Correlation of CMB with large-scale structure. I. Integrated Sachs-Wolfe tomography and cosmological implications

Shirley Ho, Christopher M. Hirata, Nikhil Padmanabhan, Uroš Seljak, Neta A. BahcallPhysical 2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a robust statistical analysis of the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect by cross-correlating cosmic microwave background (CMB) data with large-scale structure (LSS) from multiple galaxy surveys. The authors develop a sophisticated likelihood analysis that accounts for redshift-dependent galaxy biases, leading to a significant detection of the ISW effect and improved cosmological constraints, particularly on the curvature of the universe.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect is a subtle imprint on the CMB caused by the evolution of gravitational potentials as photons travel through the universe. Detecting and precisely measuring the ISW effect is crucial for understanding dark energy and the geometry of the universe, especially at late times when these potentials are time-dependent. Previous studies often relied on simplified assumptions about galaxy biases and redshift distributions, limiting the accuracy of ISW measurements and subsequent cosmological constraints. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a more rigorous method to extract the ISW signal across a wide range of redshifts and to use this to derive robust cosmological parameters.

Methods

The core of this paper is a detailed cross-correlation analysis between CMB temperature anisotropies from the WMAP satellite and LSS tracers from various surveys. Key methodological advancements include:

  • Redshift-Dependent Bias and Distribution: Instead of assuming a constant bias for galaxy populations, the authors meticulously determine the redshift-dependent bias and redshift distribution ($b(z) \times dN/dz$) for each LSS sample. This is achieved through a combination of spectroscopic data, photometric redshift analysis, and cross-correlations between different LSS samples.
  • Joint Analysis and Covariance Matrix: All LSS data sets are analyzed jointly, constructing a full covariance matrix that accounts for correlations between different samples. This is crucial for accurate cosmological parameter fitting.
  • Likelihood Function Development: The authors develop a sophisticated likelihood function specifically designed for ISW analysis, which can be applied to various cosmological models.
  • Systematic Error Mitigation: Significant effort is dedicated to identifying and mitigating potential systematic errors, including dust extinction, Galactic foregrounds, thermal Sunyaev-Zeldovich (tSZ) effects, and point source contamination.

Datasets

The paper utilizes the following datasets:

  • Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB): Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) second public data release (first three years of observations).
  • Large-Scale Structure (LSS):
    • 2-Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS): Extended Source Catalog (XSC) galaxies, divided into four flux bins.
  • Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS): * Photometric Luminous Red Galaxies (LRGs), split into two redshift bins.
  • Photometric Quasars (QSOs), split into two redshift bins.
  • NRAO VLA Sky Survey (NVSS): Radio sources.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The ISW effect is a powerful probe of late-time cosmic evolution: By carefully measuring the ISW signal across a broad redshift range, the authors demonstrate its potential to constrain dark energy and cosmic geometry.
  • Accurate redshift distributions are paramount: The paper highlights the critical importance of precisely characterizing the redshift-dependent bias and distribution of LSS tracers for reliable ISW measurements. Simple, constant-bias assumptions are insufficient.
  • Cross-correlations reveal subtle cosmological information: The joint analysis of multiple LSS tracers with CMB data allows for a more robust detection of the ISW signal and improved parameter constraints than individual analyses.
  • The universe is not perfectly flat: The ISW measurements, when combined with CMB power spectra and weak lensing data, provide significant constraints on the curvature of the universe, suggesting a deviation from perfect flatness.

Key Results

  • 3.7σ Detection of ISW: The combined analysis of all LSS datasets yields a statistically significant detection of the ISW effect.
  • No significant ISW at z > 1: In agreement with theoretical expectations for the standard $\Lambda$CDM model, no significant ISW signal is found at redshifts greater than 1.
  • Improved Cosmological Constraints:
    • Curvature ($\Omega_K$): Constraints on the curvature of the universe are improved by a factor of 3.2 compared to WMAP alone, yielding $\Omega_K = -0.004^{+0.014}_{-0.020}$.
  • Dark Energy Equation of State (w): Constraints on the dark energy equation of state are improved by 15%, resulting in $w = -1.01 \pm 0.30$.
  • Software Package: A software package for calculating the ISW likelihood function is made available.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tension with WMAP: The authors note a mild tension between the low power observed in WMAP at low multipoles and the higher ISW power measured in this study. While not statistically significant enough to rule out the standard $\Lambda$CDM model, it suggests potential areas for further investigation.
  • NVSS Redshift Distribution Uncertainty: The redshift distribution of NVSS sources remains a challenge to precisely determine due to the lack of spectroscopic data and potential instrumental systematics. The authors explore different scenarios to account for this.
  • Future Improvements: The paper suggests that future, deeper galaxy surveys and improved CMB data will further enhance the precision of ISW measurements and cosmological parameter constraints. The authors also plan to release their ISW likelihood code for broader use.

Summary updated

Abstract

We cross correlate large-scale structure (LSS) observations from a number of surveys with cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) to investigate the integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect as a function of redshift, covering $z\ensuremath{\sim}0.1--2.5$. Our main goal is to go beyond reporting detections towards developing a reliable likelihood analysis that allows one to determine cosmological constraints from ISW observations. With this in mind we spend a considerable amount of effort in determining the redshift-dependent bias and redshift distribution ($b(z)\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}dN/dz$) of these samples by matching with spectroscopic observations where available, and analyzing autopower spectra and cross-power spectra between the samples. Because of wide redshift distributions of some of the data sets we do not assume a constant-bias model, in contrast to previous work on this subject. We only use the LSS data sets for which we can extract such information reliably and as a result the data sets we use are 2-Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS) samples, Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) photometric Luminous Red Galaxies, SDSS photometric quasars, and NRAO VLA Sky Survey (NVSS) radio sources. We make a joint analysis of all samples constructing a full covariance matrix, which we subsequently use for cosmological parameter fitting. We report a $3.7\ensuremath{\sigma}$ detection of ISW combining all the data sets. We do not find significant evidence for an ISW signal at $z>1$, in agreement with theoretical expectation in the $\ensuremath{\Lambda}\mathrm{CDM}$ model. We combine the ISW likelihood function with weak lensing of CMB (hereafter Paper II [C. M. Hirata, S. Ho, N. Padmanabhan, U. Seljak, and N. A. Bahcall, arXiv:0801.0644.]) and CMB power spectrum to constrain the equation of state of dark energy and the curvature of the Universe. While ISW does not significantly improve the constraints in the simplest six-parameter flat $\ensuremath{\Lambda}\mathrm{CDM}$ model, it improves constraints on seven-parameter models with curvature by a factor of 3.2 (relative to WMAP alone) to ${\ensuremath{\Omega}}_{K}=\ensuremath{-}{0.004}_{\ensuremath{-}0.020}^{+0.014}$, and with dark energy equation of state by 15% to $w=\ensuremath{-}{1.01}_{\ensuremath{-}0.40}^{+0.30}$ [posterior median with ``$1\ensuremath{\sigma}$'' (16th--84th percentile) range]. A software package for calculating the ISW likelihood function can be downloaded at http://www.astro.princeton.edu/~shirley/ISW_WL.html.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ho2008correlation,
  author = {Shirley Ho and Christopher M. Hirata and Nikhil Padmanabhan and Uroš Seljak and Neta A. Bahcall},
  title = {{Correlation of CMB with large-scale structure. I. Integrated Sachs-Wolfe tomography and cosmological implications}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.78.043519},
}
Figure