Correlation between radiographic and functional outcome of distal radius fracture managed by closed reduction and plaster of Paris cast application: A prospective study

Nipun Aggarwal, Jashandeep Singh Chahal, Pravendra Singh, Shristi SinghInternational Journal of Orthopaedics Sciences 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated whether standard X-ray measurements of distal radius fractures predict how well patients recover functionally after non-surgical treatment. The findings suggest that while X-ray appearance is important for initial assessment, it doesn't strongly correlate with long-term patient-reported functional outcomes, highlighting the need to prioritize patient experience in treatment evaluation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Distal radius fractures are extremely common, particularly in the elderly and those involved in high-energy trauma. For decades, the standard non-surgical treatment has been closed reduction and casting. However, there's been an ongoing debate about how well radiographic (X-ray) findings, like bone alignment and length, predict the actual functional recovery and patient satisfaction after such injuries. Historically, poor X-ray results were often assumed to lead to poor functional outcomes. This study aims to clarify this relationship by prospectively evaluating both radiographic parameters and patient-reported functional outcomes (using DASH and PRWE scores) over a year following closed reduction and casting.

Methods

This was a prospective study conducted at a single tertiary care hospital. Patients presenting with closed, isolated distal radius fractures and aged over 18 were included. Exclusion criteria included open fractures, pathological fractures, bilateral fractures, and fractures older than three weeks.

Patients were treated with an above-elbow POP cast for three weeks, followed by a below-elbow cast for another two to three weeks. Mobilization began after clinical and radiological signs of union were confirmed.

Radiographic measurements were taken at baseline and at 3, 6, and 12 months post-reduction. These included:

  • Dorsal/Palmar Tilt: Angle of the distal fragment relative to the radial shaft.
  • Radial Length: Distance measured on PA view.
  • Ulnar Variance: Vertical distance between the radial articular surface and the ulnar head.
  • Radial Inclination: Angle of the radial articular surface relative to the ulna.

Functional outcomes were assessed using two validated patient-reported questionnaires:

  • Disability of Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) score: Measures disability and symptoms in the upper limb.
  • Patient Rated Wrist Evaluation (PRWE) score: Specifically assesses wrist pain and function.

Statistical analysis involved comparing DASH and PRWE scores at different follow-up intervals (3, 6, and 12 months) using t-tests and ANOVA to identify significant changes and correlations.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 146 patients treated at Maharishi Markandeshwar Institute of Medical Sciences and Research, Mullana, Ambala, Haryana, over a one-year period. No external datasets were used for comparison or training.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Radiographic Appearance vs. Patient Experience: The most striking finding is the apparent disconnect between how a fracture looks on an X-ray and how the patient feels about their recovery. Even with some residual radiographic abnormalities, patients reported significant functional improvement over time.
  • Time Heals (Most) Wrists: Both DASH and PRWE scores showed significant improvement from 3 to 6 months and from 6 to 12 months, indicating a continuous recovery process. This suggests that even if initial healing isn't perfect radiographically, functional gains continue for at least a year.
  • Non-Operative Treatment Efficacy: The study reinforces that closed reduction and casting can yield good to excellent functional outcomes for many distal radius fractures, even in patients with higher functional demands.
  • Dominant Hand Involvement: A higher incidence of fractures in the dominant hand was observed, which the authors attribute to the natural protective reflex of extending the dominant hand during a fall.

Key Results

  • A total of 146 patients were included in the study.
  • Functional Outcome Grading: 67.2% of patients achieved an "Excellent" functional outcome, 16% "Good," 15% "Fair," and 3% "Poor."
  • DASH Score Improvement: Mean DASH scores significantly decreased over time: 36.10±16.2 at 3 months, 17.71±11.8 at 6 months, and 8.88±16.2 at 12 months. All pairwise comparisons between these time points were statistically significant (p < 0.021).
  • PRWE Score Improvement: Mean PRWE scores also showed significant improvement: 23.21±23.1 at 3 months, 15.03±32.1 at 6 months, and 5.11±43.1 at 12 months. All pairwise comparisons were statistically significant (p < 0.011).
  • Mechanism of Injury: High-velocity injuries (69.8%) were more common than trivial falls at home (30.2%).
  • Sex Distribution: Males (87) were more frequently affected than females (59), which the authors link to occupational risks.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Missing Data: A significant limitation is the incomplete follow-up data. While 146 patients were initially enrolled, only 107 completed the 12-month follow-up. This missing data could potentially bias the results.
  • Sample Size for Significance: The authors acknowledge that a larger sample size might be needed to achieve statistical significance for certain observed effects, particularly when correlating perceived deformity with functional outcomes.
  • Radiographic vs. Functional Correlation: The study explicitly states that the functional outcome was found to be "not in correlation with radiological outcome," suggesting that radiological parameters alone may not be the most appropriate measure of patient success.
  • Future Work: The authors imply that further research with larger sample sizes and more robust follow-up protocols could further elucidate the complex interplay between radiographic findings and functional recovery. They also suggest that the focus should remain on patient-reported outcomes as the primary measure of treatment success.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: This study was conducted to determine whether radiological parameters correlate with functional outcome in patients with a fracture of the distal radius managed by closed reduction and pop cast application. Methods: This prospective study included all trauma cases which were presented to the Maharishi Markandeshwar institute of medical sciences and research, Mullana, Ambala, Haryana over a one year period. Radiographs in postero-anterior (PA), lateral views were used to visualise a suspected fracture of the distal radius. The information were recorded on an electronic spreadsheet. Cases were excluded if they did not meet the definition our inclusion and exclusion criteria. Patients were managed with above elbow pop cast for 3 weeks and further below elbow cast for 2-3 weeks. Mobilization was started after confirming clinic radiological union. Radiographs were taken at 3 months, 6 months and 12 months duration post reduction. Functional outcome was measured using Disability of Arm, Shoulder and Hand questioner score (DASH score) and patient rated wrist evaluation (PRWE). Results: A total of 146 patients were included. In our study we got 67.2% Excellent, 16% good, 15% fair and 3% poor results. In this study we analyzed PRWE score after 3 months, 6 months and 12 months for function outcomes. The mean difference of PRWE score between after three months (23.21±23.1) and after six months (15.03±32.1) the p value was 0.001, which was significant. The mean difference of PRWE score between after 6 months (15.03±32.1) and 12 months (5.11±43.1) the p value was 0.011, which was significant. The mean difference of PRWE score between after three months (23.21±23.1) and 12 months (5.11±43.1) p value was
BibTeX
@article{aggarwal2024correlation,
  author = {Nipun Aggarwal and Jashandeep Singh Chahal and Pravendra Singh and Shristi Singh},
  title = {{Correlation between radiographic and functional outcome of distal radius fracture managed by closed reduction and plaster of Paris cast application: A prospective study}},
  journal = {International Journal of Orthopaedics Sciences},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.22271/ortho.2024.v10.i3a.3577},
}
Figure