitus is a phantom auditory perception in the absence of an actual acoustic stimulus. It affects 15% of the global population and can be associated with disturbed sleep, poor mental health and quality of life. To date, there is no effective treatment for tinnitus. We used adult ferrets exposed to mild noise trauma as an animal model of tinnitus. We assessed the phantom percept using two operant paradigms sensitive to tinnitus, silent gap detection and silence detection, before and up to six months after the mild acoustic trauma. The integrity of the auditory brainstem was assessed over the same period using auditory brainstem response recordings. Following noise overexposure, ferrets developed lasting, frequency–specific impairments in operant behaviour and evoked brainstem activity. To explore the interaction between sleep and tinnitus, in addition to tracking the behavioural markers of noise–induced tinnitus and hearing impairment after noise overexposure, we evaluated sleep–wake architecture and spontaneous and auditory–evoked EEG activity across vigilance states. Behavioural performance and auditory–evoked activity measurements after noise overexposure suggested distinct degrees of tinnitus and hearing impairment between individuals. Animals that developed signs of tinnitus consistently developed sleep impairments, suggesting a link between the emergence of noise–induced tinnitus and sleep disruption. However, neural markers of tinnitus were reduced during sleep, suggesting that sleep may transiently mitigate tinnitus. These results reveal the importance of sleep–wake states in tinnitus and suggest that understanding the neurophysiological link between sleep and tinnitus may provide a new angle for research into the causes of phantom percepts and inform future treatments.
BibTeX
@misc{milinski2024cortical,
  author = {Linus Milinski and Fernando R. Nodal and Matthew K. J. Emmerson and Andrew J. King and Vladyslav V. Vyazovskiy and Victoria M. Bajo},
  title = {{Cortical evoked activity is modulated by the sleep state in a ferret model of tinnitus. A case study}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.05.12.593782},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure