Corrosion Compatibility of Stainless Steels and Nickel in Pyrolysis Biomass-Derived Oil at Elevated Storage Temperatures

Jiheon Jun, Yi‐Feng Su, James R. Keiser, John E. Wade, Michael D. Kass, Jack R. Ferrell, Earl Christensen, Mariefel V. Olarte, Dino SulejmanovicSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the corrosion resistance of various stainless steels and pure nickel when exposed to fast pyrolysis bio-oil at elevated temperatures. The findings reveal that SS430F, SS316, and Ni200 exhibit excellent compatibility, forming protective chromium-rich oxide layers, while SS410 shows significant susceptibility to corrosion.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Biomass-derived pyrolysis oils are a promising renewable fuel source, but their corrosive nature poses a significant challenge for the materials used in fuel storage and transportation. These bio-oils are often acidic due to the presence of organic acids and can contain impurities like oxygen and moisture, leading to complex corrosion issues. While some research exists on bio-oil corrosion, a comprehensive understanding of the compatibility of common engineering materials, particularly stainless steels and nickel, under elevated storage temperatures is still needed. This paper aims to fill this gap by systematically evaluating the corrosion behavior of several alloys in a specific fast pyrolysis bio-oil (FR3 bio-oil) derived from forest residues.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to assess corrosion compatibility:

  • Mass Change Measurements: Samples of various alloys were immersed in FR3 bio-oil at different temperatures (35, 50, and 80 °C) and durations (48, 96, and 168 hours). Post-exposure, the samples were cleaned, and their mass change was precisely measured to quantify material loss or gain.
  • Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS): The bio-oil remaining after exposure was analyzed to determine the concentration of leached metal cations (specifically iron and chromium). This provided insights into the extent of metal dissolution from the alloys.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Energy Dispersive X-ray Spectrometry (EDS): For selected samples, cross-sections were analyzed using SEM to visualize the microstructure and surface morphology. EDS mapping was used to identify the elemental distribution, particularly focusing on the presence and uniformity of protective oxide layers (e.g., chromium-rich layers).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized a specific fast pyrolysis bio-oil (FR3 bio-oil) produced from forest residues, which was characterized and agitated prior to use.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chromium is Key: The study strongly suggests that the presence and distribution of chromium are critical for corrosion resistance in this bio-oil. Alloys with higher chromium content and the ability to form a continuous, uniform chromium-rich oxide layer (like SS430F) demonstrated superior performance.
  • Protective Oxide Layers Matter: The formation of a stable, continuous Cr-rich oxide layer on the surface acts as a barrier, significantly mitigating corrosion. The absence or discontinuity of this layer, as seen in SS410 and SS430, leads to substantial material loss.
  • Nickel's Independent Resistance: Pure nickel (Ni200) showed excellent corrosion resistance, even without alloying with chromium. This suggests that nickel itself possesses inherent resistance to this specific bio-oil environment.
  • Sulfur's Potential Role: The paper hints that the higher sulfur content in SS430F (compared to SS430) might have played a role in mitigating metal dissolution, though this requires further investigation.
  • Fe/Cr Ratio as a Diagnostic Tool: The Fe/Cr ratio of leached elements (from ICP-MS) proved to be a valuable indicator. High Fe/Cr ratios in the bio-oil (compared to the alloy's Fe/Cr) suggested preferential iron dissolution and potential chromium enrichment, leading to better corrosion resistance. Conversely, Fe/Cr ratios close to the alloy's composition indicated congruent dissolution and higher corrosion rates.

Key Results

  • Excellent Compatibility: SS430F, SS316, and Ni200 showed minimal mass changes (< 2 mg·cm⁻²) even after 168 hours of exposure at 80 °C, indicating high corrosion resistance.
  • Good Compatibility: SS304 was also found to be compatible, with relatively low mass changes (< 1.6 mg·cm⁻²).
  • Susceptible Alloys: SS410 exhibited significant mass loss, even at lower temperatures (35 °C), and its corrosion worsened with increasing temperature and time. SS430 also showed considerable mass loss, particularly in mesh and coupon forms, suggesting congruent dissolution of Fe and Cr.
  • SEM/EDS Confirmation: Microscopic analysis confirmed that SS430F, with minimal mass change, possessed a continuous and uniform Cr-rich oxide layer. In contrast, samples with significant mass loss, like SS410, either lacked an oxide layer or had a discontinuous one.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Bio-oil Variety: The study focused on a single type of fast pyrolysis bio-oil (FR3 bio-oil) from forest residues. The corrosion behavior might differ with bio-oils derived from other feedstocks or produced via different processes.
  • Unclear Cr Enrichment Conditions: The specific conditions that promote chromium enrichment and the formation of protective oxide layers were not fully elucidated. Further investigation into alloy elements and microstructural features influencing Cr diffusion is recommended.
  • Sulfur's Role: The potential mitigating effect of sulfur in SS430F warrants further dedicated study.
  • Chemical Reactions: The paper calls for further research into the specific chemical reactions and corrosion mechanisms involved, particularly the influence of organic acids and other oxygenates in bio-oils, especially for low-Cr alloys.

Summary updated

Abstract

Corrosion compatibility of stainless steels and nickel (Ni200) was assessed in fast pyrolysis bio-oil produced from pyrolysis of high ash and high moisture forest residue biomass. Sample mass change, ICP-MS and post-exposure electron microscopy characterization was used to investigate the extent of corrosion. Among the tested samples, type 430F and type 316 stainless steels (SS430F and SS316) and Ni200 (~98.5% Ni) showed minimal mass changes (less than 2 mg∙cm−2) after the bio-oil exposures at 50 and 80 °C for up to 168 h. SS304 was also considered to be compatible in the bio-oil due to its relatively low mass change (1.6 mg∙cm−2 or lower). SS410 samples showed greater mass loss values even after exposures at a relatively low temperature of 35 °C. Fe/Cr values from ICP-MS data implied that Cr enrichment in stainless steels would result in a protective oxide layer associated with corrosion resistance against the bio-oil. Post exposure characterization showed continuous and uniform Cr distribution in the surface oxide layer of SS430F, which showed a minimal mass change, but no oxide layer on a SS430 sample, which exhibited a significant mass loss.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jun2022corrosion,
  author = {Jiheon Jun and Yi‐Feng Su and James R. Keiser and John E. Wade and Michael D. Kass and Jack R. Ferrell and Earl Christensen and Mariefel V. Olarte and Dino Sulejmanovic},
  title = {{Corrosion Compatibility of Stainless Steels and Nickel in Pyrolysis Biomass-Derived Oil at Elevated Storage Temperatures}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su15010022},
}
Figure