Abstract
Physical properties of the ground and excited states of a $k$-local Hamiltonian are largely determined by the $k$-particle reduced density matrices ($k$-RDMs), or the $k$-matrix for fermionic systems. For a nondegenerate ground state of a $k$-local Hamiltonian, the state itself is completely determined by its $k$-RDMs, implying it contains no genuine correlations beyond the $k$-particle level. This paper investigates whether a similar principle applies to nondegenerate excited states. While previous conjectures suggested that 2-local fermionic excited states are uniquely determined by their 2-matrices, we construct explicit counterexamples using GHZ-type states and quantum error-correcting codes to disprove this. Furthermore, we prove a "locality doubling" theorem: any nondegenerate excited state of a $k$-local Hamiltonian is uniquely determined by its $2k$-RDMs. These results establish a new theoretical framework for understanding the correlation structures of many-body excited states.
Introduction
In quantum many-body physics, the complexity of a system's state grows exponentially with the number of particles. To manage this complexity, researchers often rely on the principle of locality. If a system's interactions are $k$-local—meaning particles only interact in groups of $k$ or fewer—it is often assumed that the global properties of the system are encoded within its local parts.
For ground states, this assumption is well-supported. The ground state of a $k$-local Hamiltonian is uniquely determined by its $k$-particle reduced density matrices ($k$-RDMs). This implies that the ground state contains no "irreducible" correlations involving more than $k$ particles; any higher-order correlation can be inferred from the $k$-particle data. However, the extension of this logic to excited states has remained a subject of intense debate, particularly within the field of quantum chemistry.
The N-Representability Challenge
The motivation for studying these correlations often stems from the "N-representability problem." In quantum chemistry, calculating the properties of molecules would be significantly more efficient if we could work entirely with 2-RDMs (describing pairs of electrons) rather than the full wave function.
A long-standing conjecture suggested that any nondegenerate excited state of a 2-local Hamiltonian is uniquely determined by its 2-RDM. If true, this would mean that even in high-energy states, the "local" picture captures the entire global identity of the system. This paper rigorously tests that assumption and finds it wanting.
Disproving the Conjecture
To test the limits of local determination, the authors utilized a combination of spin-to-fermion mapping and constructive counterexamples. By translating qubit (spin) systems into fermionic systems, they were able to build specific quantum states that serve as "trap" cases for the existing conjectures.
Counterexample Construction
The researchers identified states that are unique excited states of 2-local Hamiltonians but share identical 2-RDMs with other distinct states. Two primary types of states were used:
- GHZ-type states: These are highly entangled states (e.g., $|000\rangle + |111\rangle$) that provide the simplest evidence that local information is insufficient to distinguish between global states.
- Bacon-Shor Codes: By using states derived from quantum error-correcting codes, the authors demonstrated that these counterexamples are not just mathematical oddities but can exist in complex, structured systems.
These examples prove that 2-particle correlations are insufficient to uniquely identify excited states, effectively disproving the conjecture that excited states behave like ground states in terms of their informational requirements.
The $2k$-Locality Theorem
While the paper provides a negative result regarding the 2-RDM conjecture, it offers a powerful positive result: the Locality Doubling Rule.
The authors utilized a mathematical technique known as the "$H^2$ trick." If a state $|\psi\rangle$ is an excited state of a $k$-local Hamiltonian $H$ with energy $h$, then $|\psi\rangle$ is the unique ground state of a new Hamiltonian $H' = (H - hI)^2$. Because squaring a $k$-local operator results in a $2k$-local operator, the excited state of the original system becomes the ground state of a $2k$-local system.
From this, the authors proved that any nondegenerate excited state of a $k$-local Hamiltonian is uniquely determined by its $2k$-RDMs. This sets a new fundamental bound: while ground states require $k$-particle information, excited states require $2k$-particle information to be fully characterized.
Tightness and Symmetry
The researchers further demonstrated that this $2k$ bound is "tight." By examining GHZ states of $2k$ qubits, they showed that $(2k-1)$-RDMs are genuinely insufficient to determine the state; you truly need the $2k$ level of information.
However, they also identified exceptions where symmetry simplifies the problem. For Symmetric Dicke States—states that are invariant under the permutation of any two particles—2-RDMs remain sufficient to uniquely identify the state regardless of the total number of particles or the energy level. This suggests that while the $2k$ rule is the general law, physical symmetries can sometimes lower the informational requirements.
Conclusion
This work clarifies a fundamental distinction between the ground and excited states of many-body systems. By proving that excited states can harbor irreducible correlations up to the $2k$ level, the authors have redefined the boundaries of the N-representability problem. While the dream of using only 2-RDMs for all excited states has been disproven, the $2k$ theorem provides a solid mathematical framework for future studies in quantum chemistry and condensed matter physics, highlighting the specific conditions under which local information is—and is not—enough.
Summary updated