Correlation between plastic rearrangements and local structure in a cyclically driven glass

Saheli Mitra, Susana Marín-Aguilar, Srikanth Sastry, Frank Smallenburg, Giuseppe FoffiThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The correlation between local structure and the propensity for structural rearrangements has been widely investigated in glass-forming liquids and glasses. In this paper, we use the excess two-body entropy $S_2$ and tetrahedrality $n_{tet}$ as per-particle local structural order parameters to explore such correlations in a three-dimensional model glass subjected to cyclic shear deformation. We first show that for both liquid configurations and the corresponding inherent structures, local ordering increases upon lowering temperature, signaled by a decrease in the two-body entropy and an increase in tetrahedrality. When the inherent structures, or glasses, are periodically sheared athermally, they eventually reach absorbing states for small shear amplitudes, which do not change from one cycle to the next. Large strain amplitudes result in the formation of shear bands, within which particle motion is diffusive. We show that in the steady state, there is a clear difference in the local structural environment of particles that will be part of plastic rearrangements during the next shear cycle and that of particles that are immobile. In particular, particles with higher $S_2$ and lower $n_{tet}$ are more likely to go through rearrangements irrespective of the average energies of the configurations and strain amplitude. For high shear, we find very distinctive local order outside the mobile shear band region, where almost 30% of the particles are involved in icosahedral clusters, contrasting strongly with the fraction of <5% found inside the shear band.

Introduction

Unlike crystalline solids, where defects like dislocations clearly mark where deformation will occur, glasses are structurally disordered. Identifying the "soft spots"—regions susceptible to plastic rearrangement—is a major challenge in condensed matter physics. While previous work has linked dynamics to local structure in cooling liquids, this study investigates whether structural markers can predict rearrangements in a cyclically driven glass (a glass subjected to repeated back-and-forth shearing). The goal is to determine if specific local arrangements of particles make them more or less likely to move when the material is stressed.

Methods

The researchers employed a 3D computational model known as the Wahnström (WH) model, a 50:50 binary mixture of $N = 64,000$ particles. Systems were equilibrated at temperatures ranging from $T = 0.7$ to $2.0$ before being quenched to their "inherent structures" (local energy minima) for shearing.

Schematic of the cyclic deformation process and the corresponding energy landscape minimization.

To simulate deformation at absolute zero, Athermal Quasi-Static (AQS) Shear was used. In this method, the system is sheared in tiny steps, with energy minimization performed after each step to find the new local minimum. Several key structural descriptors were tracked:

  • Excess Two-Body Entropy ($S_2$): A measure of radial ordering; more negative values indicate higher local order.
  • Tetrahedrality ($n_{tet}$): The number of tetrahedral clusters a particle is involved in. Higher values indicate more compact, locally favored structures.
  • Topological Cluster Classification (TCC): An algorithm used to identify specific geometric motifs, such as icosahedra (13-particle clusters).
  • Non-Affine Displacement ($D^2_{min}$): A metric used to distinguish "mobile" particles (those that rearrange) from "immobile" ones during a shear cycle.

Key Results and Discussion

The study reveals a clear "structural fingerprint" for stability. Particles with high $S_2$ (low radial order) and low $n_{tet}$ (few tetrahedra) are significantly more prone to plastic rearrangements. Conversely, immobile particles are frequently found at the center of icosahedral clusters ($n_{tet} \approx 20$), which act as a "geometrical shield" preventing easy rearrangement.

Comparison of local structural parameters ($S_2$ and $n_{tet}$) for mobile and immobile particles across different strain amplitudes.

A sharp yielding transition occurs at a strain amplitude of $\gamma_{max} \approx 0.06$. Below this threshold, cyclic shearing helps the glass "anneal" into more ordered, lower-energy states. Above it, the system forms shear bands—localized regions where the structure breaks down and particles move diffusively. The glass also retains a "memory" of its liquid-state ordering; at low temperatures ($T=0.7$), the correlation between liquid and glass structures reaches approximately 0.6. In high-strain steady states, a striking dichotomy emerges: outside the shear band, nearly 30% of particles are part of icosahedral clusters, whereas inside the band, this fraction drops to less than 5%.

Conclusion

The findings demonstrate that "soft spots" in glasses are deeply encoded in their local geometry. While the specific role of tetrahedrality is unique to 3D systems and the Wahnström model's tendency toward icosahedral ordering, the methodology provides a robust framework for predicting plastic deformation. Future work could involve using these structural descriptors as inputs for machine learning models to improve the spatial prediction of failure in more complex, multi-component industrial glasses.

Summary updated

Abstract

The correlation between the local structure and the propensity for structural rearrangements has been widely investigated in glass forming liquids and glasses. In this paper, we use the excess two-body entropy S<sub>2</sub> and tetrahedrality n<sub>tet</sub> as the per-particle local structural order parameters to explore such correlations in a three-dimensional model glass subjected to cyclic shear deformation. We first show that for both liquid configurations and the corresponding inherent structures, local ordering increases upon lowering temperature, signaled by a decrease in the two-body entropy and an increase in tetrahedrality. When the inherent structures, or glasses, are periodically sheared athermally, they eventually reach absorbing states for small shear amplitudes, which do not change from one cycle to the next. Large strain amplitudes result in the formation of shear bands, within which particle motion is diffusive. We show that in the steady state, there is a clear difference in the local structural environment of particles that will be part of plastic rearrangements during the next shear cycle and that of particles that are immobile. In particular, particles with higher S<sub>2</sub> and lower n<sub>tet</sub> are more likely to go through rearrangements irrespective of the average energies of the configurations and strain amplitude. For high shear, we find very distinctive local order outside the mobile shear band region, where almost 30% of the particles are involved in icosahedral clusters, contrasting strongly with the fraction of <5% found inside the shear band.
BibTeX
@article{mitra2022correlation,
  author = {Saheli Mitra and Susana Marín-Aguilar and Srikanth Sastry and Frank Smallenburg and Giuseppe Foffi},
  title = {{Correlation between plastic rearrangements and local structure in a cyclically driven glass}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1063/5.0077851},
}
Figure